Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Offensive realism is empirically disproven — WW2 transition from Britain to the US.

Jeremy Garlick 16, Director of the J. Masaryk Centre of International Studies and Associate Professor of International Relations and China Studies at Prague University of Economics and Business, 2016, “Not So Simple: Complexity Theory and the rise of China,” SAGE Publications, DOI: 10.1177/0009445516661884 [ML]

John Mearsheimer’s offensive realism, derived from the same structural principles as Waltz’s ‘defensive’ realism, states unequivocally that a rising power will always challenge a hegemon militarily, an outcome he designates ‘the tragedy of great power politics’ (Mearsheimer 2001). Mearsheimer, thus, consistently and confidently predicts that a rising China will inevitably clash with the USA (Mearsheimer 2006, 2010). Mearsheimer’s hard-and-fast prediction of war between USA and its challenger China gives offensive realism a clear edge over neorealism and constructivism in terms of theoretical falsifiability. Eventually, such a war will either occur or it will not. If global leadership passes from USA to China with or without military confrontation at some point in the 21st century, then Mearsheimer will be proved right or wrong: it is simply a matter of waiting to see. However, Buzan and Cox (2013) point out that there is already one historical case of peaceful power handover that casts doubt upon Mearsheimer’s hypothesis: the transition without military confrontation from British to USA world hegemony in the aftermath of the Second World War. This, they suggest, invalidates Mearsheimer’s assertion of the inevitability of a US–China war, and thus also upon offensive realism’s main tenet. Even if historically the majority of rising powers have challenged hegemons militarily, one exception is sufficient to negate the theory’s predictive power, and to suggest that a peaceful power transition is possible. Mearsheimer also does not expound upon non-militaristic aspects of China’s rise (such as economics and soft power), but focuses exclusively on security issues (see Mearsheimer 2010). So, like neorealism and constructivism, offensive realism emphasises one aspect of China’s rise to the exclusion of all others and thus offers a clear, parsimonious, but not a complete theoretical picture.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.