Every IR grand theory lacks explanatory power — insufficient structural factors.
Tuomas Forsberg 21, Professor of International Politics at the University of Tampere and Deputy Director of the Centre of Excellence on Choices of Russian Modernization at the Aleksanteri Institute of the University of Helsinki; Christer Pursiainen is Professor of Societal Safety and Environment at the Department of Engineering and Safety, Faculty of Science and Technology, Arctic University of Norway, 2021, “The Psychology of Foreign Policy,” Palgrave Studies in Political Psychology, https://link.springer.com/book/10.1007/978-3-030-79887-1 [ML]
We hold that while power relations, societal and cultural norms and identities, or domestic systems and politics, cannot be overlooked as structural conditions or causal factors, in the case of most important foreign policy decisions, this will not suffice. Such structural factors or variables provide the necessary but not sufficient conditions for something to happen. Left alone, as structures without agency, they are nothing more than a frame for various non-predictable actions, some of which may blow back at these structures and modify them. Indeed, a good test case for the predictive and explanatory power of IR grand theories is the aforementioned Russian behavior in respect of the Crimean crisis in 2014. In a poll conducted among 905 American researchers about a week before Russia invaded Crimea (only) 14% of those interviewed responded affirmatively to a question on whether Russia would interfere militarily in Ukrainian affairs. No major differences between the schools—such as realist, constructivist, or liberal—could be detected, although area studies (in-depth knowledge of Russia and the post-Soviet area) performed somewhat better (Maliniak et al., 2014; Voeten, 2014). The striking fact remains that a couple of days prior to the invasion, all IR grand theories failed to anticipate Russia’s behavior on the basis of their respective and rather stable structurally oriented explanatory models, but their advocates still rushed to provide their expected singlefactor explanations of the case right after it materialized (McFaul et al., 2014). This reminds us that concepts such as power, identity, regime type or domestic political determinants are so vague that one can always use them to retrospectively explain an event that was regarded as unlikely beforehand on the basis of the self-same concepts (Forsberg & Pursiainen, 2017). The structural factors, or the dynamics of the agent-structure relationship, are hence not sufficient to fully explain or understand a foreign policy decision, and we may need to consider the psychological factors involved in such a situation. Without understanding the psychological dimension of the main decision-maker(s), namely the notion that beliefs, cognitive biases, personality, and interpersonal relations may play a role, we are not really able to explain some aspects of any decisions. This is not a revolutionary conclusion, but suffices to raise the question of when and how psychology matters. While psychology is always present in human decision-making, some decisions are rather clear-cut from the explicitly pronounced psychological perspective and others more complex. In some cases, psychological factors matter more than in others. We can regard it as an empirical issue when it comes to how much they matter in comparison with a particular baseline. It is one thing to argue that there are psychological mechanisms involved in decision-making and we need to study them, but quite another to say that they are the most important or decisive factors. Peter Hedström and Petri Ylikoski (2010, p. 60) argue that “only those aspects of cognition that are relevant for the explanatory task at hand should be included in the explanation, and the explanatory task thus determines how rich the psychological assumptions must be.” Although psychological mechanisms can only provide partial explanations, they can however sometimes make a crucial difference. Knowledge of rare or weak mechanisms still increases our understanding. When conducting research, we may gain more by revealing new or surprising explanatory mechanisms than proving that the most obvious explanation for an event or a pattern of behavior has something to do with it.