Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The alternative is to embrace a cosmopolitan ethic

Burke 2015 (Anthony Burke, Professor of Politics and International Relations at the University of New South Wales, “Security cosmopolitanism: the next phase”, https://doi.org/10.1080/21624887.2015.1065109) //sethlee

Hence, I disagree with Robinson that we can jettison moral principles or rules entirely in favour of ‘practices of responsibility that emerge in the thick context of sustained social interactions among moral subjects’ or, differently, in favour of what Arendt termed ‘thinking without a banister’, relying on ‘the silent dialogue between me and myself which, since Socrates and Plato, we usually call thinking’ (Arendt 2003, 45). To be sure, there is great value in cultivating practices of social and internal dialogue that resist the reduction of ethics to unthinking habits and procedures, or undemocratic structures of institutional command. However, such practices of responsibility need to be embedded in a deeper level of guidance and commitment, so that we know what ends we should seek, whose voices and interests matter, and what kind of world we ought to try to collectively create on the basis of what we take to exist there. Cosmopolitan calls to move beyond the nation-state, and posthuman calls to push beyond anthropocentrism, are precisely efforts to reshape that fundamental matrix for ethics and politics by expanding our understanding of what exists and matters. In the era of Fox News, Islamic, Christian, and market fundamentalism, anti-scientism, climate denial, and right-wing populism, we cannot rely on the iterative wisdom of social interaction by itself, because there are already background discourses working furiously to instantiate a crippled and divisive vision of common ends that are – quite literally – working to destroy our planet. In the space of international relations, cosmopolitan and posthuman perspectives are of enormous value because they are a metaphysical challenge to existing, architectonic visions of realist-cumliberal global order (Burke 2013b). Such visions of order already prescribe a moral and ethical system that has sunk deep roots in our social and political worlds. It seems selfdefeating to oppose the articulation of alternative visions because of an automatic (and historically warranted) poststructuralist suspicion of universalism. Vulnerable communities and ecologies need the protection of a just and responsive global order, yet many of my critics disdain even thinking on the plane of that order. In this light, cosmopolitanism and the categorical imperative of security have a crucial function that many of the commentaries fail to recognise. By universalising the right to security, by emphasising the determining demand of equality between all humans and the planetary ecology (indeed the moral priority of the ecologies in which humans are existentially embedded), the theory insists that it is no longer permissible to prioritise one state or group’s security over another, or humanity over nature. It is no longer permissible to license structures and responses that undermine fundamental rights or damage the security of others, including non-human others, in defense of the imagined self. The self is dispersed into the world, into the past and future, and our ethics must honour that. The ethics of security cosmopolitanism in fact encodes contestability and context, while setting up crucial boundaries and principles of balance. Principle 1 requires an ongoing and complex dialogue within and between governments, communities, groups, scientists, and policymakers over how to create systems that will preserve the planetary ecology and ‘protect the vital core of human lives in ways that enhance human fulfilment’ across multiple spheres of activity and risk (Burke 2013a, 21; quotations from CHS 2003). Groups may perceive ‘survival, livelihood and dignity’ in different ways; their voices must be heard and honoured, but it is when these differences generate threats to others or a clash over security needs, that dialogue, compromise, and active forms of ameliorative politics must come into play. This includes the discursive dimension: groups must be willing to redefine their understanding of security to take account of the security needs of others and the biosphere. Principles 2 and 3 similarly require dialogue and deliberation, but also science and expertise, because of the challenge of mapping potential futures, the technical complexity of many domains, and the profundity of the responsibility that these principles enact. As earth systems ecology and the nuclear space highlight, there is a challenging need to combine predictive scientific models, probabilistic reasoning, the precautionary principle, and public dialogue to consider potential futures and their associated responsibilities in the now. I regard these future-oriented principles to be the most significant part of the entire theory. Climate scientists and ecologists implicitly grasp their import: as the group that warned the world to restrict global warming to less than 1°C concluded, ‘continuation of high fossil fuel emissions, given current knowledge of the consequences, would be an act of extraordinary witting intergenerational injustice’ (Hansen et al. 2013, 1).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.