Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

We need to reread the world outside of NATO---it solves best

Giovanni Ercolani 11, “Keeping Security and Peace: Behind the Strategicalization of NATO’s “Critical Security Discourse””, Security Strategies Journal, Vol 7, Issue 14, Dec 2011, p76-80 \\pairie

Conclusion: We Have to Reinvent Ourselves I would like to conclude this paper by stating that the human species is living in a particular moment in which globalisation has made the world smaller and where not everybody is a NATO model reader. NATO readers should need to reinvent themselves and face the world outside their GPNF, and this is a discourse close to the concept of “emancipation” developed by Ken Booth.

“As discourse of politics, emancipation seeks the securing of people from those oppressions that stop them carrying out what they would freely choose to do, compatible with the freedom of others. It provides a three-fold framework for politics: a philosophical anchorage for knowledge, a theory of progress for society, and a practice of resistance against oppression. Emancipation is the philosophy, theory, and politics of inventing humanity” (Booth, 2007, p. 112).

Undoubtedly, the NATO Reader has to re-read the world because he can not pretend to live as an immortal human being in a NATO-kept castle and forget or ignore not only the two clocks but even the world outside it. The Alliance structure would really like that its clock could be as the one of Benjamin Button and run backwards into the time of its youth, and NATO definitely act as it will live “in aeternum”. And this is because, despite the NATO narrative, despite the fact that NATO is “the most successful alliance in human history” (Ash, 2011), outside the NATO GPNF-cave, and NATO lines other realities are taking shape.

1. Other countries like China (with a population of 1.5 billion) have produced their own concept of war. “Unrestricted Warfare” is a book on military strategy written in 1999 by two colonels in the People's Liberation Army, Qiao Liang and Wang Xiangsui. The book rather than focusing on direct military confrontation examines a variety of other means which can be summarized in the Formula: Schwartzkopf + Soros + Xiaomolisi + Bin Laden (Liang and Xiangsui, 1999).

2. At the G20 Seoul meeting (2010) even the map of the world financial crisis was changed. Despite the western countries depicted the financial crisis as a global one, its perception from other global actors and emerging economies was completely different. According to O'Neill (Goldman Sachs), policy makers in Asia were referring to the global credit crisis as the “North Atlantic Crisis” (BBC News, Today, 2010). Thus, and for the first time, the “others” defined our military alliance as a financial system.

3. When we look at the “Multiple Stress Zone” map presented by the NATO General Soligan in 2009, how can we not see that is the exact copy of Pentagon Map which was produced in the year 2004 (Barnett, 2004) to highlight the grand strategy for the American foreign policy? Furthermore, the Pentagon Map is much more than a simple cartographic representation of the planet, it is a division of the world countries between the Functioning Core, characterized by economic interdependence, and the Non-Integrated Gap, characterized by unstable leadership and absence from international trade. The Core can be sub-divided into Old Core (North America, Western Europe, Japan, Australia) and New Core (China, India). The Non-Integrated Gap includes the Middle East, South Asia (except India), most of Africa, Southeast Asia, and Northwest South America. Thus using a realist terminology the Functioning Core can represent the land of order while the Non-Integrated Gap the land of anarchy and disorder and also it can be seen as a tentative to “ethnicalize” the world (Aime, 2004, p. 73-100). And if what can happen in the Non-Integrated Gap can produce security concerns to the NATO countries (which are part of the Functioning Core) and justify a military intervention in their internal affairs then “fear is something that is actually missing in a situation of international anarchy, and because it is missing it must be invented and skilfully deployed” (Weber, 2005, p. 23).

4. World Population Growth Rate: “By 2003, the combined population of Europe, the United States, and Canada accounted for just 17 percent of the global population. In 2050, this figure is expected to be just 12 percent. (…) Today, roughly nine out of ten children under the age of 15 live in developing countries. (…) Indeed, over 70 percent of the world’s population growth between now and 2050 will take place in 24 countries, all of which are classified by the World Bank as low income or lower-middle income, with an average per capita income under $ 3,855 in 2008” (Goldstone, 2010 and Minois, 2011).

5. Consumption factor. We have already seen that the estimated one billion people who live in developed countries, which, coincidentally, is the same number of NATO people (the “our”), have a relative per capita consumption rate of 32, while the rest of the “others” (the 5.5 billion people that constitute the developing world, have relative per capita consumption rates below 32, mostly down toward 1). How will it be possible to “secure our future” and then maintain a consumption factor of 32 when the “others” will want to consume like us? “The World Bank has predicted that by 2030 the number of middle-class people in the developing world will be 1.2 billion (a rise of 200 percent since 2005). This means that the developing world’s middle class alone will be larger that the total populations of Europe, Japan, and the United States combined. From now on, therefore, the main driver of global economic expansion will be the economic growth of newly-industrialized countries, such as Brazil, China, India, Indonesia, Mexico, and Turkey” (Goldstone, 2010).

6. Life expectancy rate. Will the people living in the “multiple stress zone” (the non- integrated gap) accept their dramatic living conditions, and live less than the people living in other parts of the globe? Will they accept the status quo that has produced their misery or will they rebel? And the peace that NATO will impose on them will be a “positive peace” or a “negative peace” which will reproduce the same “structural violence” that provoked unrest and internal conflict, and not seeing instead the “civil war as a system” (Keen, 2009, p. 11-24)?

We should accept the reality and we should reinvent ourselves. And the first step to take will be to re-read the world out-side the NATO narrative because we have to be aware of the advice which one of the supposed fathers of Realism gave to the Prince: “Therefore it is unnecessary for a prince to have all the good qualities I have enumerated, but it is very necessary to appear to have them. (…) because the vulgar are always taken by what a thing seems to be and by what comes of it.”20 Then conscious that in front of us there is a narrative which “has to appear” we have to free ourselves and not act as the Pavlov’s dog but illuminated by the doubt in front a narrative which pretends to narrate the reality and re-read the world outside the NATO keep.

It is the gift of the doubt which, as the Italian writer Leonardo Sciascia wrote some years ago, distinguishes the intellectual from the charlatan. Because “in the historical and human history the truth can appear confused and the lie can assume the appearance of veracity” (Sciascia, 1963).

Then it is in the intellectual intention to emancipate the reader from a well-defined image-interpretation of a supposed reality that the “security analyst needs to engage as a political philosopher. This is because the value of security is in constant tension and interdependence with other values, most prominent of which are the values of freedom, prosperity and justice” (Dannreuther, 2007, p. 8).

Thus emancipate the “homo videns”, who is entrapped in a NATO GPNF which reminds us of Plato’s Cave and means to give him back his capacity of abstraction and return to him his ability to think, and act autonomously and responsibly and not as a proficient apparatus. And instead of “securing our future” in which “our” means the NATO people, replace it with “we”, the international society, because we have to accept that in this earthly life there are two clocks and the evolution of the human being has to be continuous. We are responsible for the coming generation to which country, race, religion, and the like belong because “we” are all human beings, all “Homines sapientes”.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.