Security doesn’t explain how hegemons act- no root cause
Kaygusuz no date- (Özlem Kaygusuz- assistant professor at Mersin University, “SECURITIZATION IN THE CONTEXT OF GLOBAL HEGEMONY: US-TURKISH RELATIONS IN PERSPECTIVE” Mersin University-Department of International Relations, https://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/download?doi=10.1.1.408.7396&rep=rep1&type=pdf)//mishelle
There is one important point, however that should be underlined here. The emphasis on the cognitive element as a common ground or a point of connection between hegemony as the structure and securitization as the medium, should not mean that the states’ behaviors are determined by structure of ideas as they are by material structure of the neorealist hegemony that is by coercive force (McSweeney, 1999: 132-33). The internalization of ideas, values, and the security truths by the actors is not a mechanistic process of acceptance. The actors participate into the construction and consolidation of security truths through their security practices, acts and decisions in the international field. In other words, the subordinated units under hegemony are not only consumers but also producers of securitization. In this study, the enrichment of the idea of securitization as a medium in the mutual constitution of hegemonic structure and agents is based particularly on Bill McSweeney’s study on security and identity which is developed on the basis of Giddens’s Structuration Theory. The Structuration Theory can be utilized also to analyze the social relations and the constitution of identities at the international level. According to the theory any social order, including the international order cannot be considered as an independent phenomenon, external to acting units within it. The structure and the agent are ontologically interdependent (McSweeney: 138-145). In such a framework, security identity at the state level cannot be viewed as a dependent variable with respect to hegemonic security structure and accordingly, securitization is not a one way process. Here, as McSweeney proposed, the concept of political spillover can be utilized to explain the harmonization of security interests produced intersubjectively in the international field (McSweeney, 1999: 170-171) Concerning the subject of this study, that is to establish a connection between securitization and functioning of hegemony, again an understanding of spillover can be used. As in the integration to a security community, the adherence to a hegemonic order also necessitates the shifting of loyalties, expectations and political activities toward a new security truth and the secondary states learn to identify their interests with the hegemon. Here, structure is used by actors to produce meanings of domestic conduct and in that moment, it is drawn into the temporal, contextual dimension of action, thus to be reinforced and modified by usage and repetition. In a sense, actors subject themselves to the constraints of behaving within the confines of habit. Actors learn and relearn their security interest in interaction with the sub-state level actors, with other states but mainly with and with the hegemon. Such a perspective towards securitization will provide us a richer conception of security and the functioning of hegemony. Giddens’s Structuration Theory puts forward that far from being passive receptors and reproducers of an assumed consensus about meaning and norms, actors draw strategically upon such consensus to establish an agreement or to repair a relationship, in short they manage the rules that make the game interaction possible. In the same way, under hegemony, the patterns of meaning about what is to be secured or the shared knowledge of what is the threat are reproduced through typified behaviors of state actors that simultaneously sustaining it.