Perm Do Both – Policy can utilize technology towards security concerns while maintaining cosmopolitan ethics
Schmidt 2022 (Nikola Schmidt, factuly at the institute of political science in Charles University, “Space Community as an Enabler of Cosmopolitan Ideas Through Large Technical Systems” https://www.researchgate.net/profile/Nikola-Schmidt-3/publication/359408196_Space_Community_as_an_Enabler_of_Cosmopolitan_Ideas_Through_Large_Technical_Systems/links/623da8802d8ea42c14a42b48/Space-Community-as-an-Enabler-of-Cosmopolitan-Ideas-Through-Large-Technical-Systems.pdf) //sethlee
The traditional approach to socio-technical interactions is anchored in post-WW2 technological determinism. While positive technological determinism entails a conviction that technology can solve many social problems and bring good to society, negative technological determinism understands the role of technology in a society in the exactly opposite way [77]. However, the argument that technology impacts the way we live is undisputable, as current studies within the sociology of technology focus mainly on perspectives on how to study that relation in terms of evolution or dissolution of LTS and how they influence sociotechnical change [78]. We argued previously “that large technical systems have constitutive power to shape global governance system, because of their mere existence. This can be turned to humanity’s advantage if we develop a normative framework for them, before they influence our lives in an undesirable way” [74]. Each technology not only has potential to influence the way we live, but is designed to do so. A well-considered normative framework is the way to ensure that such positive potential is realized in society. The normative framework should be read as a desirable direction, desirable design of intended technological use, or desirable state of the future in general. This dynamic is even more interesting in an age in which states are continuously unable to govern technological inventions [79]. Nation states were crucial in shaping undertakings such as the Manhattan Project, CERN, and ISS. All these ideas would have never materialized without a direct political interest and direct investment by the government that had some larger picture of the future behind its rationalization; however, today’s technological inventions, and even the development of LTS, influencing the way we live are in the hands of private persons (Facebook). What the nation states could do is to encourage scientists and engineers towards certain unanswered questions, which is actually done through financial instruments of research projects, or draw more specific contours of long-term projects and include cosmopolitan ethics, as the political explanation of why it is worth pursuing. Cosmopolitan ethics should play a role in shaping policy intentions before creating LTS, which could influence how engineers and scientists approach their task to build LTS and how politicians understand their role in keeping the project in line with possible national security concerns. In other terms, the design of the project should have practical objective-solving problems (debris, asteroids, propulsion) but also a normative objective to enable responsible cosmopolitan politics. In our understanding of pragmatism as (re)introduced by Jonna Nyman reflecting both is the pragmatic approach to practical politics. One single example of such a policy approach is CERN. Scientists wanted a particle accelerator that did not exist at that time, while politicians wanted a united Europe around civilian nuclear physics research [80]. CERN was unique due to the historical circumstances. ITER is unique due to very specific research that is not affordable by a single global actor, and as a research project it will last almost or even more than a hundred years from the first ideas to the development of tokamak that would test all the technologies. The result will be a developed high-end international science in fusion physics with practical impact on humanity in general – electricity from a fusion reactor. Fusion reactors can be key to climate change, they will enable completely new possibilities in space, and the whole scientific megaproject already united countries around a critical scientific task. Striving for such global cooperation should be a central interest of any responsible cosmopolitan state – it is practical, nurtures international security, unites humanity, and yields breakthrough scientific discoveries solving key problems on the planet.