Discourse cannot explain sensory experience.
Dave Elder-Vass 12, a senior lecturer in sociology at Loughborough University. He is the author of The Causal Power of Social Structures (Cambridge University Press, 2010), 2012, “The Reality of Social Construction,” Cambridge University Press, https://libgen.is/book/index.php?md5=4F125B95651CDBF9BB8A28354A03797E [ML]
At one level, Edwards et al. are right. Realists cannot prove there is a world beyond discourse if by prove we mean ‘demonstrate with absolute certainty’ as analytical philosophers have traditionally demanded. No one can absolutely prove, for example, that the world is not a figment of the imagination of some disembodied consciousness (that would have to be my consciousness of course, not yours, since I know that I can imagine the world!) But there would be something rather ironic about a group of self-proclaimed relativists who disown notions of absolute truth demanding that other people’s claims can only be justified by that standard. Nor does the argument work as an immanent critique of critical realists, as it might if we were ourselves committed to such a standard, because critical realists insist on the fallibility of all knowledge claims: the possibility that they might be wrong (e.g. Bhaskar 1986: 15). What we claim is that it is so overwhelmingly likely that the world ‘out there’ exists that we can take this as a firm working assumption. As Bruno Latour, a very different kind of realist, has said: “why burden this solitary mind with the impossible task of finding absolute certainty instead of plugging it into the connections that would provide it with all the relative certainties it needed to know and to act?” (1999: 12). To come to this conclusion, however, we must question the assertion that our only access to reality is through discourse. Banging on a table, for example, may well be an act that is given discursive employment, but it is not only a discursive act. The person striking the table feels its resistance, its solidity, and those present hear the thump. Although our ability to label or interpret that solidity or that noise as such depends on the possession of language and a personal history of discursive interaction, there is nevertheless a sensory experience that also occurs. If the realist were to try to bang on an illusion of a table, no such solidity would be experienced, and no such noise would occur to demonstrate the point.5 It is only because humans have some access to a sensory experience of reality that we can make the realists’ point by banging on a table, although making that point also requires a shared linguistic and discursive environment. And of course, we can move one step further away from the discursive case, as Harry Collins does, for example, when he discusses the case of stumbling accidentally against a rock. When such events occur, the experience of the rock’s solidity is not a discursive act at all, yet it is a sensory experience that gives us good evidence for the belief that there is a real material world in which we move. Edwards, Ashmore, and Potter reject such claims on the grounds that in making the claim we switch between the stumbling event to a discursive account (1995: 30). But this response is viable only if we accept the constructionist argument that language cannot refer beyond itself. This argument was criticised in Chapters 5 and 7, and also by John O’Neill in his reply to these authors: “That the argument is in language doesn’t entail that it is ‘trapped’ in language” (1995: 101). Furthermore (and this is a point to which I shall return in discussing neo-Kantianism), our conversations, our speech acts, our rhetoric themselves depend on such sensory experience. Speaking is transmitted as sound waves through the air; journal articles like ‘Death and Furniture’ only succeed in communicating to us if we can sense them as patterns on pieces of paper or computer screens (whether as patterns of black and white, or as raised marks). While it is not true that we can experience the material world only through discourse, it is the case that we can experience discourse only through the material world!