Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

If our impacts are true, Securitization is justified

Floyd 2019 (Rita Floyd, Security Studies at the University of Birmingham, “The Morality of Security” https://doi.org/10.1017/9781108667814.010) //sethlee

In the process I have set forth eight principles determining just securitization. These principles are supposed to hold regardless of the origin of the threat, the nature of the referent object (i.e. the entity threatened and to be made safe by securitization) and the provider of security. In more detail I have argued that securitization is morally permissible only in the presence of a just cause which in turn is made up of an objective existential threat to a just referent object of security. Referent objects are just provided they satisfy basic human needs, specifically autonomy and physical health. I further insisted on a sincerity of intention condition, whereby the right intention for securitization is the just cause. Just initiation of securitization was complemented by a criterion specifying macroproportionality, which held that the expected good gained from securitization must be judged greater than expected harm from securitization. I further specified that just securitization needs to take account of the probable consequences of treating an issue in security mode. Specifically, securitization has to have a reasonable (i.e. greater than that of nonsecuritization alternatives) chance of succeeding in achieving the just cause. The second of the two research questions was discussed as part of the development of the principles designating just conduct during securitization. I argued that the security measures used must be appropriate for dealing with the threat in question, and not serve some ulterior motive. A second criterion was concerned with reducing harm as much as possible; I argued that while the nature of the security measures differs according to the source of the threat, as well as the nature of the referent object, securitizing actors must consider the harm caused by the measures, and aim to choose the least overall harmful option available. In addition, I argued that securitization is unjust if the measures used are more harmful to the referent object than the threat they seek to solve. A third and final criterion specified just conduct of executors of securitization, including security professionals. I argued that although securitization necessarily involves the infringement of some human rights, executors of securitization should when they – as part of securitization – harm people be appropriately constraint those people’s rights to life, freedom from torture and arbitrary detention. Like recent versions of the just war theory, JST goes beyond theorizing simply the moral permissibility of securitization. Instead, it also considers the issue of just termination of securitization. In JST, desecuritization is conceptualized as a process (not an outcome) that occurs (in time) after securitization. This has meant that unlike securitization, which in JST remains a political choice decided by securitizing actors, not scholars, desecuritization is obligatory for actors who are remedially responsible for unmaking the preceding securitization, either on the basis of outcome responsibility or by connection. Although securitization and desecuritization are then interrelated processes, in JST the justice of one is judged independently of the justice of the other. In other words, an unjust desecuritization does not render a just securitization unjust and vice versa. JST specifies three principles of just desecuritization, concerning 1) the timing when desecuritization must ensue (notably, I have argued that a securitization can remain just only for as long as there is a just cause); 2) the dismantling of the security measures taken, as well as the reversal of security language; and 3) a series of restorative measures aimed at reducing the possibility of renewed and/or reactionary securitization. In addition to providing criteria determining the justice of securitization and desecuritization, the wider research argument also revealed a number of difficult issues such as that of the moral culpability of executors of securitization who have followed the rules of just securitization, but who have acted in securitizations that were unjustly initiated (Chapter 6, section 6.6). Or the question of whether just desecuritizing actors who played no part in securitization have fewer restorative responsibilities than desecuritizing actors culpable of unjust preceding securitization (Chapter 7, section 7.9), or the issue of whether securitization and a relevant counter-securitization can be just at the same time (Chapter 6, section 6.7). I have in this book advanced answers to these and other difficult questions, but I recognize that more can and needs to be said on all of them, as well as on all of the substantive principles advanced. Beyond contributing to security studies, this book also contributes to the just war tradition. This is especially the case because some just war theorists are increasingly interested in wars that do not involve kinetic force, and as such, phenomena that may be called securitization. By thinking about what the just war tradition’s criteria mean for securitization, JST speaks to just war theorists interested in these softer versions of war. I have mentioned on more than one occasion on the preceding pages that the argument is conceived as very much a first word on just securitization. I hope that other scholars will devise theories of just securitization of their own volition. This is important because I believe that research on the principles of just securitization has more than just the potential to impact positively on the scholarly study of security and/or on the decisions and actions of practitioners. Beyond that it could – provided the idea of just securitization becomes widely known, which, in turn, is likely to happen only if just securitization becomes a research area in its own right – equip the public with tools to question the ethics of the decision to securitize including the security measures used and thus hold security practitioners accountable. In other words, the long-desired (in some parts of critical security studies) goal of emancipation can quite conceivably be achieved through just securitization. The room for competing theories of just securitization is vast. One reason for this is that my interpretation of securitization is only one among many possible interpretations of the concept. For example, a theory of just securitization that theorizes securitization as an intersubjective process and focuses on audience acceptance of the speech act as pivotal would look quite different to the principles proposed as part of JST. Among other things, such a theory of just securitization would have to focus on ethical language, that is, on what kind of things securitizing actors are allowed to utter when it comes to securitizing speech acts, while they would also have to focus on what kind of audiences make ideal ethical adjudicators of the speech act and other new issues besides. Another reason for the open-endedness of just securitization research is that JST focuses only on the circumstances when securitization is morally permissible, when it is equally valid and important to ask: when, if ever, is securitization morally required? A theory of just securitization that prioritizes the obligation to securitize is bound to be quite different from JST. Unlike JST, its objective would not be to reduce the number of securitizations in the world, but to use the mobilization power inherent to securitization to achieve security as a state of being. With this in mind, potential advocates of such a theory might utilize a scalar as opposed to a categorical approach to principles of just securitization (e.g. one where not all principles advanced as part of such a theory have to be met all of the time), largely to facilitate the ease with which securitization can take place. Theories of just securitization that focus on moral obligation could differ widely from one another depending on whether their proponents broadly concurred with cosmopolitan/global or communitarian/statist ethics. Moreover, theories of just securitization could also derive their inspiration from virtue ethics, and, for example, devise principles that determine what makes for a virtuous securitizing actor. Theories of just securitization could supposedly also take a permissive view of the justice of securitization and seek to develop principles that specify the circumstances when securitization is forbidden. In future, just securitization research also needs to engage with the issue of what can reasonably be expected of security practitioners when it comes to the issue of ethics and security.1 These concluding remarks show that there is huge potential for research in the area of just securitization. In fact the diversity and thus potential for just securitization research is such that it could become a meta-theoretical framework organizing thinking on ethics and security in general, in the same way as thinking about the morality of war is systematized by the just war tradition. Whatever happens in terms of just securitization research from here on in, this book has shown not only that questions concerning the morality of security ought to be taken seriously by anyone interested in the study and/or practice of security but also that clear and systematic answers are possible.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.