Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Security Discourse within the debate space does shape reality, but also shapes specific policy solutions which are critical to decision making.

Kronfeld 2018 (Melissa Jane Kronfeld, PhD Candidate at Rutgers University in Global Affairs, “The Construction and Prioritization of Threats in the Post-Cold War Era and the Evolution of American National Security Policy”, https://rucore.libraries.rutgers.edu/rutgers-lib/57350/PDF/1/play/) //sethlee

A crisis is defined as an unstable or crucial time period, or state of affairs, in which a decisive change is impending, or a time when a difficult or important decision must be made. Discourse is defined, in its most basic form, as a written or spoken form of communication. In the context of culture, discourse is defined as a mode of organizing knowledge, ideas, or experience that is rooted in language and its concrete contexts. Balzacq notes that using discourse, or discursive action is, “compelling power to cause a receiver or the audience to perform a deed.” He adds, “through mutual knowledge, discourse shapes social relations and builds their form and content… [and] on the causative sides, as vehicle of ideas, discourse targets and creates the instantiation of a particular communicative action. For the purposes of this research, crisis discourse is defined by the rhetorical practices employed in order to construct threats as clear and present, and requiring immediate action or resolution. In the tradition of frame analysis, advanced by David Snow and Robert Benford, or in the tradition of William Sewell’s “schemas” and Swidler’s “tool kit”, crisis discourse provides the behavioral rules and linguistic structure, as well as the repertoire of social and political practices that enables an agent or actor to act upon structures to manifest transformation. Borrowing from Snow et al. and Goffman, I define a frame as a, “‘schemata of interpretation’ that enable individuals to ‘locate, perceive, identify, and label’ occurrences within their life space and the world at large. By rending events or occurrences meaningful, frames function to organize experience and guide action.” Robert Entman adds that framing denotes the selection or emphasis on, “some facets of events or issues and making connections among them so as to promote a particular interpretation, evaluation and/or solution.” It is therefore necessary for prioritization. I define crisis discourse as characterized by 1) the identification of a threat as a hazard to the current state of affairs, or existence of a group of individuals (i.e. community, state, or way of life); 2) constructing a threat as the cause, or existing as a critical part, of a given situation in which change is impending and will significantly impact the future course of events; and 3) the framing of a solution(s) in response to the threat, as a byproduct of the identification and construction of the threat. This is particularly important when threats are clear or present because, Daniel Kahneman and Jonathan Renshon note, hawkish biases are more persuasive where conflict is, or perceived as being, more likely. Crisis discourse is critical because political culture, and its effects on institutional decision making, are best exemplified by the discourse used to frame a threat. As Deva Woodly notes, “communication matters, because changing public discourse, changes power relations, and altered power relations change politics – the principles and policy that are at stake in the struggle over who shall govern and how.” She add the “critical battleground” for change is political discourse, where “political issues take on popular meaning and affect the common-sense understanding.” Discourse can, “advance particular interests [and] to actually change politics itself, rewriting the common understandings present in the discursive field upon which political possibilities are considered and wherein binding decision are made.” As Holland notes, “9/11 generated a discursive void as the events could not be subsumed into existing foreign policy discourse. However, 9/11, in and of itself, was not a crisis. Initially unregulated but discourse, the ‘events’ did not mean anything for certain. Instead 9/11 became a crisis through a process of discursive construction, which reinstated ‘politics’ over ‘the political.’ Crises… are constructed.”

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.