Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Securitization is morally permissible if the threat is objectively existential --- proven by justified responses to white supremacy’s existential risk

Jessica Wolfendale 22, professor of Philosophy at Marquette University, 03/08/2022, “White Supremacy as an Existential Threat: A Response to Rita Floyd’s The Morality of Security: A Theory of Just Securitization”, European Journal of International Security /lg

Rita Floyd’s The Morality of Security: A Theory of Just Securitization is an important and insightful book that delineates a theory of just securitisation (modified from the jus ad bellum and jus in bello criteria in just war theory) involving three sets of principles governing the just initiation of securitisation, just conduct of securitisation, and just desecuritisation. This book is a much needed addition to the security studies and just war scholarship. 

Here, I explore the potential of Floyd’s just securitisation theory (JST) to provide insights into the moral justifiability of non-state groups that are not political entities engaging in resistance against forms of structural violence that pose an existential threat to those groups. Using the case study of the Black Lives Matter (BLM) movement and the threat of white supremacy to African Americans as an illustrative example, I argue that structural forms of violence can meet Floyd’s definition of an objective existential threat, justifying the resort to securitisation by groups such as BLM. As Floyd writes in chapter 5: 

non-state actors are permitted to [securitize issues normally under the state’s jurisdiction], and thus effectively defy the state, when states fail to do their duty to protect against an objective existential threat … this allows non-state actors to securitize against those unjust regimes that pose objective existential threats to non-state groups within states.38 

In section 1, I argue that Floyd’s analysis of non-state groups leaves open the possibility that loosely organised protest groups such as BLM may constitute a non-state group for the purposes of applying Floyd’s just securitisation framework. In section 2, I argue that white supremacy poses an objective existential threat to African Americans, meeting the criterion of just cause in Floyd’s JST. The multilayered ways in which white supremacy creates an objective existential threat to African Americans illustrates the potential of Floyd’s conception of an objective existential threat to offer insights into the impact of other forms of structural violence, such as entrenched sexism. In section 3, I show that, despite the gains of the civil rights movement, the threat of white supremacy has not been curtailed through legal reform or by democratic means. Thus, groups like BLM may be justified in resorting to extraordinary measures to combat the ongoing threat of white supremacy, including ‘whatever most reasonable persons would agree constitutes exceptional means and actions … non-state securitization can take the form of secession, civil disobedience, acts of sabotage and resistance.’ 39 Applying Floyd’s JST to the threat of white supremacy thereby demonstrates the value of her approach for thinking about securitisation outside the traditional foci of security studies but, as I discuss in section 3, also reveals some limitations in her theory, particularly in relation to the criterion of reasonable chance of success when applied to non-state groups resisting an unjust state.

Does Black Lives Matter constitute a non-state group?

Floyd does not explicitly define the kinds of non-state groups that could, in principle, engage in securitisation. On p. 61 she writes that, according to Copenhagen School, ‘sufficiently organized societal groupings united by a strong enough “‘we’ identity” … can revert to a course of conduct that can only be described as securitization’. The Copenhagen School included ‘nations, religion and racial groups’ 40 in ‘societal groupings’. However, in a footnote, Floyd notes that many security scholars now hold that ‘other − smaller − non-state securitizing actors than those who can cement a large enough we-feeling are now a possibility’, 41 suggesting that a shared identity is not required in order for a non-state actor to engage in securitisation. But it appears that Floyd agrees with the Copenhagen School that non-state groups need to be ‘sufficiently organized’ to engage in securitisation, although she does not define this term. 

In her book, Floyd discusses organised and relatively small groups such as the Sea Shepherd Conservation Society and Arizona Border Recon,42 but does not discuss broad protest movements such as BLM. That said, there are two reasons to think that BLM can fit her conception of a nonstate group. Firstly, while some might object that the Black Lives Matter movement does not have legitimate or representative authority to engage in securitisation on behalf of African Americans, Floyd explicitly rejects the criterion of representative authority in her theory of just securitisation,43 and so BLM does not need to claim to represent (or be viewed as representing) the interests of all African Americans in order for it to constitute a non-state group for the purposes of applying her framework.44 Secondly, while BLM is diverse in its strategies and has a loose organisational structure, it supports and facilitates organised action across the United States and elsewhere to protect the interests of African Americans. As the BLM website states: ‘Black Lives Matter Global Network Foundation, Inc. is a global organization in the US, UK, and Canada, whose mission is to eradicate white supremacy and build local power to intervene in violence inflicted on Black communities by the state and vigilantes.’ 45 These factors are sufficient, I argue, for BLM to constitute a non-state group for the purposes of evaluating the possibility of just securitisation.

2. Is white supremacy an existential threat to African Americans? 

In Floyd’s theory, just initiation of securitisation by a non-state group requires a just cause: ‘an objective existential threat to a referent object, that is to say a danger that – with a sufficiently high probability – threatens the survival or the essential character/properties of either a political or social order, an ecosystem, a non-human species, or individual.’ 46 Existential threats include ‘all those things that threaten basic human needs, which when met, enable humans to live minimally decent lives’. 47 Does white supremacy pose an existential threat to African Americans? 

The term ‘white supremacy’ does not simply refer to individuals’ racist beliefs. Rather, as Charles Mills explains, white supremacy ‘is a political system, a particular power structure of formal or informal rule, socioeconomic privilege, and norms for the differential distribution of material wealth and opportunities, benefits and burdens, rights and duties’. 48 In a system of white supremacy, whiteness confers social, material, and political advantages on white-identified people at the expense of the welfare and interests of non-white persons: ‘From slavery, federal land grants … through differential access to education, job opportunities, white markets, union membership, and equal wages and promotion chances to ghettoization, restrictive covenants, redlining, white flights, and differential allocation of resources to schools and neighborhoods, whites have historically been materially advantaged over nonwhites, particularly blacks.’ 49 

The concept of white supremacy thus captures the ways in which interconnected set of practices, norms, and institutions (social, legal, political) privilege white identity and negatively structure the lives of African Americans (and other people of colour) regardless of the specific intentions of the individuals involved. So defined, white supremacy is embedded within multiple formal and informal institutional and social structures that affect all aspects of life for African Americans, including (but not limited to) the education system, the criminal justice system, and the healthcare system.50 

But it is one thing to say that white supremacy systematically disadvantages African Americans; it is quite another to claim that it poses an existential threat to African Americans. Below, by applying Floyd’s threat categories to the examples of the criminal justice system and the healthcare system I show that white supremacy creates agent-intended threats (‘where an aggressor is at the source of the threat intent on harming’),51 agent-caused threats (where ‘an actor’s behaviour leads to a threat to someone else … without the actor intending to do harm’),52 and exacerbates the harm of agent-lacking threats (‘threats that occur irrespective of human agency’).53 The combined impact of these threats on the ability of African Americans to live minimally decent lives is, I argue, sufficient to meet the definition of an existential threat.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.