Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

UN’s identity as a political institution undermines effective cyber policy

Christopher Painter 21 — (Christopher Painter; President, The Global Forum on Cyber Expertise Foundation; Associate Fellow, Chatham House, Published: 12-18-2021; "The United Nations’ cyberstability processes: surprising progress but much left to do"; Taylor & Francis; Accessed: 7-20-2022; https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/23738871.2021.2014920)//Pen-SY

Despite the laudable, if somewhat unexpected, success of the OEWG and the GGE, a number of substantive and procedural issues remain unresolved. First, the path towards greater discussion, much less agreement, on how international law applies to cyberspace is unclear. Although the compendium of national views on the application of international law called for in the GGE is helpful, given the political sensitivities of this topic, further progress in the UN setting is unlikely in the near term. That is unfortunate as greater understanding and agreement on the application of international law can be beneficial to both restraining disruptive state conduct and accountability for transgressors. As more countries articulate their own views, however, there may be some room for discussion, if not agreement, in the UN in the future. Second, although the two reports help further articulate cyber norms or rules of the road, there is little if any discussion in either report on accountability. Rules of the road and even international law are little more than words on paper if there is no way to hold violators accountable or dissuade them from engaging in such conduct in the future. The increase in cyberthreats over the last several years, including the penchant of some states to continue to turn a blind eye to malicious conduct emanating from their territory, is a testament that rules and other pronouncements are not enough in the absence of reasonable consequences. Like international law, however, the issue of accountability is a politically charged one and there are unlikely to be major developments in the United Nations. Although there is good language in the reports on the peaceful settlement of disputes and the use of UN mechanisms, these mechanisms may have limited effect when the aggressor and/or victim state are members of the Security Council and can veto any action. Third, although the focus on cyber capacity building in both reports is welcome, as is the exhortation that states and other stakeholders should support these efforts, cyber capacity building remains under resourced and under prioritised. Cyberstability is not just the province of a few developed countries but requires the participation of countries and other stakeholders around the globe. Capacity building is the key to this greater participation. Here, the UN can do more and go beyond the language of the two reports – including expressly stating at a high level that cyber capacity building is foundational to achieving the Sustainable Development Goals and leveraging existing multistakeholder platforms outside the UN, such as the Global Forum on Cyber Expertise whose mission is to promote and help coordinate cyber capacity building efforts.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.