Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Disability studies is essential to their paradigm of bioethics – without it biotechnology will inevitably regress onto the structures of disability that pathologize and normalize unequal power relations.

Pitts 22 – Andrea Pitts is an Associate Professor of Philosophy at the University of North Carolina at Charlotte and they are affiliate faculty of the university’s Department of Africana Studies, Latin American Studies Program, School of Data Science, Social Aspects of Health Initiative, and Women’s and Gender Studies Program. Their research interests include Latin American and U.S. Latinx philosophy, critical philosophy of race, feminist philosophy, disability studies, and critical prison studies, and they have taught graduate and undergraduate courses on topics such as carceral medicine, Latina/x feminist philosophy, queer migration studies, prison abolitionism, critical transgender politics, and feminist epistemology. (Andrea J. Pitts, “Disability Bioethics and Race”, Routledge, Taylor and Francis Group, The Disability Bioethics Reader, 1st Edition, 2022, pgs. 235-241, DOI: 10.4324/9781003289487-30 ) || PZ

Disability studies and biomedical ethics have each been criticized for their respective omissions of the experiences, concerns, and contributions of people of color. Throughout the 1990s and 2000s, scholars began demonstrating that the first-person accounts, normative guidelines, and framings of embodiment within these interdisciplinary fields tended to prioritize the experiences of disability, pain, illness, health, and clinical treatment from a white perspective (e.g., Myser 2003; Bell 2006). In response, both fields have attempted to transform the focus of their research, activism, and clinical guidelines to include historical and present patterns of neglect, oversight, and harm impacting communities of color. Both fields have also begun to highlight insights, methods, and political strategies employed by people of color within disability activism and clinical settings. The cross-pollination of these fields of study occurred during the mid-1990s through the development of disability bioethics, even prior to coinage of the term “disability bioethics.” This new area of research urged practitioners to understand the importance of insights and methodologies from disability studies within the formation and regulation of ethical guidelines and clinical practices in biomedicine. Such insights included, specifically, that the experiences and contributions of disabled people are necessary in the field of bioethics. Regarding race, founding theorists of disability bioethics engaged race and racism to varying degrees in their respective writings. For example, Rosemarie Garland-Thomson has been described by Sami Schalk as “one of the first disability studies scholars to provide sustained race and disability analysis in the final chapter of her book Extraordinary Bodies, published in 1997” (Schalk 2018, 10). Accordingly, disability bioethics, as this volume suggests, from its inception has attempted to examine the intricacies and structural conditions of race and racism within the biomedical sciences. As a brief caveat, it is important to note that, although the focus of this chapter is on race, disability, and bioethics, the study of the intersection of race and disability exceeds the scope of the biomedical sciences. That is, as Shelley Tremain (2017) has cautioned her readers, to reduce disability to biomedical and health discourses is to potentially reify the broader societal and historical conditions that shape the pathologizing and/or normalizing relations of power that negatively impact disabled people. For this reason, although the focus of this volume is on disability bioethics, uncovering the broader relevance of the intersection of disability and race beyond medical and health discourses remains an important ongoing project. Accordingly, the analysis offered here will be limited, but will serve as a piece of a broader scholarly and political movement focusing on the relationships between race and disability more generally. To foreground a disability bioethics that grapples with the structural and intimate presence of oppression in its many valences and that emphasizes the lives and work of disabled people of color, this chapter focuses on two overlapping areas that thread together disability studies, bioethics, and critical approaches to race. First, the chapter examines work addressing the existential and conceptual relationships between race and disability. This section underscores writings by authors who analyze embodied experiences of community belonging, illness, pain, motility, madness, desire, futurity, and barriers to affirmation and care, all of which are in conversation with processes of racialization. Building on this discussion, the second section shifts to a focus on race and institutions. This section includes an examination of the functions of disability and race in contexts of clinical diagnosis and treatment, medical education and research, as well as disability and health activist movements that have challenged systemic oppressions impacting communities of color. I Existential/Conceptual Analyses of Race and Disability within Biomedical Ethics As noted above, recognizing the necessity and value of the perspectives of disabled people has been a critical turn that distinguishes disability studies more generally, and has surfaced within bioethics more recently. The common English-language refrain within disability rights activism since the 1990s “Nothing about us without us” presents a demand for policymakers, theorists, and organizers to prioritize the experiences, worldviews, and resources of people who identify as disabled or who may be socially marked as disabled or debilitated. Likewise, critical race studies and Indigenous studies have long recognized the need to prioritize the perspectives of people of color and Indigenous peoples to avoid the exoticizing, commodifying, or otherwise misinformed views developed within the anthropological, biological, and medical sciences. Social epistemologist, Charles Mills (1998), for example, considers the novel Invisible Man by Ralph Ellison a classic illustration of the existential conditions of Black Americans who have experienced patterned epistemic erasure and invalidation by white Americans. Or, as Anishinaabe theorist and literary author, Gerald Vizenor (1994) proposes, the fact that vastly distinct Indigenous societies of the Americas have been placed under one homogeneous label “Indian” has required Native peoples to devise “postindian” strategies to subvert and survive the damage caused by settler colonial imaginaries. Given this shared methodological stance across these fields, we find the study of race, disability, and the biomedical sciences similarly taking on such a priority. As such, we can turn to accounts of the relationship between race and disability that explore the existential and conceptual conditions of encounters with clinical, research, and other medical settings. First, regarding existential conditions that frame the interconnected relationships between race and disability within biomedical contexts, a number of theorists have explored the differing forms of medical treatment, attitudes and expectations of medical providers, and the everyday forms disregard for people of color within clinical settings. Notably, women of color authors of the 1970s–1990s utilized descriptions of embodied pain, illness, and disability to critique heterosexual norms and post-racial framings of “color blindness” within medical settings. Works of fiction, nonfiction, and poetry by authors such as Gloria Anzaldúa, Audre Lorde, Evelyne Accad, and Leslie Marmon Silko (Laguna Pueblo) each respond, in differing ways, to conditions of pathologization and debilitation impacting communities of color. For example, Lorde’s The Cancer Journals (1980) analyzes the author’s experiences of breast cancer, including biopsy, diagnosis, and mastectomy, and the text documents her refusal to be objectified or shamed within the clinical encounters that she endures. She describes her experience of breast cancer as stemming explicitly from a Black lesbian feminist perspective, and the text is framed throughout by excerpts from the author’s journal from the years 1978–1980. Seizing control of her narrative, Lorde opens The Cancer Journals by describing the “transformation of silence into language and action” (18). Specifically, she outlines the double binds often experienced by Black women, including their hypervisibility and simultaneous invisibility within allied political movements with white women. Within such settings, Black women, she writes, have had to fight and still do, for that very visibility which also renders us most vulnerable, our blackness. For to survive in the mouth of this dragon we call america [sic], we have had to learn this first and most vital lesson—that we were never meant to survive. (21, 17) Against this deathly tendency, she states, survival depends on “teach[ing] by living and speaking those truths which we believe and know beyond understanding” (22). In the context of The Cancer Journals, she intimates that writing about her experiences with breast cancer, including the patterned harms that she underwent within the clinical setting, is vital to her own survival and to the survival of other Black women. Additionally, “know[ing] without understanding” appears to refer to the inchoate existential awareness of one’s own sensations, emotions, and other embodied experiences, experiences that are not fully transparent to oneself or others. According to Lorde, the act of bringing such pre- or non-discursive forms of awareness, including experiences of pain and illness, into expression becomes a method to reshape personal and collective possibilities. On this point, Therí A. Pickens (2014) notes that Lorde “wrestles with the appropriate ethical response to her pain” and configures her writings as a means “to move toward awareness, discussion, and activism” (130–131). The importance of highlighting such a relationship between pain and expression is that Lorde is able to demonstrate the many ways in which Black lesbian women struggle through cancer and amputation. Among the themes that emerge in Lorde’s work is the dominance of the medical establishment over patients’ own narrative descriptions. Thus, describing her pain through evocations of joy and sensuality, including phantom pains, becomes a resistant act against the power of clinical medicine’s force relations. For example, after her mastectomy, Lorde writes that “the pain returned home bringing all of its kinfolk” (Lorde 2014, 31–32). Through drawing on familiar vernacular, Lorde’s description serves as a response to the insufficiency of medical discourses to describe the experiences of Black American women in pain (Pickens 2014, 132). The Cancer Journals also underscores Lorde’s decision not to wear a prosthesis following her mastectomy. Specifically, nurses and volunteer staff encourage her to wear a pink prosthetic breast following her surgery, and the reasons offered are that such a prosthesis will make Lorde and others around her feel more comfortable (1980, 42). The artificiality of the pink prosthetic contrasts with Lorde’s descriptions of her own “soft brown skin” after surgery, and her remarks critique the white aesthetic norms that exist within biomedical technologies of the flesh (44). Pickens also notes the heteronormative encounters Lorde describes while being encouraged to wear the prosthesis, including the suggestions by medical staff that wearing the prosthesis would allow her to remain attractive to men (2014, 135). In these ways, Lorde’s writings refuse these tendencies to foreclose her own appreciation of her body and desires, and her descriptions reopen a discursive space for a distinctively Black lesbian response to the misunderstandings and erasures that stem from the medical world around her. As such, Lorde’s writings offer a counternarrative to the whiteness of clinical medicine, and provide a descriptive opening for the existential conditions of illness, pain, and pathologization experienced by queer women of color. Alongside the pivotal work by Black, Indigenous, and other women of color in the 1970s and 1980s, more recent scholarly and activist work operating through framings of disability justice has focused on the specific existential and conceptual tools necessary for disabled, queer and trans people of color. For example, although authors like Lorde and Gloria Anzaldúa wrote extensively of experiences of illness, medical intervention, pain, and blindness, these authors were often reluctant to interpret themselves in terms of “disability” or as “disabled.” Along these lines, Moya Bailey and Izetta Autumn Mobley (2019) and Aurora Levins Morales (2013) have respectively explored the relationships between race and disability, examining the reasons why people of color may choose not to politically organize around disability rights or through identification as “disabled.” Namely, Bailey and Mobley note that tropes of the “crazy Black woman” are weaponized against Black women leading to high rates of violence committed against them, and that such violence occurs while simultaneously failing to address the needs of Black people with psychiatric or physical disabilities (2019, 31). Additionally, they point out that: Black women and other women of color do most of the labor in the service of disability despite the impact on their ability to care for themselves or their families. Caregivers are often engaged in debilitating work for disabled people and become disabled themselves. (32) These concerns, along with others, may thus complicate political and personal mobilization through a framing of disability for people of color. Bailey and Mobley also note, however, that growing work is currently being done among Black authors and activists to explore the terms of a disability within Black communities, including as their work attests, developing a Black feminist disability framework from which to theorize and mobilize. Along similar lines, Morales notes that for Gloria Anzaldúa, as a “dark-skinned working class Tejana lesbian,” to have affirmed disability as an identity would likely have required “a strong, vocal, politically sophisticated, disability justice movement led by queer working class women and trans people of color who understood [her] life” (2013, 5). From this insight, Bailey and Mobley, as well as disability justice activists have resisted individualist rights- and autonomy-based models of justice to focus on collective resistance to ableism in its many instantiations. Instead, disability justice activists and scholars demand a recognition of the interdependence of shared struggles against systemic oppressions and how disability functions across all forms of oppression—all of this while foregrounding the desires, joys, and networks of care among disabled people who are fighting against those systemic oppressions. For example, disability justice organizers Talila A. Lewis and Dustin P. Gibson, through their social media, workshops, and collective public actions, offer powerful critiques of the forms of systemic ableism that undergird US prison systems and policing, while also dedicating time and energy to curate Black disability solidarity music, art, film, and history (Lewis 2020; Gibson 2020). Additionally, Sins Invalid, founded in 2005 by disability justice activists Patty Berne and LeRoy F. Moore, is a performance-based artist collective composed of artists of color and LGBTQ/gender-variant artists that explores themes of sexuality, the non-normative body, and social and economic justice through their performances and workshops (Sins Invalid 2020). These examples of disability justice activism thus illustrate the important point made by Bailey and Mobley that there are creative aesthetic, embodied, and political contributions founded in the experiences of disabled people of color, and that organizing work done within a disability justice framework celebrates both the lives and experiences of disabled people of color while also critiquing the very systematic patterns of harm that would seek to erase, reduce, or eliminate their very existence. Lastly, regarding the relationship between disability and race, Nirmala Erevelles (2011) explores the “racialization of disability” and the “dis-abilization of race,” a process that Erevelles offers to bring both categories into material relation. Specifically, she argues that whiteness, defended as a form of property right, is “the ideological discourse that has been used to justify the racial superiority of white people over people of color by using the logic of dis-ability (e.g., inferior genes, low IQ) to decide who has the rights to citizenship” (166). By this, Erevelles suggests that the racialization of disability is the process by which white, able-bodied heterosexual cisgender men become centered as the most productive (and thereby valuable) citizens within capitalist societies. In this, the productive possibilities of such white citizens are protected through institutions such as the law, education, and health care. Regarding education, for example, the criminalization and pathologization of Black children in k-12 settings, as well as the segregation of educational institutions by “cognitive ability” seeks to shore up protected educational resources for those deemed more deserving or more capable of making “positive” contributions to society. Regarding the dis-abilization of race, Erevelles notes that people considered outside the productive metrics of advanced capitalism are often relegated to the welfare state, and thereby stigmatized as burdensome on the civic body. The responses to such so-called “dependency” on social welfare programs, however, is also a lucrative business, she argues. Testing companies, metrics and measurements for success, juvenile detention facilities, and other programs designed to manage or “uplift” children of color effectively foreground a life marked by pathologization and deviance for many people. Moreover, Erevelles proposes that the debilitating conditions of labor for many people of color in the USA also lead to increased marginalization, vulnerability, and medical precarity for such populations within advanced capitalism.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.