Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Disability is not solely a material codification but operates on invisible registers which doom its subjects to endless encounters with ableism.

Kattari et al. 18 – Shanna K. Kattari, PhD, is an associate professor at the University of Michigan School of Social Work, the Department of Women and Gender Studies, and Director of the [Sexuality|Relationships|Gender] Research Collective. Their practice and community background is as a board certified sexologist, certified sexuality educator, and social justice advocate. Dr. Kattari’s extant research focuses on understanding how power, privilege and oppression systematically marginalize, exclude, and discriminate against people regarding their identities/expressions through negative attitudes, policies reinforcing oppression, oppressive actions and isolation. (Shanna K. Kattari, Miranda Olzman, Michele D. Hanna, “‘You Look Fine!’: Ableist Experiences by People With Invisible Disabilities”, Sage, Journal of Women and Social Work, 2018, pgs. 1- 4, https://doi.org/10.1177/0886109918778073 ) || PZ

In the literature on diversity, a significant amount of work has been undertaken on issues of racism, sexism, and more recently, heterosexism, and their corresponding privileges. However, despite discussion on disability being more than decades old, with the mainstream disability rights movement gaining momentum in the 1960s and 1970s (Wolbring, 2012), and the Americans with Disabilities Act having been enacted in 1990 (United States Code, 2008), notably less academic literature has addressed ableism, particularly within the field of social work. Even disability policy as an area of focus in the literature is relatively new, given the large number of disabled individuals in the United States (Schriner, 1990). This study examines whether and how the experiences of ableism by people with invisible disabilities (someone who might not be assumed to be disabled at first meeting, such as individuals with chronic pain, traumatic brain injury, multiple sclerosis, HIV, etc.) are disparate from those whose disabilities may be more evident to others. Although members of this community use both identity-first (disabled people) and person-first (people with disabilities [PWD]) language (Dunn & Andrews, 2015), this article will focus primarily on identity-first language, as this language comes from a self-determination paradigm in line with both social work and feminist values (Ladau, 2014; National Association of Social Workers, 2017). The United States Census Bureau (2012) reported that in the 2010 Census, 21.3% of those of age 15 years and older had a disability or impairment. From these statistics, it can be inferred that approximately one fifth of U.S. residents are currently living with a disability or impairment. Disability in and of itself is a community with blurred lines—people can acquire disabilities (both short term and long term) throughout their lives, making the concept of membership to the disabled community one that is frequently difficult for other marginalized groups to understand (Davis, 1999). Although individuals with “invisible” disabilities (those that are not always, or ever, apparent to others) may not receive as much overt or explicit social stigma as those with more apparent disabilities, they are still exposed to forms of rejection, ableism, and discrimination; in fact, they may even have more trouble accessing support services than their visibly disabled counterparts due to being expected to prove their disability (Davis, 2005). Disabled individuals with invisible disabilities may struggle with “passing” as nondisabled persons in many settings (Samuels, 2003). While passing may be seen as a privilege, it can also be a challenge for these individuals to find community and be validated by disabled people. The decision on whether to pass or not comes with not only personal implications of stigma and discrimination but also more societal and political implications of outing themselves as disabled (Brune & Wilson, 2013). They may also have issues in accessing the services, support structure, and even physical spaces that they need, given assumptions about what their bodies and minds are able to do, and whether those given the power to make the distinction decide whether they are “disabled enough” (Lightman, Vick, Herd, & Mitchell, 2009). Therefore, it is possible that members of this community experience ableism in different ways than those who have apparent disabilities. Ableism is the overarching act of prejudice and/or discrimination against disabled people and the devaluation of disability (Hehir, 2002) and corresponds with able-bodied/neurotypical privilege, the set of unearned privileges held by nondisabled individuals. They are both interconnected systems that maintain stratification around disability. Ableism values physical, emotional, and mental capital, following socially constructed expectations of ability (Loja, Costa, Hughes, & Menezes, 2013). Queer/disability theorist McRuer (2006) posits that like the ideal of compulsory heterosexuality, ableism results in a compulsory able-bodiedness, demanding that disabled individuals do whatever it takes to enact a nondisabled identity however possible. While sexism, racism, and other isms certainly are prevalent in all types of systems and interactions, Wolbring (2008) argues that ableism is one of the most accepted and widespread isms in society and works in conjunction with many other isms. Because of the lack of conversation around ableism and able-bodied/neurotypical privilege, prejudice against disabled people may at times be more prevalent and socially acceptable than many others types of prejudice (Ford, 2009). Although ableism is insidious and apparent in all aspects of society, little research has been conducted to understand the lived experiences of ableism by disabled individuals, nuanced disabled identities (such as those who have invisible/less obvious disabilities), and intersections of other marginalized identities with disability identities. Moreover, while there have been some publications in the field of social work around ableism, much of it focuses on policy (El-Lahib & Wehbi, 2012), sanism (discrimination around mental health) specifically (Poole et al., 2012), or the general need for better culture competency in social work practice and education regarding disabled populations (Carter, Hanes, & MacDonald, 2012; Dupre´, 2012). Disabled individuals also experience higher rates of poverty and chronic health issues than their nondisabled counterparts (Hehir, 2002; Roux et al., 2001; Storey, 2007), and there are few instances of social work around the experiences of disabled people of color, transgender disabled people, and the ways that other marginalized identities interplay with disability and ableism. Feminist disability scholars in particular have brought up the need for intersectional frameworks and connecting disability to conversations around diversity (Kafer, 2013; McRuer, 2002; Olkin, 2002). In Feminist, Queer, Crip, feminist disability studies, scholar Kafer (2013) explains that not only did feminist theory gave her the ability to critically examine notation of disability but also emphasizes the bridge between theory and practice, something incredibly relevant to the discussion of disability and ableism in social work. Microaggressions: Death by a Thousand Papercuts The concept of microaggressions is used to explain the phenomena of the implicit perpetuation of racism, sexism, heterocentrism, transphobia, anti-Semitism, and other forms of power and oppression in society (Sue, 2010). Microaggressions are everyday interactions that perpetuate inequalities and stereotypes against people who belong to marginalized communities (Solo´ rzano, Ceja, & Yosso, 2000; Sue, 2010). They are perpetuated against many individuals holding many different identities, including race, gender, sexual orientation, religion, and disability (Solo´ rzano et al., 2000; Sue, 2010). Frequent exposure to microaggressions, including ableist microaggressions, can result in higher incidence of negative mental health outcomes, feelings of being excluded, and lower positive outcomes including reduced academic performance (Khattari, 2017; Nadal, Griffin, Wong, Hamit, & Rasmus, 2014). Microaggressions are a common means of perpetuating ableism. These may include telling someone that they speak very well for a deaf person, telling someone they are lucky to get to bring their dog everywhere with them, asking a group of people to all stand for an activity (making the assumption that everyone can stand), or making a joke about how fast someone can go in their wheelchair (Storey, 2007). Many of these microaggressions are a result of assumptions about disabled people. Storey (2007) found that perpetuation of these microaggressions and assumptions result in disabled people feeling excluded or unwelcome in educational settings and produce outcomes including anger, frustration, and other feelings that can be harmful to an individual’s engagement with their community. Invisible Disabilities People with invisible disabilities or illness may be more likely to experience ableism indirectly, including through ableist microaggressions. For example, while someone might not use language like “lame” in front of someone they perceive to be mobility impaired, they may be less reticent to use such language in front of those they identify as nondisabled, whether or not those individuals actually are. Additionally, people with invisible disabilities may experience ableism when using adaptations for PWD, such as disability-designated parking spaces or elevators, when others view them as nondisabled individuals. It is possible that this is a result of unintentionally fulfilling the role of compulsory able-bodiedness suggested by McRuer (2006), simple by not having disabilities that might make themselves visibly distinct as disabled to outsiders. Disabled bodies are frequently othered and feared by society at large (Hirschmann, 2013), but there is little knowledge on how this may be experienced by those with invisible physical disabilities. Mad studies, a subset of disabilities focusing on mental health and sanism, have noted similarities in the “coming out and facing stigma/not being out and facing different marginalization” decision as faced by other individuals with sometimes invisible identities (Pilling, 2012). Therefore research is needed to help understand how disabled individuals who may not be read as disabled experience ableism in their lives. Bridging the theoretical understanding of ableism into the lived experiences of this community is a crucial move forward in creating more disability inclusive social work practice. This study explores the experiences of ableism specifically for individuals with invisible disabilities because, given that this invisibility often prevents these individual from being viewed as disabled, it is likely that their experiences may differ from disabled individuals with more apparent disabilities.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.