Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Our embracement of Black madness :: mad blackness operates as a discursive move against the imposition of whiteness and being able bodied through speaking on realities that are inherently unspeakable. Absent this mode of analysis, logics of white eugenics will lock mad blackness into a position of unfreedom.

Pickens 19 [Therí Alyce Pickens, Professor of English, specializing in African American, Arab America and disability literatures and theories at Bates University, June 7, 2019 “Black Madness :: Mad Blackness”, Duke University Press, Durham and London, pgs. 24-29, JMH]

Seemingly in answer to Bell’s work, scholars developed a reading strategy that clarifies how race and disability operate: mutual constitution. Specifically, mutual constitution impresses upon readers how these two discourses operate as interrelated and simultaneously present. This reading strategy performs several useful functions within the scholarship. In the interest of carving space to examine our critical conversations and open them up with the work of artists-theorists, I turn to several key moments in our use of mutual constitution to think through when it works and when it does not. This critical reading strategy becomes useful when understanding how disability has been used as a discursive tool. For example, racial and gendered groups have tended to justify their cases for civil rights in opposition to individuals with disabilities. The rhetorical invocation of disability here only functions to undergird the validity of another people groups’ personhood (at the expense of the personhood of the disabled).4 Disability, in this case, does not quite exist as a material reality but rather as a hauntological presence that helps create race and gender, sometimes as superlative. In thinking of race and disability as material, one must consider that contexts of oppression and war create disability, often with detrimental effects on those already disenfranchised by institutional racism.5 In this case, disability shores up the physical evidence of institutionalized racism and systemic injustice, helping to define race as a matter of life and death. In addition to highlighting the discursive and material effects of race and disability in tandem, such mutuality also serves an argumentative function. Since it is a critical reading practice, it also shapes how critics write about the two subjects. This project, in its interest in openoing up the critical literature to itself, invests in discussing this as a writing and reading strategy for how it roadmaps intellectual possibility (and, as the metaphor goes, closes off certain avenues). Within Ellen Samuels’s monograph Fantasies of Identification: Disability, Gender, Race (2014), she pinpoints that “the mutual entangled and constitutive dynamic of disability, gender, and race in modern fantasies of identification determines the shape and trajectory of [her] book” and, in articulating her main argument, states that “if, at times, one of these embodied social identities comes to the foreground, such that parts of the book address disability or race or gender more centrally, the overarching argument remains structured around the inseparability of their meanings.”6 An incredibly useful proposition. Samuels’s caveat guarantees that readers do not miss the way that all discussions heavily rely on each other. Historically speaking, the creating of disability, race, and gender occurs at the same time. The strands of what would become modern medicine worked to differentiate bodies from each other, specifically normal bodies from abnormal ones, where abnormal was constituted in gendered, raced, and abled terms. These fantasies of identification found their justification in what Samuels terms “biocertification,”7 a process that further links the construction of abnormality (and with it the construction of Blackness and disability) to objective science, aspiring to some semblance of truth. What becomes clear is not just that one cannot read race without disability nor disability without race, but that their entanglement requires a robust critical armature that grapples with them both. When I trace the use of mutual constitution, two critical reading practices emerge: first, recuperation projects that seek to historicize, and, second, retrieval projects that read against ableism to find agency. In this way, mutual constitution performs as scholarly shorthand for “It’s complicated.” Intussuscepted (that is, enfolded) in these readings are several challenges to the practices themselves: specifically, scholarship is stagnated between recuperation and resistance. What of the projects that are neither? Is there a space between these or next to them, narratologically speaking? How can we read the moments when race and disability have a wider range of relationships? In what follows, I read the spaces where the critical material breaks open the possibilities for new readings of Blackness and disability in tandem. Though much of this material analyzes Blackness and disability broadly, I find that the distillate reveals the critical material to itself, suggesting that madness, Black madness in particular, troubles the impulses of retrieval and radicality. First, Blackness and madness encounter the problem of existing on the same temporal plane, particularly when whiteness is a factor. The Black mad subject gets evacuated from history while the white able subject or white disabled subject dictates the terms of history’s narration. Second, Black mad subjects cannot always serve as the prompts for others’ freedom from ableism. It is possible for Black individuals, institutions, and cultural spaces to be ableist. Moreover, when Black spaces function as examples of freedom for others, they do not exist on their own terms, a logical concern that lands us back in the terrain where whiteness instrumentalizes Blackness for its own ends. Later in this conversation, I turn to Octavia E. Butler’s Fledgling (2005) and her archive for how she theorizes Blackness and madness.8 Butler’s texts and her archive offer alternative analytic strategies to the problems posed by mutual constitution in its current form. Recuperating, Historicizing Mutual constitution attends to the fiction of fixity often ascribed to race and disability writ large. Reading race and disability in this way yokes the discourses to each other, since they typically cannot be pinned down elsewhere. When Ellen Samuels traces the way this mutual constitution functioned within the nineteenth century, she finds that the discourses that created and sustained ideas about race and ability were not only created at the same time but also reliant on each other for validity. These national fantasies were created by physicians who scrupulously searched the body for clues about its difference.10 Both the physically or mentally abnormal body and the racially abnormal body were understood as close cousins, demonstrating in their difference the validity and supremacy of the white able body by contrast. Samuels writes, “At the core of the fantasy of identification lies the assumption that embodied social identities such as race, gender, and disability are fixed, legible, and categorizable. This assumption, by now deeply naturalized in our social and ontological structures, in fact required elaborate construction and ongoing policing through the nineteenth century and early twentieth.”11 The very mutability of these social categories makes necessary the fiction of their fixity and the necessity of their policing by parties for whom that mutability causes concern. Mutual constitution offers a conceptual corrective, given the discursive history, and allows for an analysis to take shape around that history and the cultural context of its object(s) of inquiry. Ensuring that this corrective attends to history authorizes critics to acknowledge the plasticity of Blackness and madness in tandem. Consider that the United States census of 1840 was the first to provide statistics about mental illness. The faulty statistics counted a higher incidence of madness among Blacks in the North at numbers that far exceeded the amount of Black people full stop. This pseudoscientific evidence not only arrogated madness to Blackness generally but also provided putative proof that Blacks were unfit for freedom, claiming that free Blacks were eleven times more likely to have mental illness than the enslaved or white populations.12 The postbellum environment does not undergo a dramatic shift in this regard; the definitions of Blackness available hinge on definitions of sanity. Kim Nielsen’s A Disability History of the United States (2012) traces the early conception of citizenship as tied not only to enslavement but to mental illness as well.13 This connection and its mutability continue into the mid-twentieth century when wider public scrutiny of mental health institutions (and some scandal), advocacy from the family of president John F. Kennedy, and civil rights discourse made it possible to imagine integrating mentally ill and cognitively disabled people into public spaces.14 This integration effort occurs simultaneous to that which occurred for Black people, linking the two populations in the public sphere. This history pertains mostly to those categorized as mentally ill or cognitively disabled. Though the definition of madness for this text is more expansive than that (given the healthy skepticism of psy-disciplines based on this history), sketching the relationships between the two discourses and social identities over time permits a closer look at how Blackness and madness rely on each other for concretization. Such an analysis also reveals how tenuous they are. This history makes clear that within the United States’s cultural zeitgeist, there is no Blackness without madness, nor madness without Blackness. Yet, the discourses’ fragility suggests that the two have been forced together out of political convenience and presumed abjection. Notwithstanding the utility of mutual constitution as a historicizing tool, it cannot—as a methodology—fully account for how race and disability interact on a body or between bodies. To be mutually constituted implies a reciprocity of creation. I put pressure on reciprocity because mutual implies simultaneity while occupying the temporal plane. I put pressure on creation because constitution assumes that, where discourses or material conditions related to race and disability exist, they develop and are sustained completely and consistently. In other words, the phrase mutual constitution implies race and disability announce themselves at the same time and both exert pressure in constant fashion. Case in point: Michelle Jarman’s work exposes this fold. In her hermeneutic reading of lynch mobs and eugenic discourse, she writes that the two discourses are “not equal or competing” but rather “dynamic social and discursive processes that inform each other.”15 What her rhetorical sleight of hand allows is the possibility that one discourse will occupy more space than another or affect the material reality more than the other particularly within interracial encounter. Jarman pinpoints the hefty pull of eugenics discourse on the eventual castration of Benjy Compson (in Faulkner’s The Sound and the Fury). Because the action of the novel takes place during the early twentieth century, she links this eugenics discourse to the pervasive nature and likely rationales for lynch mob murders. Though her link to lynch mobs undergirds her argument by positioning the two discourses as reliant on each other, her readings reveal that they do not affect material reality equally. For instance, Jarman’s opening gambit points to a tragic illustration of when both ableist and racist discourses collide in the real life beating of Billy Ray Johnson, a Black cognitively disabled man, and its aftermath. Here, the full force of racist eugenics comes to bear on the availability of justice for Johnson. There is a slippage in the way these two discourses occupy space: news outlets, civil rights organizations, and law enforcement could not conceptualize Johnson as both Black and cognitively disabled (I say more about this invisibility in the second discussion). He was either one or the other in their imagination. The material consequence— suspended sentences and probation for his assailants instead of jail time— exacerbates the violence already inflicted. What Jarman’s example reveals is that race and disability do vie for narrative space and, in this instance, determine material consequence based on which narrative is told and which is believed. Billy Ray Johnson’s story ghosts that of Faulkner’s Benjy because it undermines how we read the interlocking ideas about Blackness and madness within Sound and the Fury Here lies the critical lacuna we have yet to address. The historicization approach to discussions about race and disability presumes a linear progression of time, an unfolding that takes place at a pace to which we have become accustomed delineated by demarcations of second, minute, hour, day, month, and year. However, as calendars themselves often lay bare, few cultures think of time in the same way. Which New Year do you celebrate? Is your calendar lunar or solar? Time does not progress in the same fashion for everyone. It becomes useful to think of history in terms of the fold. Here, I yoke Spillers’s concept of the flesh with Deleuze’s understanding of the fold (a point of connection between ideas where one begets the other) to Fred Moten’s conceptualization of being, living, writing, meaning “in the break” (where history and narrative converge—invaginate or intussuscept to use his terms—as a requisite part of being intertwined). If we are to linger in the fold, in the break, then we must reckon with the way madness and Blackness force us to render history countermnemonically: attending to gaps, mistakes, deferrals, silences, glitches. It is in this break, cut, fold that the relationship between Blackness and madness becomes most clear. Here is the relationship between Blackness and disability writ large, a relationship sutured at times by its connections, but also turned in and turned out by missed connections, erasures, and gaps.16 Despite the fact that both disability and race as ideas emerged at the same moments in history, they do not necessarily occupy the same temporal plane when conjoined in quotidian interaction. In thinking of interracial encounter for instance, Sharon P. Holland reminds us of a “persistent problem in the Black/white encounter,” specifically that we must question “what happens when someone who exists in time meets someone who only occupies space?”17 As she delineates, Blackness appears as the antithesis of history, its excretion, whereas whiteness stands in for progression, being in time. Our sense of the two interacting in the same moment then is skewed by the fact that Blackness is not meant to be a part of history but rather its object. Black cultural production has consistently expanded upon this idea through its skepticism of linear progressive narratives that assume Western origins, choosing instead to position Africa (usually the continent, broadly conceptualized) as a futuristic space or elide Western notions of time and space.18 Thinking through the Black mad subject, we must consider that this person is meant not only to occupy space but to be consistently removed from space in order to make room for the more recognizable subject: the white able body. It is this body that dictates the terms of history and narrative. In the case of Billy Ray Johnson, the criminal justice system determined that his assailants were allowed to move on with their lives regardless of the violence and damage done to his body. If we are to consider Bell’s modest proposal, the Black mad subject is removed from time to make space for the white disabled body as well. In other words, the Black disabled subject exists only to shore up the value of others. So, when the Black/white encounter is divided along ability lines such that the disabled body is white and the able body is Black, what emerges is a dynamic of relationships that force Blackness and disability into the realm of unspeakability, troubling the idea that both are created and sustained at the same time.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.