Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The 1AC operates as an intervention against white able-bodied structures that seek to bracket out forms of black. Absent this analysis, whiteness will always seek to control the uncontrollable of mad black life.

Pickens 19 [Therí Alyce Pickens, Professor of English, specializing in African American, Arab America and disability literatures and theories at Bates University, June 7, 2019 “Black Madness :: Mad Blackness”, Duke University Press, Durham and London, pgs. 50-54, JMH]

As I mentioned, I deploy the term madness because of the critical possibilities it offers in its vagueness. It operates as a way to describe impairments such as cognitive disability or mental illness as well as a catchall phrase designed to reference those not behaving according to culturally prescribed norms. Here, I harken back to the idea that madness is maddeningly everywhere with biopsychological and sociocultural valences. Within Black cultural contexts, madness not only has this critical purchase but also carries with it the vernacular appeal of excess (e.g., mad as equivalent to very) and anger. For the purposes of this discussion, I loosely bifurcate madness into two categories, keeping in mind that each carries with it the cultural valences of excess: cognitive impairment (read: autism, Down syndrome, traumatic brain injury, dementia, etc.) and mental illness (read: bipolar, depression, schizophrenia, etc.). I split these experiences in order to attend to the differences in the way madness writ large is treated within Black cultural contexts.3 There are overlapping concerns, to be sure, but the reactions within Black communities shift depending on the particular kind of madness one demonstrates. Lurking within each discussion of madness— cognitive impairment or mental illness—is the idea, simply put, that Blackness changes things. A Black cultural context mandates a different set of interpretive strategies because of the confluence of structural racism from the outside and its impact on the intracultural community, and structural patriarchy and ableism emanating from within the community. Parsing mental illness and cognitive disability allows for a certain type of granularity when discussing Black cultural contexts and madness. The conversation that follows relocates the discussion of Blackness and madness outside the confines of the interracial encounter in order to under stand what may constitute disability cultures within Blackness. What analytics become necessary when examining madness within Blackness? There are of course two caveats to this discussion. First, it is not entirely possible to get outside the confines of white cisheteropatriarchy, since it structures so much of what is possible within Black contexts. For that reason, I turn to Nalo Hopkinson’s work because she dares to theorize a set of Black cultural contexts that are largely independent from white cisheteropatriarchal structures. Hopkinson’s theorizing about intraracial contexts relies on the particular tools of Black speculative fiction, even though her ideas resonate outside of that creative context.4 I also focus on cultural narratives because of what they offer in terms of theorizing from below, especially since “through analysis, texts on disability can be made to reveal the texture of community life.”5 The second caveat is that there are a wide variety of Black cultural contexts available to examine. The intention of this discussion is not to provide a rubric that suits all of them but to provide an inroad to examination, one that exists as a set of overarching analytical possibilities until others develop. As a way to develop this schema, I read the current strategies for discussing madness within Blackness. Again, the critical literature reveals itself to itself through the gaps it leaves unattended. I propose the mad Black as a way to reimagine and reread. Nalo Hopkinson, as an artist-theorist, creates mad Black characters—one with a cognitive disability and another with a mental illness—in her mad Black novel Midnight Robber (2000). The two narratives twin each other and open up the possibilities for interpreting madness within Black communities. In considering mental illness within Black communities, two interpretive moments in the critical literature open up the parameters to think through how madness lays bare common culturally accepted narratives about Blackness. For example, in Anna Mollow’s meditation on Meri Nana-Ama Danquah’s Willow Weep for Me: A Black Woman’s Journey through Depression, A Memoir (1998), Mollow concludes that Danquah’s narrative of depression foregrounds her race, class position, and immigrant status as a barrier to receiving adequate health care for her depression. Contrary to most within the ex-patient/survivor/consumer movement, Danquah’s concern is not overmedication or forced medication but a lack thereof. Not only do health care professionals demonstrate a lack of competence in discussing the influence of racial discrimination on Danquah’s depression, but Danquah also has to combat the following ideas: that depression is not real, that she is particularly strong as a Black woman, and (specific to her identity as an immigrant) that she only need work harder to overcome her sadness. Mollow reads Danquah’s narrative as a structural critique of the medical establishment’s tendency to ignore and/or underestimate Black women’s pain. I would add that Danquah’s memoir is a cultural critique of intraracial dictums that diminish Black women’s experiences with mental illness. What Mollow’s reading reveals is that Danquah’s depression exceeds the parameters in which she is expected to operate as a Ghanaian immigrant woman in the United States, parameters set by both dominant cultures and her own. To my mind, Danquah becomes circumscribed by her inability to appropriately perform the scripts of Black womanhood because of her mental illness. Here, the critical gap lies in the space between how Danquah’s depression indexes structural critique and how it also points to sociocultural critique. Whereas Mollow’s reading of Danquah’s narrative reveals how structural racism materially compounds the assault of oppressive intracultural narratives, literary interpretations within African American Studies unmask the limited space available for Black characters who experience madness. When discussing August Wilson’s oeuvre, which includes his cadre of cognitively disabled characters, Harry Elam describes “racialized madness” as a “trope that became operative in clinical practice, literary creation, and cultural theory in the modern period as artists, critics, and practitioners in all these arenas identified social and cultural roots for Black psychological impairment.”6 Elam usefully locates this trope in Frantz Fanon’s and W. E. B. Du Bois’s work as a diagnosis of what ails African descended people. The solution with August Wilson’s (and others’) work is to upend the social, cultural, and discursive elements that comprise a world hostile to Blackness. Elam argues that August Wilson creates characters that experience madness to clarify how much social and spiritual change would be necessary for a group of people who have already been driven mad by a mad world. This is a sociogenic madness, madness without pathos.7 I reference Elam and his work in African American literary study because of the way sociogenic theories have particular critical purchase for this field. They denounce the pathologization of Black people for being Black yet embrace the understanding of the world as anti-Black. Yet, this is also madness without the multidimensionality that accompanies embodiment or aesthetic intervention: madness in service of sanity. Mollow, Elam, and others abide by one delimited script: madness is not a biological or psychosocial impairment with experiences all its own. Rather, those who are Black and mad are societal bellwethers. Their madness either presages or pinpoints putative larger issues at stake. This idea rests on the politicization of both Blackness and madness, where either or both are primarily or solely political identities. Black madness then becomes revelatory for the rest of the world and the Black mad folks—real or imagined—stand in for an examination of what is happening. Their existence functions as an analysis tout court, an explication de texte that the world operates according to antiBlack logics. This script is of course not new. We have consistently thought of people who occupy marginalized social positions as markers of whether our governments, cultures, and communities fulfill ethical or moral obligations of caretaking. However, we cannot completely shunt aside the way the idea of a societal bellwether objectifies and distances the Black mad, stripping them of the multidimensionality that would emerge within a communal context. Critics attend to this conceptual problem by considering these characters or people within intraracial communities, but often these communities embrace this script as well. From this critical impulse follows the erroneous idea that the Black mad do not have community, or they operate as lone soldiers. Here, their existential or ontological homelessness becomes a vehicle for other (sometimes, non-Black or non-mad) characters or people to discover their own missing humanity. Or, said homelessness results in death. Read in the fold, in the break. The Black mad as societal bellwether moves according to a linear progression of time, where their existence must be incorporated or excised in order to demonstrate progress of some sort. (Billy Ray Johnson echoes here.) Typically, that results in an erasure of either their Blackness or their madness. Removing the impulse to view the Black mad as living analyses, they become invaginated into the moments of a text and do not function in the service of others but rather have their own plotlines and, sometimes, create their own resolutions. Or don’t. Narrative time no longer stands still, but it also does not operate strictly in linear fashion, preferring to intussuscept itself or create gaps and pauses.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.