Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Emerging technologies create disinformation campaigns, expanding state influence to justify its mistreatment of racialized and disabled subjects through the weaponization of cognitive dissonance in algorithmic fashion

Zach Naqvi 21 [Department of Political Science, University of Alberta, Madness, Migration and Media in the Modern Digital Age, April 14th 2021, pg.2-7, -ekh-]

Citizenship, migration and international relations informing how we conceptualize policy get inextricably tied to sovereign states that determine the fate of refugees. The framework that facilitates this process has followed a chaotic trajectory in recent years. Understanding the rise of populist rhetoric emerging in North America and Europe, among others, points to recent developments in international relations requiring greater scrutiny, with specific practices necessitating a closer look by communities at home and abroad. I argue that we have fallen short of our collective humanitarian promise of dignity and fundamental human rights for everyone, regardless of race, gender, religion, class, or country of origin. Unsurprisingly, the sovereignty of the state and a universal humanitarian aim have had difficulties getting reconciled. In theory and practice, pragmatism and utopia and things related to realist necessity versus a more utopian idealism – international relations are plagued with a disconnect between what ought to be and what is. The reason is that states, unlike individuals, families and communities are not concerned primarily with such lofty ideals as human dignity, fraternity, equality, and the like. Instead, they get inseparably linked with the fundamental objective of consolidating, maintaining, and executing powers that we as individuals upon the grounds of elections, citizenship and birth or connection have authorized the state to have. Furthermore, many view frameworks of citizenship and migration from a privileged standpoint, concerned with realist undertones of security, sovereignty, and the success of their state above all else. The dire question here is whether those immigrating, seeking asylum or even completely stateless can reasonably expect to be accommodated by sovereign states.

First, alternative facts or the designation by some that we are entering a post-truth world, amplified by improvements in technology moving us collectively towards increasingly interconnected existence, lay bare for all to see a new power dynamic playing out over the past decade. The aim of alternative facts is “to establish power: they are lying to flaunt power. They are saying to us: ‘we know that you know that this is a lie, and we don’t care, because there is absolutely nothing you can do about it’ … over years, ceaseless propaganda and spectacle, exacerbated by corrections and retractions, can destroy your sense of reality. Time spirals forward and lurches backwards.” (Kendzior, 2020, p.18) Take Franz Fanon, for example. Despite his death decades ago, his lived experience then provides critical insight now. Fanon was a doctor and the acclaimed author of Black Skin, White Masks. Despite his subjective personhood being complex and multifaceted, not constrained simply to role or race, when practicing medicine, it is a mistake made as a black doctor if he made a mistake. Similarly, refugees, migrants, and asylum seekers are broadly categorized as if the totality of their being constitutes race – and nothing more. Other times, we simply view things based on monetary or pragmatic conditionality. As Fanon notes, it is society, unlike biochemical processes, that do not escape human influence. Yet, it is us that brings society into being. (Fanon, 2008, p. XV) We saw this media makeover take place in society with the portrayal of Muslims, migrants and more recently with the Chinese during COVID-19, among a myriad of other examples through the ages. Kendzior notes how, “a media makeover is a peculiar wound. It is a terrible feeling to be in pain and ignored – as a place, as a person. It is worse to be given a mask and told it’s your face.” (Kendzior, 2020, p. 22) In other words, alongside ordinary people behaving rationally according to human psychology, some behave pathologically according to inhuman psychology. (Fanon, 2008, p. 15) We have forgotten sense from nonsense and implemented it ubiquitously as if it held any semblance of truth.

Take Wiener’s (1960) framing of the coming difficulties of technological advancement. It still proves influential because he generalized it beyond literal human–machine cooperation to any situation in which two systems work together at different temporal and perceptual scales. Because choices made today with limited information can have terrible long-term consequences that we cannot foresee, Wiener warns that “the purpose put into the machine — be it a literal machine like a Twitter algorithm, or a metaphorical one like the corporation that runs it — should be the purpose that we ‘really desire’ and not a colourful imitation.” (Wiener, 1960; Prier, 2017) That colourful imitation has become the norm with associations of refugees, migrants and asylum seekers based not on dignity but premised on race and identity politics masquerading as genuine discourse. In terms of how to meaningfully address this inversion, I believe it necessary to borrow from the very tactics we aim to illuminate. In a manner reminiscent of Darko Maver, where “the borders between reality and false, if they exist at all, are so thin that often the roles exchange and reality copies imitation,” Deseriis (2010) theorizes their method as a form of ‘media homeopathy.’ Where “the idea was to inject into the media bloodstream stories whose patent falsity would eventually induce the media immune system into a reaction of its own.” This example brings us to the most suggestive connection to the present. The QAnon conspiracy, from the beginning, fixated on the lurid idea of hidden child molestation rings. However, historically this is nothing new. The middle ages were plagued with conspiracies concerning Jewish cabals and children. (Spence, 2019) Recently, Swami (2012) noted a positive relationship between right wing authoritarianism and beliefs in anti-Jewish conspiracy theories, but a negative relationship with general beliefs in conspiracy theories. It points to how individuals may well pick and choose theories that fit with a particular political view or belief system. Moreover, the 90s saw Italy face its version of “Satanic Panic” around child sex abuse. Feeling that people were baselessly targeted, Luther Blissett activists responded in an unconventional way — with a multiyear campaign of interconnected, multi-city media pranks.” (Davis, 2018) As Q-Anon has gotten ‘unmasked’ recently in the HBO (2021) documentary Q, Into the Storm, and used to get hosted on a site whose slogan is ‘embrace infamy’, it would appear history has repeated itself through the injection of blatantly false narratives, except this time – it led to a clear and definitive mass mobilization. Furthermore, states profoundly benefit from this obfuscation, and I believe, as was the case with Trump in 2016, can have real success from dividing people into distinct categories and subsequently pitting these separate groups against each other. Rhetoric based on this divisive and obfuscated nature is the link I explore that differentiates arguments about justice, human rights, and dignity on the one hand and the actual telos of institutions on the other. Migration, immigration, and asylum frameworks have particularly gotten affected by this developing phenomenon detaching its purpose from actions. What I mean is instead of being concerned with the framework on which migration gets premised, we have forgotten that the framework’s telos or point in favour of the outcomes that result from it. As a means to an end, the frameworks are politicized in a Machiavellian manner, not ends in themselves. Likewise, social media is not free as one would like to believe. It follows a similar path as it is us who are the product, which is done by commodifying our data. Additionally, migratory narratives are often not concerned with promoting virtue but instead are concerned with outcomes. Kantian autonomy and human dignity help one to discern how this plays out; as is the case with varied frameworks, we treat people as a means to an end and not an end in themselves. The result: utilization of polarization for populist ends that often scapegoat’s foreigners, migrants, and refugees – among other fashionable outgroups, dependent on time, place, and circumstance. (Muslims after 9/11, Turkish with BREXIT, Chinese during COVID,)

Unfortunately, as much as we have never been more connected, we are also divided and polarized by the very tools that promote this connectivity. Similarly, the problem with Trump’s rhetoric, as with big tech, is that the purpose or telos gets obfuscated, and as a result, many lack the ability or context necessary to discern fundamental conceptions such as the difference between a migrant, internally displaced person, and refugee from broader conversations on what migratory regimes ought to look like. A clear example of this was illustrated during Hurricane Katrina, where many government representatives mistakenly referred to the displaced persons as refugees. Additionally, “the U.S. government did not adequately protect the rights of Gulf Coast residents during displacement, failing in many cases to prevent discrimination against the poor, immigrants, and people of colour, and allowing children, the elderly, disabled persons and other vulnerable populations to be put in life-threatening situations.” (Brookings, 2008, p. 5) If this occurred to those already in the US, it is unsurprising to see this outcome on a more pervasive scale for those with no citizenship or legal standing. On a more positive note, despite state powers, we also have the power to articulate concerns and voice expectations – albeit without a monopoly on violence like the state. (Weber, 1965) As Kendzior points out, “There is a difference between expecting autocracy and accepting autocracy. It is necessary to expect it so that you can plan how you will fight. But the battle lines change, and you often end up changing with them.” (Kendzior, 2020, p. 15) The sentiment as mentioned above is echoed in Nietzche’s quip how “he who fights with monsters should be careful lest he thereby become a monster. And if thou gaze long into an abyss, the abyss will also gaze into thee.” (Nietzsche & Zimmern, 1997, p. 52) Building on Nietzsche, I surmise the reason for our collective spiral into distrust, fueling anti-immigrant populist rhetoric, reflects how misinformation embodies the tale of the mythological hydra. What I mean is, when you cut one head off – three grow back to replace it. Similarly, when attempting to debunk blatantly false narratives, it only feeds further into conspiratorial rhetoric, reinforcing the person’s views that they are getting confronted because what they view is correct. Exchanges like this rob potential discourse of being constructive and cannot reasonably assess the credibility of varied points of view. Moreover, cognitive dissonance is a powerful influence on the mind causing hesitations regarding the credibility of contradictory information, especially pertaining to conspiracies. (Leman & Cinnirella, 2013) A typical interaction I have personally experienced many times manifests as such:

One person critical of conspiratorial narratives can say, “Not everything is intentional, and not everything has meaning,” referring to some real or imagined cabal, deep state, or conniving billionaire suiting their predispositions (Soros, Gates, Zuckerberg, Musk, Bezos, Trump, etc.) In response, the person defending their blatantly false views can say, “Well… that is just your opinion,” “You fell for the misinformation,” or “I did my research, you should do yours.”

The distrust is so pervasive that even asking for sources for the ‘research’ is met with hostility, contempt, or stonewalling. As a result, honest and credible debate cannot occur when the very foundation the conversation rests on is negated through open-ended Socratic style musings that talking heads like Tucker Carleson implore regularly. (Kaufman, 2021; AP, 2020) To clarify precisely how this presents itself, suppose I ask you, “are illegal aliens a burden to our country?” This is precisely the bad faith musings that presuppose a determined answer. By calling migrants, refugees, or asylum speakers’ illegal aliens,’ you are already denoting them in a negative light, grouping distinct cases into a bundle premised on the negation of the group’s humanity. Additionally, by using loaded words like ‘burden’ with negative connotations, the answer is built into the question. Unfortunately, despite various politicians, NGOs (non-governmental organizations) and citizens’ repeated assurances that it is absurd to give this type of discourse credence, one must never forget – even the road to hell is paved with good intentions. Interestingly, Swami et al. (2012) demonstrated in a controlled study how belief in entirely fictitious conspiracy theory was significantly associated with stronger belief in other real‐world conspiracy theories, stronger paranormal beliefs, and lower crystallized intelligence. Nevertheless, we must remember these subtle influences that guide the narratives we tell ourselves and society collectively are not spirits, hydras, or demons but rather,

“bots and opaque algorithmic processes, which alternately and capriciously curse or bless us. One such force is, of course, Internet memes and online content generally. Amplified and circulated by complex proprietary information platforms hidden behind corporate obfuscation and often too complicated even for their own engineers to fully comprehend, these systems make their users vulnerable to external predation by harmful forms of social influence. The common factor in all the fears about rampaging memes is the belief that memes are like magic, with powers to cause real-world effects.” (Elkus, 2021)

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.