The embracement of Black speculative fiction through our 1AC creates agentive forms of intimacy and resistance within white spaces that crowd out discussions of black life. This intervention counters logics of whiteness that seek to desire but terminally destroy Black disabled persons.
Pickens 19 [Therí Alyce Pickens, Professor of English, specializing in African American, Arab America and disability literatures and theories at Bates University, June 7, 2019 “Black Madness :: Mad Blackness”, Duke University Press, Durham and London, pgs. 36-41, JMH]
Both frustrating and fascinating, Black speculative fiction writer and pioneer Octavia E. Butler renders intimate, personal relationships with an eye toward complexity and compromise.35 Her characters’ investment in each other does not necessarily equate to a divestment from the oppressive ideologies that buoy their power. Most important for this inquiry, Butler’s work foregrounds the spaces of discomfort and erasure that accompany Black madness. As noted in the preface and introduction, I view Butler as a theorist working in the medium of fiction. I analyze her archive and her final published novel Fledgling (2005), interpreting the intimate relationships she depicts. Here, I invest in the “politics of the possible” regarding modes of interpretation that function as alternatives to mutual constitution.36 Elsewhere I have discussed the enemy relationships in Butler’s Fledgling, pinpointing that the protagonist’s enemies “[mobilize] racist rhetoric subsequent to failed ableist rhetoric.”37 Their motives and their ideas are easily understood as a threat to the protagonist’s life, a desire for her erasure, since their engagement with Blackness and disability relies on a denigration of both. This discomfort and erasure flows from the protagonist’s lovers, friends, and family as well. Here, the discourses of madness and Blackness vie for importance, a competition of sorts in which neither can win, but where the decision to prioritize one over the other shifts the emotional and ideological terrain, particularly in the interracial, multiability encounter. Butler theorizes that Black madness creates a crisis of the self in which subjectivity and identity is destabilized and the conception of the future altered. Butler conceptualized Fledgling as a coming-of-age and chase narrative that follows the structure of a crime procedural. In a letter to her editor she writes, “This one is essentially Shori’s [the protagonist’s] struggle to rebuild her life in spite of her lost family and memory—and, of course, she can only rebuild if she finds those who are hunting her and her love ones and stop them. In Law and Order fashion, she does this first through physical action— looking for answers, finding them, getting surprised, fighting to stay alive. . . . Then there’s the trial—a less physically active part of the story, but one just as involved in its own conflict and drama.”38 The first third of the novel follows Shori as she awakes with amnesia, learns that she is a vampire (called Ina) from her father, Iosif, and finds human companions, including Wright, Celia, and Brooke (called symbionts, abbreviated as syms) to survive. During this time, she learns that what separates her from other Ina is genetic experimentation with human blood that grants her melanin and the capacity to remain awake during the day. The middle third of the novel depicts her adjustment to her new symbionts, including three same-gender loving relationships with syms Theodora, Celia, and Brooke, and her alliance with the male Ina family to whom she was/is betrothed (the Gordons). The final third delineates the trial, or Council of Judgment, which determines truth and consequences for those Ina who attempted to murder her, and successfully murdered her family (Silk family, Dahlman family). Butler’s notebooks and journals reveal that she conceptualized several sequels to Fledgling. She completed five chapters of a novel tentatively called Asylum or Flight. In it, she introduces a new symbiont, a newfound archive from Shori’s mothers, and the drama of being kidnapped by unmated male members of the Silk family. In the journal entries months before her death, Butler rethinks the story line of kidnapping and considers the story of a seduction, where Shori must build a family of symbionts and Ina sisters.39 Within Fledgling, several intimate relationships—the Gordon family, Daniel Gordon, Shori’s symbionts—clarify how Black madness disrupts the ideological field: their behavior clarifies that the reading strategy of mutual constitution elides the competition between Blackness and madness for narrative space, the impossibility of linear progressive understandings of history and time, and the fiction of Black mad resistance as always agentive. As a family, the Gordons remain in thrall to their able-bodied and race privilege, such that it governs their interpretations of Shori. They “deploy an evaluative gaze that assesses Shori’s ‘fitness’ based on their own criteria— shaped as it is by abled embodiment. The Gordons constitute fitness based on criteria that demonstrate their ignorance about the systemic effect whiteness and ability have had on their lives.”40 Since they do not distinguish between her amnesia as impairment and Ina cultural and traditional customs as fomenting disability, they exude a paternalism that becomes taxing for Shori to navigate. She must consistently remind them that her impairment has practical implications to which their cultural structures (such as the Council of Judgment or mating rituals) must adapt.41 She reminds them, “My memory goes back a few weeks and no further,” and the narration explicates her emotional response, “And because I was annoyed. I let my tone of voice say, You should all realize this. I’ve explained it before.”42 Further, they neglect to think of her Blackness as more than just the genetic engineering experimentation that allows her to be awake during the day. They consider her melanin useful as part of her physiology but do not think through the implications of how it creates her outsider status. The Gordons rank her identities: her Blackness as more beneficial, her amnesia as more pitiable, her Blackness as less important, her amnesia as less desirable. Their logic views the two identities as competitive in their narration of events: only one category requires their attention at any given time. Their priorities reveal how one identity, disability, is a problem for them that they can articulate. Her other identity, Blackness, is a problem to be sure, but one about which they cannot answer a word.43 Further, it stresses that their deliberate problematizing of one identity parses Blackness and madness for their own comfort. When Butler portrays Shori as frustrated in addition to misunderstood, she debunks the idea that all one must do is fuse the identities together. In other words, it is not necessarily a problem that the Gordons must strategize about Shori’s disability (especially since doing so will help save her life), but rather that they seek to strategize without fully understanding the disability itself (and how it is shaped by Blackness) and without her input. In this instance, Black madness cannot be agentive or radical or resistant all by itself. Shori’s mere presence cannot bear the weight of reorienting the narrative all on its own, nor can her behavior automatically shift the ideologies that govern her circumstances or change the people who helped create and sustain them (which, by default, includes the Gordon family). Instead, Butler’s work suggests that allies themselves must reconcile the competing tension between their own privileged positions and their desires for inclusivity. Though Shori can marshal her embodied knowledge to instruct others, she has limited success. The Gordons’ gaze functions similarly to that of Shori’s enemies. Their intimate interaction highlights that the difference between the two—that is, good intention—requires more labor on Shori’s part (which by itself curtails agency). She cannot dismiss the Gordons because they are not antagonists; instead, she must reframe the conversation to emphasize her position as potential daughter-in-law in need of assistance. When Shori reminds them, “So far [her] problem is ignorance, not dishonesty,”44 she splices impairment from disability and suggests listening as an integral facet of engagement. Yet her interactions with the older Gordons remain taxing and frustrating because their good intentions do not match the impact of their behavior. Their remarks—she is “somewhat arrogant” or she must “seem more Ina than [the antagonists],” or she is “both very attractive and very frightening”45—belie their weddedness to ableism, even as they attempt to help her navigate institutionalized barriers. It is up to them to shift their thinking, and it is not clear that ever occurs by the end of Fledgling. In Butler’s drafts of Fledgling, she toys with the way Shori’s Black madness structures her interactions with the Gordons and the text writ large. Each instantiation of the novel evinces Butler’s commitment to depicting Blackness and madness as destabilizing forces, which heighten and problematize privilege because they shift the contours of the multiability, interracial encounter. The two discourses work together and, in that sense, remain coextensive, but they also function at cross-purposes. For instance, Shori speculates that the Gordons test her when they allow her to question the human agents responsible for the arson that killed her family.