The conceptualization of the black cyborg ruptures whiteness’s frame of technology as the tool of the colonial master. Theorizing through the black cyborg is a tool for the becoming resists the assumption that technology is the province of white ingenuity and that technological engagement is incompatible with Black culture.
Gunn 20 [Caitlin Gunn is a feminist educator, researcher, and equity and diversity consultant currently operating in Minneapolis, Minnesota. She earned her doctorate in Feminist Studies from the University of Minnesota, Twin Cities. “Black Cyborgs: Blackness Narratives in Technology, Speculative Fiction, and Digital Cultures” published in June 2020 https://conservancy.umn.edu/bitstream/handle/11299/216885/Gunn_umn_0130E_21616.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y accessed on July 13, 2022 by AP]
In her article, “New Genres of Being Human: World Making through Viral Blackness,” Ashleigh Greene Wade’s approach is similar to Puar’s with its shared roots in assemblage theory and commitment to thinking through new frameworks for being. From an explicitly Black feminist framework, she calls in Sylvia Wynter and Wehilye to a discussion of assemblage in order to power her central argument: we have shifted into a new way of experiencing our own humanness and subjectivity, and it is an experience that fundamentally weaves our physical selves with our digital experiences. Weaving together Black techno-social practices and Black feminist notions of the human, Greene Wade produces a significant development toward theorizing the virtual-physical assemblage. Central to Greene Wade’s analysis is the idea of virality and viral Blackness. She names virality as “an affective condition in which content spreads widely, changing both the form of the original content and the channels through which it passes.” She calls upon Puar and Patricia Clough as interlocutors in the conversation of virality, citing their introduction to the Women’s Studies Quarterly volume devoted to the concept of virality which notes the spread of “viral” as a descriptor for things happening in biological, physical, financial, linguistic, and cultural realms. Greene Wade notes the fear that the word “viral” can evoke; the dominant use of viral is in discussion of spreading disease. While she urges us to expand beyond this fear and critically engage with the viral as a generative concept, I like to linger on the fear component of Black virality. The fear is essential for understanding how the Black viral has been tracked, surveilled, and covered: the white gaze looks upon Black viral phenomena with equal parts intrigue, confusion, and fear. Its effects are visible: social movements spring up, hashtags trend, bodies show up, information is shared. The methods remain opaque, rendered as invisible as a virus. As Greene Wade notes, the most terrifying aspect of viral Blackness is its uncontrollable nature: “Within the carceral state, containment is extremely important for maintaining control, but the viral cannot be contained. While the source of viral content can be located, once it is released, control societies cannot dictate how or where it spreads.” This uncontrollable, mutable, spreading form of viral Blackness manages to blend the boundaries between the virtual and physical, to muddy binaries, and to resist legibility to whiteness. The subversion of control found in viral Blackness is part of what I will argue makes Black feminist cyborgs so effectively able to travel worlds. When mutability and shape-shifting themselves assist, viral Blackness becomes a powerful tool for achieving and maintaining a sense of cultural control. The most critical aspect of the functioning of viral Blackness is the political force we are able to exert in digital spaces and manifest offline. Greene Wade asks us to consider the emergence of viral Blackness through #BlackLivesMatter (among other associated hashtags) and place it in the context of Black technological activism. She cites the mobilization efforts in 2014 around Ferguson, particularly organizing buses of protestors and funds and resources for protestors on the ground. She points to pre-social media periods, referencing events as far back as 1997, when Black women honed early Internet resources to organize the Million Woman March. In this project, I place this work in the framework of Anna Everett’s “Black technophilia,” the basic concept that Black people’s love for and skill with technology is neither rare nor deficient but is part of the tradition of Black people’s innovation in finding and creating tools for survival. In Greene Wade’s analysis, hashtags, viral videos, and images from Black protests and demonstrations are not only tools, but also “material artifacts of viral Blackness.” Greene Wade concludes her article by making the case that weak, appropriative, derivative hashtags stemming from #BlackLivesMatter serve to highlight the ways viral Blackness disquiets and disrupts white supremacy. #AllLivesMatter and #BlueLivesMatter, for instance, rest on outmoded and fixed identity categories. She issues a call: “We have to release Blackness from essentialism so that it may be deployed toward liberation within a multiplicity of subjectivities.” Moving toward conceiving of a Blackness that operates as a virtual-physical assemblage is part of that vision. Though Greene Wade does not mention cyborgs, I place this essay and Puar’s essay in conversation to illuminate my vision of the makeup of the cyborg: the Black feminist cyborg is a virtual-physical becoming-intersectional assemblage, slinking and changing from one world to the next, armored on digital platforms and able to shapeshift beyond the rigid grids of identity politics on technosocial platforms. This theory demands that we re-think what a cyborg is. In the intellectual tradition of Puar, conceptualizing a cyborg as humanity and technology gracelessly mashed together leaves us with an indelicate and relatively worthless metaphor. If we think about a cyborg as a new genre of being, the way Sylvia Wynter via Greene Wade ask us to think about humans, it prepares us to imagine the cyborg as a virtual-physical assemblage equipped to both travel through and make worlds for Black feminists who seek refuge, feminist discourse, and methods for moving through online spaces. The part-time Black feminist cyborg is able to move as Black women so often do: as part of a side-hustle, as part of an informal, widespread Black aesthetic devoted to hustling in the margins, seeking and performing community support and maintenance, gaining insight from other places and people to be repurposed toward Black excellence. The Black feminist cyborg side-hustle is one which pays in security, heightened ability, heightened perception, and occasionally heightened suffering. Though the “side hustle” is a language of labor, it is labor performed for self and community. I take Joy James’ critique of Black cyborgs operating as super-human seriously, and argue that the part-time nature of this aesthetic allows for breaks, rest, and centering of the self rather than super-human strength and performance to please and serve whiteness and white people. The part-time hustle allows for anonymity: no one need know about your alternate cyborg mode of being. If we are all to embody a new genre of being human and become virtual-physical assemblages, the part-time Black feminist cyborg theory serves as a method, a tool for the becoming. This concept quickly falls apart if there is commitment to the tool of technology as it has been traditionally discussed, even among feminist thinkers, as dominance and conquest through mechanical and digital means. Black feminist speculative fiction authors can offer us an alternative way of thinking through definitions of technology, often advocating a reassessment of what technology is, can be, and has been in the hands of Black people. In the interviews I conducted, I asked each participant two main questions related to the nature of technology: how have you conceived of or grappled with themes of technology in your speculative fiction work? And what would you consider the most dominant messages about Black people, bodies and technology that come from popular culture or mainstream speculative fiction? In response to the first question, participants frequently mentioned cyborgs, the steampunk genre as a space to toy with our preconceived notions, and expansive definitions of technology. Tempest K. Bradford responded: I mean, technically, again, the novel I’m writing now, it’s steampunk, so there is a technology in it even though it’s in the past. The technology is what is driving the commentary about social change[,] my commentary on 71 inequality[,] because in this story, it’s set in ancient Egypt. The steampunk elements are copper scarab beetles that are really big. People ride around in them and they run on the power of steam generated by sunlight. adrienne maree brown noted that she had grappled with themes of technology in her speculative fiction work “sort of flailingly? Like, I mostly imagine futures where technology is invisible or inside of us, cyborgish, enhancements. I also think of technology as how we do everything.” Encapsulating both themes, Walidah Imarisha comments on the whitewashing of the definition of technology and steampunk as a site of reproducing racist and colonial narratives, and as a means of expanding and responding to definitions of technology for Black survival: I think having conversations about what technology is, is also really important from the beginning. I think that we think of technology in a very Western, European white-centered frame. And so, I think that it’s important to recognize that a lot of the ways we think about technology... I think that steampunk is a genre [that] actually is a really useful way to sort of externalize the implicit conversations that often happen about technology— the way... that technology is intimately linked to colonialism and the global spread of white supremacy [in] this sort of white racist utopian fantasy that white folks create when they create steampunk. So. You know, I think, again, if technology is not a useful term, then we just don’t use that term. I do think it’s useful to challenge that idea and saying, well, what is our definition of technology? Technology is actually much broader than just externalized robotic gadgets that often are what we think of when we think of technology. So I think that’s one thing. I think the other thing, I definitely feel like I think about technology a lot. [I have] a couple pieces that center around [technology] that I’m working on. I’m actually working on developing a workshop that takes current developments and technology that folks think of as science fiction, but that are here now, and then has folks kind of imagine how this might be used against us in the future as folks try to change the world, because it will. And then develop potential strategies to challenge that… I don’t think we can deny the digital technological advances that exist in this world. I think we do so at our own peril. 72 In line with their thinking about expanding both ideas of technology and “cyborgish” ways of being, I find something productive and playful about imagining taking on the label of a cyborg, which requires being built, shaped, taken apart, and re-imagined in the face of oppression. There are deep resonances between descriptions of the cyborg and the experiences of being a Black woman: feeling like a being both out of time and somehow advanced, forced to travel worlds the way Lugones describes, continually being drawn both into the past and the future, losing limbs and gaining playfulness along the way. The cyborg concept has been considered by many feminist theorists in the decades since Haraway’s introduction and is increasingly relevant in the face of continuing technological advances. In TechnoFeminism, Judy Wajcman calls our attention to this fascination with the cyborg when she notes, “The cyborg has fired the feminist imagination. It crystalizes our pleasure in, desire for, and anxiety about technological transcendence. Perhaps this, and the infinite flexibility of what has become the postmodern icon, explains its rhetorical force.” Cyborg metaphors about the Black body and Black experience are present in literature, art, popular culture, and academic theory; indeed, Haraway specifically mentions the Black speculative fiction endeavors of Samuel Delany and Octavia Butler in her manifesto, appreciating them among other prolific feminist science fiction writers as “storytellers exploring what it means to be embodied in 73 high tech worlds,” and that they operate as “theorists for cyborgs.” Women of color is the category of coalition that Lugones writes about, framing their unique ability for worldtraveling as a result of marginalized positionality. The cyborg in Haraway’s conception is also portrayed as an ideal creature for moving “between worlds,” as Lugones describes them, or, into and out of the margins. Fused with technology and flesh, the vulnerability and adaptability of the cyborg allows for the variety of shifts in perspective required for moving between worlds—perception, vulnerability, and adaptability being kinds of technologies of their own. Moving into Digital Worlds The Black feminist cyborg resists the assumption that technology is the province of white ingenuity and intelligence, and that technological engagement is incompatible with Black people and Black culture. Claiming space in discourses of social technologies can push back against the limited kinds of knowledge production that people of color can produce that is legible within white supremacy. A modern cyborg still lives in a humandominated world with a very narrow conception of humanity. As Haraway acknowledges science fiction writers as cyborg theorists, I also turn to the writers I interviewed for their reflections on Black bodies and technology. Their contributions offer vital insights into both the genre of science fiction and real-world digital landscapes. Black women 74 operating as part-time cyborgs must move through these digital worlds, which provide new conditions for loving perception. A Black feminist cyborg is continually adapting to digital worlds where physical safety is less likely to be threatened and our access to one another is unprecedented. A Black feminist cyborg practical aesthetic is ideal for traveling to these worlds mediated through social media platforms, where we extend our Blackness beyond our physical bodies and simultaneously become aware of the embodied ways technology mediates and fuses with our lived realities. Black Cyborgs Moving Forward I have positioned the Black feminist cyborg as an ontological approach and a creature of fiction, but I would be remiss if I did not mention the rapidly closing gap between the cyborg as fiction and the cyborg as reality. In my interview with speculative fiction author Walidah Imarisha, the subject of bio-hacking was discussed in relationship to some of her latest writing and activist work. For example, she is in the process of developing a workshop which has participants think about concepts like bio-hacking, the import of technological and mechanical tools into one’s body, often imagined as science fiction but already part of reality, and strategize ways to combat their inevitable use against Black bodies. Her upcoming fictional work incorporates bio-hacking themes to underscore both the anxiety about technological additions to bodies and Black resistance 75 to methods of white social control over Black bodies. Citing facial recognition software newly employed in airports and the recent trend of corporations bio-hacking willing employees with identifying chips, she tells an oppositional story of a dystopic world in which characters are guided by self-implanted chips that point them in the direction of the North Star. In the interview, she describes the research she conducted for background in her story. She says, with both the excitement and trepidation that the idea of fusion with technology, especially for Black people, can bring: “The piece I was reading about was folks, like, bio-hacking themselves and becoming cyborgs! And getting superhero powers, basically. I was like, this shit is real, y’all, people are cyborgs right now!” Imarisha calls our attention to the narrowing divide between the cyborg as a creature of fiction and a creature of reality and imagines the way Black people can use technology to combat white supremacy. This speculative work through a Black feminist lens is imperative, because it challenges the notion that Black people can only interact with technology to serve white supremacist aims, and it rejects the erasure of Black people’s long, rich relationship with science and technology. It is transgressive in that it rejects the notion that Black people’s bodies and minds operate as machines and tools, having technology used on and through them. As I demonstrate in chapter four, Black people 76 harness the technological tools available to them and created by them. As social media drives much of Trump-era political discourse, Black people use it to facilitate cultural conversations, strategize for livable and desirable futures, and center the experiences of marginalized people. The Black feminist part-time cyborg aesthetic is a way to visualize the experience of moving in between the digital and physical, with room for both worlds. In the following chapter, I assess examples of world-traveling Black part-time cyborgs from popular media. These examples from Star Trek: Deep Space Nine and the discography of Janelle Monáe illuminate the way loving perception partnered with cyborg theory can provide a method for fruitful Black feminist world traveling, selfexpression, and play