Reject presumption- it relies on the logics of productivity and goal-oriented approaches that prevent other modes of being within debate.
Pickens 19 [Therí Alyce Pickens, Professor of English, specializing in African American, Arab America and disability literatures and theories at Bates University, June 7, 2019 “Black Madness :: Mad Blackness”, Duke University Press, Durham and London, pgs. 57-59, JMH]
Considering Black cultural contexts where mental illness and cognitive disability occur, the two major Western modes of interpretation—ocularity and (drawing on our earlier conversation) linear time—no longer retain the exclusive right to interpret meaning. The Black mad are, in some sense, no more. They becomce the mad Black. I theorize mad Black and mad Blackness as a formulation that disrupts the ocular and linear legacies of the West’s conception of space and time, respectively. To theorize the concept of the mad Black or mad Blackness opens up critical space to consider how the discourses of madness and Blackness not only operate in intraracial spaces but also intensify and dismantle common understandings of each other. When mad becomes a modifier for Black it carries with it the charge of excess (i.e., more Black, really Black, unapologetically Black, Blackity Black), anger, and insanity as it simultaneously functions as an intensifier for Blackness itself. In some ways, madness amplifies Blackness in this conception, pushing it to excess, but it also has the potential to dismantle it. Said potential lies precisely in the disruption of Western space and time. Sight no longer acts as the dominant mode of sense making. Linear progressions of time no longer capture the movement of subjects and objects through narrative. Mad Blackness fills in the gaps heretofore created by reading strategies (i.e., mutual constitution) that rely on these two Western modalities of interpretation. For instance, Octavia E. Butler’s mad Black character cleaves time from space with her very existence, such that the linear progressive narrative plane is disrupted. She also foregrounds the lie in thinking of the impeachability of sight as the dominant mode of interpretation. Her allies cannot see her illness. Their understanding based on sight—no matter its superlative quality— is impoverished. The mad Black then is not solely disruptive because of its embodiment. But also, the mad Black figure and mad Blackness stage a narratological intervention in how we analyze and tell stories about race and disability writ large. Mad Blackness describes the aesthetics of a text that refuses to adhere to ocularcentrism or linearity. In these texts—including but not limited to the ones in these conversations—madness and Blackness pervade the structure of the text such that linear renderings of the narrative always do a disservice to the text and an emphasis on sight forecloses interpretive possibility. To be clear, it is not that ocularcentrism and linearity are wholly inappropriate, but rather that they are explicitly incomplete due to the influence of madness and Blackness in the structure and characters of the text. As a result, mad Blackness necessarily critiques texts that de bnigrate madness or Blackness or both. Despite, and perhaps owing to, this disruptive quality, I would not define mad Blackness as a revolutionary force, nor would I expect mad Black figures to offer solutions. Their disruption—of interpretation, of narrative—does not require that they provide solutions, since that contrasts their suspicion of linearity and teleology, nor does it require that they be benevolent, since that often requires they be in service of those that create and maintain antiBlack ableist and sanist structures. This book, Black Madness :: Mad Blackness, is one such example of a mad Black text. As I mentioned, the conversations herein reveal critical conversations to themselves, and seek to perturb some of the foundations upon which Black studies and disability studies rest all while yoking them irrevocably together Nalo Hopkinson’s work in Midnight Robber (2000) theorizes this concept through her two mad Black figures (one who experiences mental illness and another, cognitive impairment) and her aesthetic commentary on narrative structure. Midnight Robber is not her only novel that explores the mad Black. Hopkinson’s oeuvre includes a variety of characters and plotlines influenced by or experiencing some form of madness peculiar to the worlds they inhabit. In Sister Mine (2013), one of Hopkinson’s main characters has a congenital magic defect. In The Chaos (2012), the entire world randomly changes so that rules of physics, metaphysics, climate, thermodynamics, and electricity no longer apply. Brown Girl in the Ring (1998) features a cadre of characters who do not share the reality of the community. The New Moon’s Arms (2007) wades into the territory of madness within a subplot about the main character’s origins. Hopkinson’s short stories in Skin Folk (2001), particularly “Tawny Bitch,” which depicts a woman in an asylum, also feature (and I mean that in the vernacular sense) mad Black characters and aesthetics.13 For the characters for whom this is an embodied reality, madness can be real or imagined. It tends to divide into the two categories described and parsed above: cognitive disability and mental illness. Cognitive impairment within the world of Hopkinson’s novels carries with it a sense of responsibility to the person experiencing the impairment. Those who have been perceived as having mental illness tend to be sequestered or isolated from a larger community either physically or emotionally. Determining soundness of mind crystallizes in our logophilic obsession with the book and the insistence on the unimpeachability of sight. Here—in this break—is where Nalo Hopkinson’s work becomes instructive.