Reject humanism- mad blackness overdetermines one’s ability to be a human in the first place.
Pickens 19 [Therí Alyce Pickens, Professor of English, specializing in African American, Arab America and disability literatures and theories at Bates University, June 7, 2019 “Black Madness :: Mad Blackness”, Duke University Press, Durham and London, pgs. 36-41, JMH]
In Butler’s drafts of Fledgling, she toys with the way Shori’s Black madness structures her interactions with the Gordons and the text writ large. Each instantiation of the novel evinces Butler’s commitment to depicting Blackness and madness as destabilizing forces, which heighten and problematize privilege because they shift the contours of the multiability, interracial encounter. The two discourses work together and, in that sense, remain coextensive, but they also function at cross-purposes. For instance, Shori speculates that the Gordons test her when they allow her to question the human agents responsible for the arson that killed her family.In Butler’s drafts, she experiments with how to split the questioning between Shori and the Gordons, and, in the final version, Butler settles on Shori’s silence. In the published version of Fledgling, Shori is only present to reassure the human agent and persuade him to tell the truth.46 The effect of these changes—displacing the Gordons as the primary interrogators—suggests that the difference is not merely about the space given to the Gordons but rather how Blackness and madness operate. In one draft, Shori interrogates the human agent. Here, her Blackness functions as a discomfiting presence for the human, a reminder and remainder of her difference that forces him to reveal the identity of the Ina agents. Making her the interrogator does not disappear her madness, but it does emphasize a soundness of mind that does not appear to be consonant with her understanding of being Ina, undermining her general authority over her amnesiac experience. In another draft, the Gordons serve as the primary interrogators. Here, her Blackness performs a similar discomfiting function. Her amnesia bolsters her authority over her own experience, even as it forms the basis for her being surveyed by the Gordons. Her madness, invisibilized though it may be, structures the interaction since the Gordons’ familiarity with other Ina allows them to ask leading questions of the human agent. By virtue of her amnesia, this s not an interrogation skill she can use. As a result, her silence in the face of her amnesia lingers as an answer to the Gordons’ skepticism about her, creating two interrogations. In these drafts, splitting the questions between Shori and the Gordons reorganizes how and why information about the attacks is given, clarifying that Shori’s Blackness and madness work on the interaction differently than the Gordons’ whiteness and presumed sanity. In the final version of Fledgling, since she is largely silent, Shori’s Black madness functions as a sustained pressure for the interrogation, emphasizing the Gordons’ privilege in relation to her. Whereas her Blackness shores up her utility during the questioning, her madness strips away her authority and autonomy because the Gordons take over the interrogation of the human agent and, without saying a word about her amnesia, create an interrogation of her. Though her race is recognized in both the draft and the final copy as a boon to helping them catch and coerce the human agents, the difference in interrogation technique allows for her madness to reveal the Gordons’ relationship to privilege. Recall that thinking about Blackness and madness as mutually constituted leads us toward reading the two identities as an avenue toward agency when they are located on the same body. I objected to this line of thought because it requires that Blackness operate as a stepping stone for imagining agency only available under certain material conditions and assumes that mere knowledge of one’s condition suffices as emancipatory. Butler’s novel and archive theorizes about this in contemplating the interplay of desire and madness. Butler writes several drafts of an interaction between Shori and Daniel Gordon where Daniel, lost in his own desire for Shori, invites her to bite him.47 In each draft, the invitation remains unspoken at first, functioning only as a matter of scent. He allows her to crawl all over him while they smell each other. The olfactory plays a large part in Ina attraction to either possible symbionts or other Ina. So, Daniel’s invitation to smell—especially since he has to keep himself from acting on sexual arousal caused by her scent—is dangerously coercive. It suggests sexual agency for Shori, but in fact it jeopardizes her life. Butler writes what appears in the final version: Daniel’s admission that he had hoped Shori’s memory was impaired enough to let her bite him. He says, “I half-hoped you would [bite], that maybe with your memory gone, you would simply give in to my scent, my nearness. If you had, well . . . If you had, no one could prevent our union. No one would even try.”48 What keeps her from such an action is her understanding that it might threaten her good standing at the Council of Judgment. In these scenes, Daniel remains silent at first and, later, forthcoming about his desires/intentions. His invitation is a test, one Shori must pass to prove her Ina-ness to other council members, a perception of her identity dependent on both her race and her impairment. This is not merely about Daniel’s desire but rather how his desire manifests as a form of ability that takes advantage of Shori’s impairment and bears repercussions for the perception of her identity. Operating along the axis of desire, Daniel’s craving of Shori microaggresses her by circumscribing her within parameters that facilitate her erasure. Microaggressions as a series of environmental, verbal, and nonverbal slights often fall into the category of unintended discrimination and often occur in intimate and/or interpersonal spaces. At times, this discrimination also comes from an affective space of benevolence, where one intends to be nice but instead reveals one’s own biases, ignorance, and desires. To read a microaggression, to understand it, is to analyze the break in the everyday since those moments prove revelatory about the microaggressor. Daniel intends to demonstrate desire and create intimacy, become Shori’s Ina lover, and concretize what he views as the eventual mating between their families. However, Shori is not old enough in Ina society or physiologically mature enough to mate, and her impairment renders her ignorant of social customs regarding interaction between Ina males and females. In addition, Daniel has made a decision about his desire to mate with Shori, whereas Shori’s ability to make such a decision must be—by virtue of her circumstances— delayed. Note the issue of time. Despite her enjoyment of Daniel’s scent, Shori does not control the marketplace of desire, making murky the possibility of consent. Daniel’s solicitation encourages her to break the rules and flirts with disaster given that they are on the cusp of a Council of Judgment meant to decide her fate.