The stigma that fatness inherently equals disability allows the media to perpetuate that fat, black people fall victim to the violence that they experience is due to a fault of their own and not the oppressive systems built against them
Mollow 17 (Anna Mollow, Doctor of Philosophy in English in the Graduate Division of the University of California, Berkeley (2017). Unvictimizable: Toward a Fat Black Disability Studies. African American Review, 50(2), 105–061. doi:10.1353/afa.2017.0016)
Those who defended Garner’s killers added another source of blame to an already familiar mix: Garner was fat. According to the New York Republican congressman Peter King, the chokehold was necessary because Garner was a “350- pound person who was resisting arrest.” Furthermore, King asserted, if Garner “had not had asthma and a heart condition and was[n’t] so obese, almost definitely he would not have died” (qtd. In Henderson). Here, fatphobia and ableism function as weapons of antiblack violence, allowing Garner to be blamed for his own death at the hands of police. In this essay, I argue that fatphobia is routinely deployed in ways that exacerbate the problem of state-sanctioned violence against African Americans. As we shall see, antifat prejudice, racism, and ableism intersect to create a double bind in which black people are depicted as unvictimizable for two contradictory reasons: black people—of all sizes, but fat black people in particular—are figured as innately disabled but also as invulnerable to disability, injury, or suffering. For example, defenders of the officers who killed Garner reproduced stereotypes of black bodies as inherently disabled when they insisted that fatness-induced disabilities—rather than a deadly police chokehold—caused Garner’s death. At the same time, Garner was portrayed as almost superhumanly invulnerable when Congressman King described him as a “350-pound person who was resisting arrest,” the implication being that Garner’s size made him so dangerous that deadly force was necessary to defuse the threat that he presented. In this and other tragic incidents that I discuss in this essay, fatphobia and ableism work in conjunction with racism to construct an ideological double bind that rhetorically positions black bodies as incapable of being victimized. One side of this double bind renders violence against black people inconsequential by suggesting that fatness is the real cause of any injuries inflicted upon them, while its other side depicts violence as a necessary response to the excessive physical power that black people, especially those who are fat, are imagined to embody.
This racialized double bind is not a new invention. In the U.S., it dates back to the era of slavery, when slave owners and their supporters contended that black people were so prone to physical and mental disabilities that they could not survive without the “protection” of their white owners—while at the same time maintaining that people of African descent possessed such inordinate strength that they did not suffer from the abuses that their enslavers imposed upon them.2 Today, discussions about race are less likely to explicitly invoke biological theories equating blackness with disability. More common is a discursive formation that some scholars call the “new racism,” which blames the social disadvantages that black people experience 105 African American Review 50.2 (Summer 2017): 105-121 © 2017 Saint Louis University and Johns Hopkins University Press not on biological impairments but instead on alleged moral failings, such as “laziness” and lack of “personal responsibility” (Collins).3 What is important is that the new racism has not replaced the old racism; instead, it repackages longstanding racist stereotypes to make them more palatable in a neoliberal, ostensibly “postracial” era (Collins 32-33). Fatphobia functions efficiently as a weapon of the new racism by enabling the adaptation of old ideas about black people’s supposed inborn physical deficiencies to a modern context, attributing the putative bodily pathology of “obesity” to moral shortcomings that are coded in racialized terms. Tellingly, the behaviors to which fatness is commonly attributed replicate stereotypes of black people as undisciplined and unable to control their appetites (Williams-Forson).
A central justification for stigmatizing fat people rests on two unexamined assumptions: that fatness is a choice, and that it typically leads to disability. Because fatness and disability are inseparably linked in the cultural imagination, it is impossible to adequately theorize antifat oppression without simultaneously attending to ableism. Nor, I will argue, can antiblack violence be sufficiently analyzed without examining the ways in which ableism and fatphobia reinforce longstanding constructions of black bodies as unvictimizable. We therefore need a methodology that takes measure of deeply imbricated relationships among racism, ableism, and fatphobia. Because no such theoretical apparatus currently exists, this essay begins conceptualizing a new, transdisciplinary methodology, which I provisionally term “fat black disability studies.” Fat black disability studies brings together four principal bodies of work: critical race theory, fat studies, disability studies, and the Black Lives Matter movement. While the present essay focuses on racialized state violence, this by no means exhausts the topics that fat black disability studies could illuminate. As I articulate my argument about the roles of fatphobia and ableism in sustaining antiblack state violence, I also sketch the contours of fat black disability studies, highlighting key insights within the multiple disciplines that compose it: critical race theory’s concept of intersectionality, fat studies’ contestation of the medicalization of fatness, disability studies’ analyses of social constructions of “health,” and Black Lives Matter’s demonstration of the ways in which police brutality is fueled by other, often unrecognized, forms of antiblack violence.