Even if debate is a game, you should transform it into a mad game challenges projections of ableist violence into the space
Cecilia Rodéhn 22 Aassociate professor and a senior lecturer at the Centre for Gender Research and Department of Game Design, Uppsala University, 2022, Introducing Mad Studies and Mad Reading to Game Studies, -ekh-]
A mad reading of games seeks to identify the workings of normative ableist discourses in texts and how sanism is conflated with other oppressive regimes. The purpose is to interrupt and resist sanism. Investigating representations of sanism is also a good starting point for the exploration of madness. The reason for this is that many representations of madness in games are sanist. This means that madness often appears through the lens of sanism, and sanism is seen through madness in games. However, there isn’t just one kind of sanism in games, which I shall now discuss.
In many games, mental illness is embodied by male characters (cf. Shapiro and Rotter, 2016, p. 1594). This is perhaps no surprise, seeing that men are overall overrepresented in games at large (cf. Taylor & Voorhees, 2018). Male characters with mental illness are often portrayed as violent, psychotic, and homicidal maniacs (Shapiro & Rotter, 2016, p. 1594; Ferrari et al., 2019, p. 6). Violent behaviour is often associated with masculinity in games, but games portray a kind of masculinity where violence is expressed as controlled by an often emotionally stoic character. Male characters with mental illness are often contrasted with this stoic masculinity. For instance, Scarecrow in the action-adventure game Batman: Arkham Knight (Rocksteady Studios, 2015) exhibits erratic, emotional, and unpredictable behaviour, and the patients in Mount Massive Asylum in the first-person survival horror game Outlast (Red Barrells, 2013) are represented as both catatonic and scared or as butchering the staff and raping corpses.
Women, on the other hand, are often represented as victims and/ or patients of psychiatric facilities in games (Shapiro & Rotter, 2016, pp. 1592-1594). These depictions can be connected to the tradition of objectifying women in games and portraying them as passive and/ or damsels in distress. A recent trend in games is to present girls as those dealing with mental illness, such as in platform-adventure game Gris (Nomada Studio, 2018), the platform role-playing video game Child of Light (Ubisoft Montreal, 2014) and the platform video game Celeste (Matt Makes Games, 2018). Representing mental illness using children as a metaphor offers possibilities to highlight the vulnerability of the person suffering from mental illness, but this is problematic due to a long tradition of portraying the relationship between doctors/nurses and mental patients as one of a parent to a child. In addition, China Mills and Brenda Lefrançois shows that the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM-V), which is a manual that classifies and explains illnesses and behaviours and functions as a handbook for health care services, lists “childishness” and “childlike behaviour” in adults as a symptom of mental illness (Mills & Lefrançois, 2018, p. 512). Furthermore, psychiatric discourse marks people experiencing mental illness as underdeveloped or wrongly developed (Mills & Lefrançois, 2018, p. 504). Representing mental illness as a child or through a child’s perspective unfortunately works to reproduce discourses of mental patients as infantilized.
Sanism also needs to be positioned in relation to issues of race and ethnicity since stereotypes of mental illness are often conflated with stereotypes of race and ethnicity (Rodéhn, 2020). Research shows that there is a history of denoting Jewish and African American groups as predestined for madness, revealing that race, ethnicity, and madness are conflated in cultural representations (Gilman 1985, pp. 24-25, 162). For instance, Blackness has been considered as equal to madness, and blackness became a prerequisite for the social constructions of madness (Pickens, 2019, p. 4). I suggest that this construction of Blackness is the source for why Black men have been portrayed as irrational, unpredictable, and violent in games. An example of this is the pirate lord Vaas Montenegro in the first-person shooter game Far Cry 3 (Ubisoft Montreal, 2012), who is depicted as loud, erratic, sadistic, and violent.
Adrienne Shaw shows that Black and indigenous women are almost non-existent in games, and when portrayed, they are often depicted as abuse victims (Shaw 2014, p. 21). In popular culture, Black women are commonly portrayed as lazy, slow-minded or angry and/or seductive, which are also characteristics used to represent people diagnosed with mental illness (Mollow 2006). The way sanism is intertwined with colonization and racism needs special attention because when sanism is visited on racialized bodies it is especially devastating (Meerai, Abdillahi & Poole, 2016, p. 22). Characterizations of mental illness in video games, where the character is explained as having a diagnosis or illness, occurs more among characters that are white and male. This suggests that white people are represented as suffering from a condition, whereas Black people are merely represented as erratic and violent.
Furthermore, it is common that queer and transgender characters are represented as mentally unstable in games. One example of this is the character Reni Wassulmaier, introduced in action-adventure game Grand Theft Auto: Liberty City Stories (Rock Star Games, 2005) and reappearing in Grand Theft Auto: Vice City Stories (Rock Star Games, 2006). Reni Wassulmaier is portrayed as a prostitute and a porn star. Reni was assigned female at birth, but they go through four gender confirmation surgeries: female-to-male, male-to-female, female-tomale again, and then male-to-female again. This transphobic representation, parodying the process of gender confirmation surgery, works to portray Reni Wassulmaier as mad and as having erratic behaviour -- not being able to decide on a gender. The result of this is that queerness is represented as madness and madness as queerness. The connection between madness and queerness is not new; there is a history of pathologizing and diagnosing transgender people in, for instance, the Diagnostic and Statistic Manual of Mental Disorders. The conflation can also be seen in terms of sexuality. Reni Wassulmaier is characterized as a mad seductress, trying to seduce every man they meet in all different kinds of situations. Shapiro and Rotter show that the appropriation of the mad seductress trope is well-established in media and used as a way to connect feminine and female sexuality to madness (Shapiro & Rotter, 2016). In Grand Theft Auto, the trope is used to portray Reni’s madness and reveal the tendencies to pathologize femininity and feminine sexuality as performed outside the boundaries of heteronormativity.
I suggest that, to expose and resist sanism, the following questions can be useful guidelines to conduct a mad reading of games: (1) What normative discourses produce madness in the game that is being studied, and how are these representations connected to other oppressive ideologies? (2) What kind of madness does the intersection of sanism and other oppressive ideologies produce?