Analysis of debility is key to understand the ways in which Black Women are coded as “angry, restless” and in need of “healing”.
Knadler 19 - ( Stephen Knadler; Stephen Knadler is an associate professor of English at Spelman College, where he teaches US literature and cultural studies. He has been published in American Literature, American Literary History, American Quarterly, Minnesota Review, and Modern Fiction Studies.; Originally published: August 6, 2019; “Vitality politics : health, debility, and the limits of black emancipation”; http://link.umsl.edu/portal/Vitality-politics--health-debility-and-the/n6SXiAQq3achttp://library.lol/main/D8D265377A8F7623EB4F5A75223D22AB) Dōgen
Most of the action in The Chinaberry Tree occurs in the past time of the novel and is over when the story opens as the characters struggle to move beyond its traumatic consequences. The novel’s recovery plot, thus, builds its suspense on the question of the “redemption,” or, in the medicalized terms of the novel, “healing” and rehabilitation, of the two main protagonists: Laurentine Strange and her cousin Melissa Paul. In the backstory of the novel Sal Strange, Laurentine’s mother, had a scandalous affair with a white man, Colonel Halloway, who moved her from Alabama to set her up in a beautiful house with a chinaberry tree in Red Brook, New Jersey. Although Sal and Colonel Halloway’s sexual union recalls the familiar story of the plantation master’s sexual exploitation of his kept slave mistress, Aunt Sal insists that her relation with the now deceased Colonel Halloway was a “love story” and “she to this day still loves him” (2). After the birth of Laurentine, “Aunt Sal,” as she is generally called, remains a “maladjusted,” overly sensitive, tragic mulatta, ostracized from both the white and Black communities of the town who condemn her as having “vicious” or “bad blood,” thus seeing her moral impropriety as resulting, as an earlier race psychology maintained, from hereditary character defects. When Laurentine was a young girl, however, her mother’s sister Judy came to stay in Red Brook and temporarily relieved the family’s isolation. During Judy’s visit to Red Brook, she has an affair with the husband of one of her friends, Sylvester Forten, which results in the birth of another “illegitimate” daughter, Melissa Paul, who later, in the present time of the novel, falls in love and plans to wed unwittingly her half brother Malory Forten. Like Maggie in There Is Confusion, Melissa is a class outsider who has a “morbid” and restless ambition to be part of “larger and more brilliant settings” within the exclusive circles of the town’s Black bourgeois elite (71), and, as a consequence, she initially declines marriage with the “essentially sound” southerner Asshur Lane because she insists on wedding a wealthy and socially prominent man, Malory Forten (337). In the novel’s denouement, the “secrets” of the past are finally revealed, including that Maggie and Malory are half brothers and sisters. But if such a tragic disclosure of possible incest might have permanently broken the “strange” women, both Laurentine and Melissa are “adjusted” to a “healthy wellbeing” (medical language that Fauset herself uses) by the men in their lives (120): first, Dr. Denleigh, a former head of the National Medical Association, who heals Laurentine of her “melancholy” (113), and, second, Asshur Lane, whose “fine, sweet sanity, a strength,” in the novel’s final tableau under the chinaberry tree ensures Melissa’s recovery from her own feverish “morbid” desires that nearly caused her to break unwittingly one of the most fundamental taboos (336). Although Fauset’s The Chinaberry Tree follows once again the medicalized recovery narrative of social psychology that we saw in There Is Confusion, in which the restless, angry Black woman (Melissa) must be cured by the good Black man’s “sweet sanity,” I want to focus on the rehabilitation storyline of the novel’s other main female protagonist, Laurentine Strange, for what it reveals about the complex biopolitics of Black women’s depression in the Jim Crow United States. Throughout the novel Laurentine is depicted variously as “melancholy” (113), as having an “irregular” life (69), as highly sensitive and “withdrawn to herself ” (19), as full of “restlessness” and “hopeless brooding” (98), and “sick” with “hopelessness.” Although the plot traces out how she learns to become “more normal” (98) once she is taken under the wing of Dr. and Mrs. Ismay (herself a trained nurse from Boston) and is courted by Dr. Denleigh, once again Fauset creates a contradictory novel in which there is more meaning in the “disorder” than in the cure, and indeed the novel blurs the boundaries between social psychology’s distinctions between maladjustment and integration, disorder and rehabilitation. Laurentine’s cure, Fauset implies, is forced, artificial, and silencing of the way that Black women like Laurentine speak and witness through their mental distress and pain. As Fauset demonstrates, Black women’s depression, whatever biochemical (or blood) roots may be behind it, is embedded within the unequal gendered and racial relations that Black women daily “weather” and which define their proper, “good” feminine identity. I want to look for a moment at Fauset’s description of Laurentine’s “bitter and futile life” before she is rescued by Dr. Denleigh for what it says about Laurentine’s “strange” character, and for what it says about Black women’s “strange” or “mad politics” of mental distress: But she [Laurentine] was sick. Sick not only with wounded pride and bewilderment, but with something far worse than that— hopelessness. For what could she expect? She would live like this always, seeing herself ripen, ripen—she was twenty-four, there were many years of cruel, burning, unsatisfied life still before her. Yes, she would ripen—some poet had said it—“ripen, fall and cease.” It would be exactly as though she had never been; like a leaf that had fallen too early; like a flower that someone had picked and deliberately thrown away,—no worse, had carelessly dropped to be trampled on, withered. So had her mother and Colonel Halloway dropped her and she was being trampled on, withered. (61–62) In the language describing Laurentine’s depression, Fauset indicates that her “pathology” is her body’s way of speaking, doubting, and trying to repress feelings and thoughts that are at odds with the “healthy” “sane” forms of respectable Black womanhood. Although Laurentine does not acknowledge the source of the poetic refrain that organizes her meditation, the line “ripen, fall, and cease” comes from Alfred Lord Tennyson’s “The Lotus Eaters” and refers to the temptation of the sailors to renounce the hard life of the sea to remain in the seductive tranquility of the home of the “lotus.” The irony here is that Fauset/Laurentine correlates the futile “numbing” life to the domestic scene (not the sea) and to the respectability expected of “good” race women. In contrast to this “good” and “unsensational/unfelt” life, however, is the “unsatisfied burning” (willed, angry, sexual) that Laurentine cannot act on due to codes of gender, race, and class imposed on Black women. Instead, she feels as if she can only ripen unfulfilled and “cease.” Thus, Laurentine’s depression, social withdrawal, and fatigue are, Fauset implies, both a sign of mental distress and a complex expression of insight: an anxiety and hopelessness voicing her frustration and inability to act in the face of systematic oppressions (whether those oppression are the everyday nerve-wrecking psychological maimings imposed by white supremacism, or the codes of respectability placed on Black women). As a result, Laurentine turns her anger inward. In this scene, Fauset traces out a new language of Black women’s depression that identifies it not as emptiness within, but as a violence imposed from without on Black women’s vitality, or their flowering into themselves.