Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Their analysis of vulnerability ignores the disabling nature of racial-sexual violence, an ontologically unspeakable moment – their model trades off with collective falling apart and fracturing, moments of dissociation that are necessary to enact a radical care

Alyson K. Spurgas 21 [Solidarity in Falling Apart: Toward a Crip, Collectivist, and Justice-Seeking Theory of Feminine Fracture, Cripistemologies of Crisis: Emergent Knowledges for the Present, Issue 10.1 (Spring 2021), https://csalateral.org/section/cripistemologies-of-crisis/solidarity-falling-apart-toward-crip-collectivist-justice-theory-feminine-fracture-spurgas/, -ekh-]

In 1992, psychiatrist Judith Herman published Trauma and Recovery: The Aftermath of Violence—From Domestic Abuse to Political Terror. In this important intervention, Herman argued that the trauma that results from domestic violence and sexual assault, as part of patriarchal aggression, constitutes a type of political violence or even gendered terrorism. As it also tends to be quite commonplace yet simultaneously hidden from view (and thus complicated and insidious in its effects), Herman made the case that the traumatic symptomology that follows from domestic violence and sexual assault must be reconceptualized—thus heralding the shift from post-traumatic stress disorder, or PTSD (which had up to that point been reserved primarily for the “shell shock” experienced by soldiers in war), to complex post-traumatic stress disorder, or C-PTSD. C-PTSD was to be understood as distinct from PTSD in part because “the syndrome [or spectrum of conditions] that follows upon prolonged, repeated trauma needs its own name.” The most important aspects to note about the shift to C-PTSD include the following: 1) sexual trauma is most often gendered and specifically feminized as it is disproportionately experienced by women, 2) one of the most notable and common symptoms of this feminized trauma is dissociation, or the splitting of consciousness as a protective mechanism (as it has been since early Freudian formulations of hysteria and other feminine neuroses), and 3) the symptoms of dissociation and other traumatic sequelae may be ordinary, ongoing, and quite literally complex. In explicating this shift, Herman brought gendered and sexualized violence into mainstream psychological and therapeutic conversations and illuminated their inherently structural nature. C-PTSD arguably brought thinking on trauma closer to the chronic, as well, as it attended to the effects of prolonged exposure to violence. Herman staunchly advocated that the conceptual groundwork of trauma must account for the minutiae of the everyday life of domestic violence victims, which subsequently illuminated how so many forms of gendered trauma are “not outside the range” of normal human experience, and are not exceptional. For Herman, too much of what happens in the home, in the bedroom, and on the street might be seriously dangerous and traumatizing to women, in particular. The personal is political.

One of the most common symptoms of trauma, in Herman’s analysis as in others, is the dissociative silence that accompanies it. C-PTSD then still remains within the traditional psychoanalytic trauma theory framework, relegating trauma to that which cannot be narrated, categorically. So, although Herman placed trauma itself squarely within the sociopolitical, she did not question the ontological status of trauma’s unspeakability—understood to be the result of a temporal split and the subsequent need for psychic defense due to an experience that was quite literally unthinkable and thus also unsayable. In this essay, I question trauma’s fundamental inability to be spoken of or even adequately recounted by survivors. Is trauma unnarratable by nature, or are traumatized people instead just too often part of communities that are either ignored or actively silenced? To this end, I propose that trauma’s unnarratability is not fundamental nor ontological, but rather political and structural. And this may be particularly true for the feminized trauma that results from domestic violence, sexual assault, and other gendered—and, importantly here, racialized—aggressions.

As revolutionary as it was at the time, Herman’s reframing was also insufficient in attending to the full breadth of trauma responses across experiences of gender and femininity (i.e., cis, trans, nonbinary, agender, genderqueer, etc.), and experiences related to race, class, nation, and citizenship. Dissociation, still centered in Herman’s C-PTSD framework, has become the sine qua non of trauma and has been treated as necessary for trauma to register as legible and legitimate—but arguably not all trauma survivors experience dissociation, or experience it in the same way. This de facto requirement is also troublesome insofar as the very same folks whose credibility is regularly questioned as it is (i.e., women—especially trans women—of color, first and foremost) are viewed as non-credible if they do not exhibit this symptom. Further, even as dissociative and other traumatic symptomology are conceptualized as ongoing and everyday in Herman’s updated C-PTSD model, they are still framed as ills that can be overcome, rehabilitated, and even cured. And recovery here entails being able to reconnect the disconnected parts of the dissociated (and unspeakable) self, often through medicalized and individualized therapeutic modalities. It is because of the inadequacies of this continued framing of trauma as unspeakable, the centering of dissociation as the categorically legitimate response to gendered and sexualized violence (often evacuated of race, class, and nation), and an emphasis on individualized recovery under neoliberalism, that I argue we must reconsider and reformulate notions of feminized trauma. Attending to the range of ways in which violence is meted out and experienced will help us to listen to survivors without presuming their inability to communicate. And this can help promote a new and politicized understanding of trauma, and pave the way toward more just forms of collective and communal care. 

My analysis moves between theoretical and conceptual registers and discussions of various types of data (i.e., historical and contemporary scientific discourse, tweets and other media-based accounts, and autoethnographic narrative) and illustrates the type of fracturing or falling apart that I describe as a legitimate trauma response. Not fully dissociative, but a little all over the place. Sometimes declarative, sometimes interrogative—at moments “feral.” This fractured method suggests the difficulty (but not impossibility) of communicating everyday trauma. It is repetitive, fragmentary, and at times frustrated—a banal collage of dull anger and pain (including anger at the silencing of so many others). Asking questions, I argue, can help open up space for radical intervention and reframing. So when I ask questions, the intervention I propose is, in part, enacted in the asking. This method is not only a form of inquiry and interrogation but also of recognition—the recognition that some things, some very important parts of the story, have been missing and should be heard.

In the remainder of this essay, I argue that even as we have moved toward thinking of gendered and sexual violence and their traumatic aftermaths as political and structural (and as psychologists have gotten better at accounting for these types of violence and their effects), we still too often operate within a reductive logic regarding femininity that is ultimately unjust insofar as legitimate trauma becomes relegated to a certain demographic, and only that type of trauma experience is legible as suffering. Further problematic is that, under this prevailing logic, the type of feminine suffering that is most clearly legible is that which follows from violences framed as “exceptional” (as opposed to the suffering of those who are not victims of “stranger rape,” incest, or abuse “at home”). Most often, survivors (even under Herman’s improved formulation) are imagined to be white and wealthy or middle-class—and their treatment is targeted as such. Given all of this, I argue that we must responsibly ask: What symptoms might we observe if and when we recognize that many traumatized folks do not have recourse to diagnosis, to treatment, and, in some cases, do not even have the time or space to dissociate? (Let alone to recover?)

In response to the historical and contemporary whitewashing, cisheteronormativity, and class reductiveness of psychological frameworks of feminized trauma, I re-theorize the symptomology and sequelae of gendered and sexual violence alongside recent conceptualizations of insidious trauma, crisis ordinariness, debility, chrononormativity, slow violence, and slow death. With an eye toward the liberation of groups whose experiences are often minimized or blatantly ignored, I argue that traumatic symptomology such as dissociation ought to be re-read through the lenses of critical disability studies and, more specifically, crip-of-color and feminist-of-color disability studies—which offer novel ways to consider the imbrication of minds, bodies, and the social. These frames are oriented toward structural critique, and move us beyond traditional formulations of the psychosomatic, bringing us closer to an understanding of the environmental, relational, and often traumatic constitution of bodyminds in the world. Such an orientation is imperative in that it allows for deeper attention to how race, class, citizenship, and other intersecting statuses contour feminized trauma and symptoms across gendered populations.

An increased attention to multivalent structural inequities within recent work coming out of disability studies is exciting and noteworthy. However, disability studies has historically had its own problems with a reductive and bourgeois whiteness. Thus, Black feminist theory’s attention to productions of gender, femininity, and sexual difference, and to how these feel, necessarily helps reconceptualize feminized trauma. Black women (and particularly Black trans women) tend to have more frequent experiences of both macro traumas caused by clearly identifiable forms of violence and the more mundane, banal, and gnawing forms caused by everyday violations. I am informed by radical Black feminist scholarship that considers Black feminism and Black femininity as affective, as felt, as lived—sometimes defensively (out of necessity and toward an [often obstructed] agency)—in everyday environments that are traumatizing and debilitating insofar as they are saturated with racism, sexism, misogyny, and misogynoir, and which condone and perpetuate Black unfreedom, violation, death, and harm (and/or threats thereof). Audre Lorde and, more recently, Treva Ellison, Amber Musser, Jennifer Nash, Sami Schalk, and C. Riley Snorton have theorized how structural racialized and gendered violence contributes to traumatic Black feminine subject formation. These scholars consider how (sometimes negative) affects associated with Black femininity inhere in subjects but are, in fact, produced within white supremacist, colonialist, misogynistic, transphobic, and otherwise toxic environments and relations wherein Black women are regularly injured—and then expected to heal themselves.

Historically through today, dominant psycho-logics have perpetuated racist, classist, and imperialist conceptualizations of femininity itself. Simone Brown utilizes the concept white prototypicality to theorize the racialized normativity of biometrics (such as fingerprinting and other forms of surveillance). Elsewhere, I have critiqued the ways that medical and scientific protocols both depend on and simultaneously disavow feminized trauma as they attempt to explain white feminine sexual “receptivity,” “responsiveness,” and “discordance” in depoliticized behaviorist and evolutionary terms. Following Browne and other Black feminist scholars cited above, in this essay I consider how trauma frameworks are constituted within registers of racial normativity—a type of white prototypicality that dwells within the dominant psycho-logic for interpreting gendered and sexualized trauma. Given this white prototypicality, I seek new ways to understand feminized trauma experiences outside of both contemporary psychological frameworks and traditional psychoanalytic conventions. I foreground traumatic affects as they are lived at the level of raced, classed, and gendered populations, while simultaneously reconceptualizing how traumas are felt at the level of individual bodies and relationally among them. My intervention is threefold:

First, I suggest that, because sexual and gendered violence is directed disparately (both quantitatively and qualitatively) at groups of femmes which are internally diverse, trauma responses also necessarily look different across these populations. Feminized trauma must then be rethought, particularly when violence is slow, grating, cumulative, and disconcertingly ordinary and normalized to the point that it is expected—rather than posited as abnormal, exceptional, and something that can be healed from individually. Traditional psychological approaches to diagnosing and treating trauma are not only limited to race-, class-, nation-, and gender-specific subjects, but, in fact, produce and configure traumatized subjects as only intelligible when they fit within these boundaries. 

Secondly, once trauma (as it is experienced by many feminized folk) is reconceived as banal, mundane, and chronic, I open up space for acknowledging, valuing, and centering a traumatic dissociative-adjacent standpoint (or sitpoint). Absent in mainstream psychological frameworks for interpreting feminized trauma, this is an invaluable perspective on sexual and gendered violence from which much can be learned. 

Finally, within a disability justice framework, I advocate that this traumatized femme perspective, epistemology, and form of knowledge-production provides the ground upon which survivors who live with raced, classed, and gendered trauma can come together as they enact radical care in community with each other, fracturing and falling apart together. My analysis seeks to illuminate the full spectrum of feminized trauma experience and amplify accounts rather than assuming unnarratibility. To this end, the notion that trauma is ontologically unspeakable must be called out for what it is—a form of silencing that is undoubtedly structural and political. Women and femmes—and here they are grouped together insofar as I am describing feminizing processes rather than femme identities, per se—have been silenced, including when they try to speak of their traumas (or feel and register them outwardly, publicly). Creating space—and a fleshy and affective language of sorts—to narrate endured violences is part of an abolitionist justice project and can help to end expectations of silence. I argue that this will offer a different type of healing, as well, one that is not tied to individual rehabilitation, but which instead allows fractured populations—both fractured from traumas (but not fully split) and fractured along raced, classed, and gendered lines—to stand in solidarity and feel differently (not “better” in the vein of neoliberal productivity) together. With such a goal in mind, I argue that even a C-PTSD-based therapy and analysis framework is inadequate for fully attending to the insidious nature of everyday traumas, and that instead, a crip theory of feminized fracture or falling apart will help us move beyond the limitations of both PTSD and C-PTSD and their treatment. This affect-attendant, justice-seeking, cripistemological orientation to the multiplicity of traumatic iterations counters previous myopic formulations of trauma and its symptoms, and empowers and gives voice to those who are traumatized.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.