Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Hyper alertness creates a threadbare life representative of an unfinished psychic split that questions of vulnerability never resolve – the framing of violence as “resolvable” ignores the ontological nature of sexual violence

Alyson K. Spurgas 21 [Solidarity in Falling Apart: Toward a Crip, Collectivist, and Justice-Seeking Theory of Feminine Fracture, Cripistemologies of Crisis: Emergent Knowledges for the Present, Issue 10.1 (Spring 2021), https://csalateral.org/section/cripistemologies-of-crisis/solidarity-falling-apart-toward-crip-collectivist-justice-theory-feminine-fracture-spurgas/, -ekh-]

Insofar as dissociation was often comorbid with a diagnosis of hysteria for early psychoanalysts like Freud and Josef Breuer, there is a long history (or hystery) of dissociation as feminized, or as part of a sequelae of feminine neuroses. But if we take seriously that women are more likely to dissociate, we must also follow the earliest Freud and remember that this occurs so often in women (and here, I will add femmes more broadly to update Freud’s argument) due to their disproportionate experiences of sexual violence and abuse. Today, women and femmes continue to be unduly violated, and trans women, particularly Black trans women and other femmes of color, are disproportionately likely to experience violence—including sexual violence—during their lives. Further, current research suggests that while 6.8% of the general adult population in the United States report symptoms of PTSD, prevalence estimates of trauma among trans folks range from 18% to 61%—and according to recent studies, discrimination and assault associated purely with being trans (rather than with exogenous experiences such as sexual abuse) significantly amplify PTSD symptoms among transgender folks. These symptoms are, of course, exacerbated when intersecting experiences of oppression are at play. Given these disparities in proximity to trauma, and because we are in an age of ever-present yet unspectacular harm, I argue that we are also in a moment in which it is imperative to rethink structures of gender, race, class, and nation as structures of feeling  which are ontologically shaped by closeness to supremacist state violence. It is time to reconceptualize sexual and gendered trauma, the logic of dissociation, and the affective structure of femininity itself.

If part of living as a femme-identified or femme-coded individual—and particularly as a Black woman or femme of color—involves living with apprehension, hyper-alertness, and the daily specter of anticipated violence, then how does this affect symptomology? What do symptoms look like when they are the result of banal, chronic, slow violence? If they follow from everyday, grey brutality and ordinary crises? What if there is a detachment, but it is not a full rupture, and instead . . . fragmentary? Always bubbling up, but never completely coming to the surface, an embodied-psychic stretching, to the point where the bodymind feels threadbare . . . never fully numb, but never fully (or hyper-) vigilant. Maybe the dissociative-adjacent symptom looks instead like anxiety, or it’s akin to brain fog—pervasive, yet partial—or it’s the perpetual feeling that you’re about to fall apart, to come unglued. Maybe it’s having a constant lump in your throat, a racing heartbeat, and radiating tension while also feeling utterly empty and dazed when you read the news, when you are out on the street. Maybe the psychic split is never finished—a fracture, fleshed-over . . . semi-sutured . . . but never fully severed? 

Not only might we ask what this shift to a new framework for trauma symptomology looks like, how it presents, but also: what knowledge does shifting from breaking / splitting to fracturing / falling apart make possible? And legible? Feminine fracture then is both symptom and standpoint/sitpoint. But if it is a standpoint/sitpoint, maybe it is also a rallying point . . . and even a rallying cry. 

To begin this project of fleshing feminine fracture, we might take the experience of dissociative-adjacency as a point from which to theorize. Returning again to early psychoanalysis, I propose that we do this in the vein of Freud’s and Breuer’s notion of hysteria as an altered state of consciousness, as, in fact, double consciousness. This notion is particularly apt here as it shares many uncanny epistemological and phenomenological assumptions with double consciousness as it has been theorized by W. E. B. Du Bois and later as bifurcation of consciousness by Dorothy Smith. And most usefully, Black feminist scholars such as Patricia Hill Collins and Kimberlé Crenshaw have utilized intersectional analyses to bring these frameworks together. I follow the work of Jennifer Nash and Jasbir Puar who consider (in addition to the feeling of being multiply marginalized) how intersectionality might be experienced affectively, and what types of feelings “becoming-intersectional” and being forced into a defensive posture around intersectionality elicit. This ontological orientation to intersectionality-as-event can help illuminate how a traumatic double consciousness as sequelae of gendered and sexual violence is inextricable from racism and white supremacy. How might we honor this feminized, racialized, and classed experience while simultaneously taking care not to essentialize or universalize it? How is a traumatic double consciousness kindred with fracturing and falling apart? In our contemporary climate of slow violence and crisis ordinariness, how do these ways of knowing, feeling, and living trauma manifest? And how are they contoured by difference—including the difference that race makes?

In April 2020, during the COVID-19 pandemic, Latina trans activist Lorena Borjas fell ill with the virus and passed away, leaving a deep and painful void in her community. In a tribute to Borjas’s life, another NYC-based activist and writer, Cecilia Gentili, articulates a type of feminized traumatic experience that feels chronic, heavy, ossified, sedimented:

Many of us have been forsaken by our families, found ourselves homeless and deprived of support from teachers, co-workers, and employers. We’ve lived through extreme poverty—have made cohabitation with risk and danger part of our normal. Transgender women of color—like she was, like I am—know the uncertainty of taking each step as if it may be our last. We know the weariness of walking under the weight of transphobia, racism, and misogyny.

The burden described here might not be easy to recover from; one might be more likely to feel as though she will fall apart beneath it. In order to get closer to feeling/understanding/recognizing falling apart—an experience akin to dissociation, derealization, and depersonalization but not quite the same thing—I propose that, in addition to embracing a traumatic or hysterical double consciousness, we work backward. Here, a cripistemology of feminine fracturing or falling apart has a kinship with both double consciousness and feeling backward, which might involve an “embracing of loss and risking of abjection”—and deeply resonates with what Gentili describes above. This kinship is clear, in that a traumatic or hysterical double consciousness, feeling backward, and feminine fracturing and falling apart all fuck with time and space. They alter our perception, allow for altered perception, and provide new forms of affective knowledge through altered perception, and what it makes intelligible. This has direct import for reconceptualizing trauma and its sequelae. Fracturing and falling apart, alongside traumatic/hysterical double consciousness and feeling backward, all expand how we interpret feminized trauma, as they are standpoints/sitpoints which are explicitly anti-chrononormative. 

An imagined place of recovery can be a starting point from which to work in order to better understand the experience of feminized trauma—particularly insofar as the injury that is feminized trauma is, in part, constituted by the non-negotiable injunction to recover. Recovery and rehabilitation are normative processes, which involve taking individual action—but trauma, as it is traditionally framed, is “paralyzing,” even “crippling.” So, once again, we have a paradox. But if we conceive of paralysis and crippling outside of this individualizing logic of recovery, beyond the logic of unnarratability, and instead as possible to speak about or feel and even worth speaking about and feeling, and we do this alongside others who are injured, then we may be able to get past this seemingly insuperable foreclosure. Thus, feeling backward, along with embracing traumatic double consciousness, are central to understanding feminine fracturing as an alternative to dissociation, and as an alternative to the conceptualization of trauma as breach—as a break between a past and present self, or between a body and a mind. This alternative framing also exposes how normative formulations of gendered and sexualized trauma have been founded upon a specific vision of an innocent and whole (white) woman, who is then damaged and broken, but who is finally cured and can live normally (normatively) again. If we look at the ways that traumatized people have been and continue to be expected to recover, we can come closer to a cripistemology of feminized fracture, and also get outside of the white, bourgeois, cishet femininity built into formulations of gendered and sexualized trauma. Further, taking seriously how diverse feminized and traumatized populations have been expected to heal themselves allows us to consider more communal and radical ways of caring for each other.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.