Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Only questions of disability in IR can draw the genealogies of war-spaces such as Afghanistan into the broader question of a racialized Fem IR

Alison Howell 22 [Feb 25 2022, Imagining Afghanistan in Post-colonial IR: Feminism, Disability and Imperial Warfare, https://www.societyandspace.org/articles/imagining-afghanistan-in-post-colonial-ir-feminism-disability-and-imperial-warfare, Society and Space, -ekh]

One clear starting point in apprehending the contributions of Imagining Afghanistan is to heed Manchanda’s alertness to the “co-optation of discourse [analysis] as a depoliticized study of language, semantics, and rhetoric” (2020: 17) that is, the pacification and de-barbing of discourse analysis as a methodology of (feminist) critique. Imagining Afghanistan instead develops its arguments concerning the racial-sexual nature - and violent material consequences - of Anglophone imperial knowledge production about Afghanistan by gathering an extensive and divergent archive of source material: the book eschews a sole focus on the ‘easy targets’ of George W Bush-era or military proclamations, to instead trace not only the production but the circulation of discourse, and in particular to consider the racial logics of Anglophone constructions of Afghanistan across the political spectrum. 

So, for instance, we find rich discussion of the production of imperial discourse by those strongly (even dynastically) associated with ‘the left’ and with (white) feminism, such as the longtime Guardian columnist Polly Toynbee (Manchanda 2020: 151). Yet the book also recognizes some potential limitations to an intellectual and political orientation of challenging Western/Anglophone constructions of Afghanistan, as it acknowledges the potential critique (via discussion of Zia 2017) that a “focus on Western constructions of Afghan women’s oppression” might “[make] it difficult for Afghan feminists to expose and arraign local forms of patriarchy and the curtailment of the rights and agency that these entail” (Manchanda 2020: 176; see also the Coda to the book).

Crucial here is that these kinds of engagements are illustrative of the need to resist any temptation to comfortably conceptualize feminist IR in terms of a binary reading of a homogenized ‘white’ versus a homogenized ‘other’ feminism, when some of the most exciting debates in feminist IR work through conversations and contentions between, for example, divergent schools of postcolonial feminist, transnational feminist, and anti-imperial and Third World feminist thought, with their different emphases and methodologies for understanding colonial matrices of power, imperial warfare, and resistance. In this sense, Imagining Afghanistan raises urgent questions (without claiming to ‘resolve’ them with finality) about whether challenging white-Western feminist canons of knowledge risk re-centering them as objects of knowledge, and whether there is room for multiple, sometimes contentious, avenues for imagining and enacting feminism as an anti-imperial project.

Another way in which feminists and others can read Imagining Afghanistan is to consider how it empirically illustrates that thinking about disability (studies) might enrich our accounts of war, empire and global politics. While the book makes scant reference to disability studies texts (containing some discussion of Puar’s 2017 The Right to Maim), there are two notable sections of the book that sit squarely in the realm of disability studies concerns: the first (Manchanda 2020: 44-49) examines the “leitmotif” of “illness and disease,” that is, the persistent articulation of Afghanistan as a festering, cancerous, pathological space in need of curative and surgical (read military) intervention; the second (Manchanda 2020: 188-190) is situated in the chapter on representations of Afghan masculinities, and unpicks the figure of the “Mentally Unstable Taliban.” 

Such empirical concerns, and the book’s brief engagement with some recent literature located as interventions in disability studies opens productive space for thinking about imperial warfare from a decolonial disability studies perspective. Despite of, and historical focus on the Global North in, disability studies (cf. Bell 2006; Gorman et al. 2013; Miles, Nishida and Forber-Pratt 2017), like feminist IR, there are many worlds of disability scholarship and activism, including parallel genealogies of anti-imperial and anti-racist work that treat  (cf. Meerai, Abdillahi, and Poole 2016; Pickens 2019). Established and growing research in this field has been shaped by an acknowledgement of the need to decolonize disability studies and firmly place disability in global and colonial contexts (cf. Erevelles 2011; Meekosha 2011; Grech 2015; Grech and Soldatic 2016), as the field has examined the imbrications of racism and ableism in a number of areas of empirical concern to global studies, including for example: migration and detention (cf. Joseph 2015; Tam 2017), development (cf. Cosgrove et al.), the arms trade (cf. Meekosha 2011), and war and militarism (cf. Wool 2015). Like Imagining Afghanistan, some of the work emerging from this field has entailed researching how colonial knowledge and imperial violence are produced through racist and ableist registers of madness and deviance, especially the pathologization of the figures of the terrorist or insurgent (cf. Howell 2007; Patel 2014; Rai 2006).

One of the highly productive tensions emerging out of these literatures concerns how to situate research focusing on the representational/discursive in relation to efforts to decolonize disability studies in ways that foreground how enslavement, land theft, and colonial warfare have been and continue to be productive of mass impairment and debility (cf. Meekosha 2011; Grech 2015; Puar 2017). This latter move may press on understandings of disability as a basis for political identity, community and collective action (sometimes organized through the concept of ‘Pride’). Put differently: how can the bodily devastation of colonialism and imperialism be captured as a disability issue, without casting racialized disabled people or disabled people in the Global South as pitiable victims lacking agency, or without reifying representations as a function of deconstructing them? 

One answer has been to highlight shared collective political struggles, for example by recognizing attempts to disqualify colonized peoples from self-determination and sovereignty on the basis of the production of racial hierarchies of mental capacity, intelligence, maturity and (sexual) deviance (cf. Bruce 2017), or political activism and scholarship that highlights shared but divergent histories of incarceration (i.e. penal incarceration and disability incarceration in institutions or by ‘chemical incarceration’) and of abolitionist activism (cf. Ben-Moshe 2020; Carey Chapman and Ben-Moshe 2014; Fabris 2011).

To begin to think through how these literatures might come into conversation with Imagining Afghanistan, we might start by acknowledging that what’s at stake in taking this scholarship seriously is not, as Manchanda warns, to adopt a “mantra of race, class and gender” (Manchanda 2020: 183) to which ‘disability’ could be ‘added,’ but rather recognize that “[s]ocial difference is messy, uneven and ambivalent.” Put differently, this is not about cataloguing a more complete list of ‘isms’, but about fostering a more conceptually and empirically robust field of imperial war studies. 

Bringing Imagining Afghanistan into conversation with these disability studies literatures pushes us to consider, for example, the relations between colonial tropes of the Taliban ‘warlord’ as mentally unstable and as sexually deviant, topics which are treated sequentially in the book (chapter 5). Such tropes of madness and deviance are not new, and can be situated amidst a long history of misogynist and racist psychiatric knowledge and practice in settler and other colonial spaces. It is noteworthy that precisely where Imagining Afghanistan shifts gears from the discursive or “metaphoric to the literal” (Manchanda 2020: 48) is in the discussion of representations of Afghanistan as a diseased and pathological space, where the direct relations between drone warfare, CIA activity and elevated polio rates are discussed. This suggests natural lines of affinity with the kinds of disability studies scholarship that view colonization through the lens of the production of impairment, while opening space to highlight agency and resistance to war and other forms of correction-through-violence.

Read through and against these political and scholarly contexts, Imagining Afghanistan points to exciting common touchstones across these fields of inquiry, suggestive of ways to significantly push forward the fields of critical and postcolonial war studies, and to better grapple with all of the complexities of imperial warfare.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.