They are wrong about capital. The “able / disabled” distinction over codes capitalism’s analysis of productive value.
Reynolds 22 – Dr. Joel Michael Reynolds is an Assistant Professor of Philosophy and Disability Studies at Georgetown University, Senior Research Scholar in the Kennedy Institute of Ethics, Senior Advisor to The Hastings Center, and core faculty in Georgetown’s Disability Studies Program. He received his Ph.D in philosophy from Emory university, and he is the founder of The Journal of Philosophy of Disability and co-founder of Oxford Studies in Disability, Ethics, and Society from Oxford University Press. (Joel Reynolds, “Disability and White Supremacy”, Critical Philosophy of Race, Penn State University Press, Project Muse, Volume 10, Issue 1, 2022, pp. 50-54, DOI: 10.5325/critphilrace.10.1.0048) || PZ
That is to say, the process and apparatus of making abled and disabled emerges not simply out of capitalism, but out of the racial subsidies upon which it is based, producing the twin needs to humanize those who control the means of production and dehumanize those who do not and do so at varying levels of stratification depending upon context, locale, political exigency, extant social mores, etc. As Ryan Fics puts this matter, “disability and ability aren’t necessarily the product of capital, but, rather, they are co-originary with that which informs and arranges capital, especially the white supremacy that undergirds” its historical formation and emergence.25 Yet another component of this co-originary logic is that of extermination. The extreme and systematic acts of violence and murder by white Americans against Black Americans has been a historical mainstay.26 Making Black bodies disabled and making Black bodies dead is at the center of the structural intertwining of ableism and anti-Black racism upon which this country is founded. Along with the racial subsidies upon which the power of capture, influence, and polarization is afforded to those who are racialized as white comes also the production of social identity. When James Baldwin claims that whiteness must be seen in terms of the “protection of . . . identity,” I take him to be pointing to the way that whiteness becomes constitutive of the very sense of self of white Americans, of those who live in its possibilities of violence and capital gains without limits—as well as living with limits to their own exposure to certain types of living and labor conditions.27 But a central feature of capitalism, like any economic system, turns on the distribution, accumulation, and transferal of abilities. The ability to build, to buy, to negotiate, to insure, to sell, and to move capital (both social and financial) just is, among other things, a particular economy of this way of distributing ability. And insofar as the birth of the (modern) racial subject is linked to the history of capitalism, then this is at the same time to claim that the birth of the (modern) disabled subject is linked to the history of capitalism. One of the intellectual tasks at hand, I think, is to better see how the social value of any given “human” ability has become refracted through whiteness, which is to say, how whiteness inflects (and, certainly, infects) what any individual or group is taken to be able to do and whether that ability is held to carry any value, any capital. Sylvia Wynter explicitly links disability (both physical and cognitive) with the meaning of Blackness and the legacy of anti-black racism and settler colonialism in the United States more generally. “The bottommost role of Black Americans in the United States is systemically produced . . . a parallel and interlinked role is also played by the category of the Poor, the jobless, the homeless, the ‘underdeveloped,’ all of whom, interned in their systemically produced poverty and expendability, are now made to function in the reoccupied place of the Leper of the medieval order and of the Mad of the monarchical, so as to actualize at the economic level the same dysgenic or dysselected-by-Evolution conception.”28 On my reading, Wynter is here claiming that white supremacy in the United States has relegated Black Americans to disabled outcasts. This means, among other things, that being disabled cannot somehow offer protection for those who are black, as Curry’s analysis assumes in principle, whether through increased pity, consideration, social supports, or what have you.