Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Blackness and disability exist in a state of becoming; through the transatlantic slave trade, ability has intrinsically been tied to whiteness and disability to blackness. We should treat these as aligned instead of antagonistic to one another.

Erevelles 2011 (Erevelles, N.. Disability and Difference in Global Contexts : Enabling a Transformative Body Politic, Palgrave Macmillan US, 2011. ProQuest Ebook Central, pg 38- pg 42 “Disability as “Becoming”: Notes on the political Economy of the flesh” https://ebookcentral-proquest-com.proxy.lib.umich.edu/lib/umichigan/detail.action?docID=832212. )// RB

In Hortense Spillers’s (1987) essay, “Mama’s Baby, Papa’s Maybe,” the social context in which the embodied subject becomes-in-the-world is one suffused with an ineffaceable horror. Spillers, in this essay, locates the “origins” of African American subjectivity in the (trans)Atlantic slave trade, which starts with the unimaginable violence during the Middle Passage; continues through the dehumanization of slavery; and finally concludes by exposing dominant conceptualizations of the contemporary “Black Family” as a tangle of pathology. Her analysis pierces the body to expose “the hieroglyphics of the flesh” whose “undecipherable markings” become the cornerstone of an American Grammar that continues to this day to deny the African American his/her subjectivity, such that his/her body “becomes both the physical and biological expression of otherness . . . becoming both physically and generally powerless” (p. 67). In this section, I argue that Spillers’s essay is as much about disability as it is about race, even though the word “disability” is not mentioned even once in her essay. I find this startling because the “scene[s] of actual mutilation, dismemberment, and exile” (p. 67) that Spillers describes in her essay produce disabled bodies—black disabled bodies—who in an ironic turn are transformed into commodities that are exchanged in the market or profit. I call this ironic because the dominant paradigm has conceived of disabled bodies as having little economic value except in very limited contexts where their extra-ordinariness was made hypervisible, as for example, in the freak shows—another profitable venture (Adams, 2001; Bogdan, 1988). In Spillers’s essay, on the other hand, it is in becoming disabled that the black body is at the height of its profitability, and it is the historical, social, and economic context of this becoming that I will now foreground in this section.

Before I undertake this analysis, however, I want to distinguish my position from other positions that have theorized the relationship between race and disability. For the most part, race for disability scholars and disability for race scholars are conceived of as “prosthetic metaphor[s]” (Barker & Murray, 2010, p. 219). In race studies scholarship, Ewart (2010) calls this practice “dis appropriation,” where the language of disability is used “to affirm (an often-subordinate) voice to elucidate agency and figurative empathy for other oppressed and exploited populations” (p. 152). In disability studies scholarship, disability oppression/struggle is equated with racial oppression/struggle (James & Wu, 2006). In each of these cases, both disability and race are conceived of as tropes that can be used interchangeably to foreground the ubiquity of oppression, but that fail to explore the complex ways in which “the categories of race/ethnicity and disability are used to constitute one another or the ways that those social, political, and cultural practices have kept seemingly different groups of people in strikingly similar marginalized positions” (James & Wu, 2006, p. 4). Conscious of this critique, in this section, I will show how race and disability are imbricated in their collective formation of the black disabled body that now becomes a commodity that has economic, social, cultural, and linguistic implications for transnational subjectivities.

As mentioned earlier, Spillers’s essay does not follow normative ways of engaging both disability and race because disability is never actually mentioned in her essay. Instead, Spillers focuses on the deliberate and violent process by which the black body is transformed into a commodity— without gender, without genitalia, without subjectivity—a commodity so abject that it exists even outside kinship relations (the most fundamental of social units), such that, in another ironic twist, its very aimlessness constitutes it as “an effective social and economic agent” (p. 74). I underscore both the historical and economic contexts here that are instrumental in the body becoming both racialized and disabled. I want to stress here that my argument is not that disability is like race or that race is like disability. Rather, I am arguing that within the specific transnational conditions of colonialism/neocolonialism, the becoming of black disabled bodies is indeed an intercorporeal phenomenon that foregrounds a violent hierarchical context that contemporary theorists of difference have been reluctant to address or even acknowledge.

Spillers’s essay begins (and I use this verb very tentatively) in the fifteenth century, in the initial encounters between European adventurers and West Africans, as culled from the 1789 narrative of the Nigerian Olaudau Equiano or Gustavus Vassa and the Portuguese Gomes Eannes de Azurara’s chronicle of the discovery and conquest of Guinea, 1441–1448. In both narratives, written from entirely different perspectives, the initial encounter between the Self and its Other produced the shocked recognition of radical difference. In these initial encounters, “white men with horrible looks, red faces, and long hair” (Equiano as quoted in Spillers, 1987, p. 67) came face to face with men and women “black as Ethiops, and so ugly, both in features and in body, as almost to appear (to those who saw them) the images of a lower hemisphere” (1: 28; De Azurara as quoted in Spillers, 1987, p. 70)

The sociocultural and psychic horror expressed by the Self when brought face to face with the monstrous Other mimics Julia Kristeva’s (1982) argument that the abject inspires an irrational fear of engulfment and/or contamination. And, at face value, it would appear that both parties are guilty of this horror. However, as Spillers is quick to point out, this notion of simultaneous/mutual horror is a solipsism that conceals a more brutal reality—the intention of the One to subjugate the Other on the basis of difference perceived in skin color. To the ship crew of mostly European men, those bodies, “black as Ethiops and so ugly, both in features and in body,” were nothing more than cargo to be transported to the New World by sea, and to be traded for unimaginable profit because of their obvious “physical” impairments.” It is at this moment that the conceptualization of black subjectivity as impaired subjectivity is neither accidental nor should it be conceived of as merely metaphorical. Rather, it is precisely at the historical moment when one class of human beings was transformed into cargo to be transported to the New World that black bodies become disabled and disabled bodies become black. Further, it is also important to note that blackness itself does not stand in for skin color. After all, in his chronicle, de Azurara recognizes that “in the field of captives, some of the observed are ‘white enough, fair to look upon, and well-proportioned’ [while] Others are less ‘white like mulattoes’” (Spillers, 1987, p. 70). In other words, black and disabled are not just linguistic tropes used to delineate difference, but are, instead, materialist constructs produced for the appropriation of profit in a historical context where black disabled bodies were subjected to the most brutal violence.

The other factor to recognize in these flesh-and-blood encounters of intercorporeality, which Shildrick celebrates in her own work, is that both blackness and disability are mutually constitutive on account of this social violence. Here, disability is again not just a linguistic trope, but the actual bloodied markings on the black body. Spillers cites William Goodell’s account of North American slave codes that expose this brutal violation of black flesh: “The smack of the whip is all day long in the ears of those who are on the plantation, or in the vicinity; and it is used with such dexterity and severity as not only to lacerate the skin, but to tear out small portions of the flesh at almost every stake.” The anatomical specifications of rupture, of altered human tissue, take on the objective description of laboratory prose—eyes beaten out, arms, backs, skulls branded, a left jaw, a right ankle, punctured; teeth missing, as the calculated work of iron, whips, chains, knives, the canine patrol, the bullet. (p. 67)

While Spillers describes these markings on the flesh as “the concentration of ethnicity” in a culture “whose state apparatus, including judges, attorneys, ‘owners,’ ‘soul drivers,’ ‘overseers,’ and ‘men of God,’ apparently colludes with a protocol of ‘search and destroy’” (p. 67), I argue that these same markings on the flesh, quite simply, also produce impairment. Here, impairment is not just biological/natural, it is also produced in a historical, social, and economic context, where the very embodiment of blackness and disability “bears in person the marks of a cultural text whose inside has been turned outside” (p. 67). Here too, Rosemarie Garland-Thomson’s (2002) depiction of disability as the set of practices that produce disabled/nondisabled bodies via a system of interpreting and disciplining bodily variation takes a brutally violent turn.

When the imbrication of blackness and disability produce violent markings on enslaved bodies, the assault on enslaved subjectivities is profound. Take, for example, one historical account cited by Spillers, which describes the detailed specifications provided as instruction to the crew of one of the most famous ships associated with the Middle Passage ( The Brookes ) on how to most profitably cram its human cargo on board: “Let it now be supposed . . . further, that every man slave is to be allowed six feet by one foot four inches for room, every woman five feet ten by one foot four, every boy five feet by one foot two, and every girl four feet six by one foot . . . “ The owner of The Brookes , James Jones, had recommended that “five females be reckoned as four males, and three boys or girls as equal to two grown persons.” (p. 72)

Instructed with much mathematical precision, bodily boundaries collapse and collide, stretch and shrink. The categorical permeability of boundaries has scant regard for the sovereign subject, because complex computations of equivalency are not bound by bodily limits. And yet, it is difficult to celebrate the fragility, malleability, and instability of these bodily boundaries borne out of so much violence as either transgressive or transformative. Rather, more profoundly, the intercorporeal permeability between these un-gendered, un-named, and un-remarkable bodies (except for their economic value as cargo) only serve to further erode any form of subjectivity that these bodies could claim for themselves. Here, the historical conditions of a nascent colonialist transnational expansion of capitalism are responsible for the violent reconfiguration of the flesh, such that it becomes almost impossible to claim the sovereign subject, now mutually constituted via race, disability, and gender as a dehumanized commodity. And yet, even though the deconstruction of the sovereign subject is cause for celebration, how does one celebrate in the face of so much violated and wounded flesh?

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.