Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

There is clear connection between the social death and its relation to blackness and disability- particularly in places like debate seek to pathologize these experiences.

Erevelles & Minear 2011 (Erevelles, N. and Andrea Minear Disability and Difference in Global Contexts : Enabling a Transformative Body Politic, Palgrave Macmillan US, 2011. ProQuest Ebook Central, ““Unspeakable Offenses: Disability Studies at the Intersections of Multiple Differences with Andrea Minear 1” https://ebookcentral-proquest-com.proxy.lib.umich.edu/lib/umichigan/detail.action?docID=832212. )// RB

“Spirit Murder” and the “New” Eugenics: Critical Race Theory meets Disability Studies

The three stories of Eleanor Bumpurs, Junius Wilson, and Cassie and Aliya Smith, however poignant they may appear to be, are not unique. Police brutality, false imprisonment, and educational negligence are commonplace in the lives of people of color— especially those who are located at the margins of multiple- identity categories. So common are these practices that CRF scholar Patricia Williams (1997) has argued that these kinds of assaults should not be dismissed as the “odd mistake.” On the other hand, Williams has argued that that these “mistakes” be given a name that associates them with criminality. Her term for such assaults on an individual’s personhood is “spirit murder,” which she describes as follows: I see spirit murder as no less than the equivalent of body murder . . . One of the reasons I fear what I call spirit murder or disregard for others whose lives qualitatively depend on our regard, is that its product is a system of formalized distortions of thought. It produces social structures centered around fear and hate, it provides a timorous outlet for feelings elsewhere unexpressed . . . We need to see it as a cultural cancer; we need to open our eyes to the spiritual genocide it is wreaking on blacks, whites, and the abandoned and abused of all races and ages. We need to eradicate its numbing pathology before it wipes out what precious little humanity we have left. (p. 234)

Clearly, in our educational institutions, there are millions of students of color, mostly economically disadvantaged and disabled, for whom “spirit murder” is the most significant experience in their educational lives. In fact, it is this recognition of “spirit murder” in the everyday lives of disabled students of color that forges a critical link between disability studies and CRT/F through the intercategorical analysis of intersectionality. In other words, utilizing an intercategorical analysis from the critical standpoint of disability studies will foreground the structural forces in place in schools that disregard students who are perceived as disruptive to the dominant ideologies that shore up the mythical norm. That most of the students are poor, disabled, and of color is critical to recognize from within a CRT/F perspective, because the implications these exclusions have on the community of color as a whole are disastrous. By failing to undertake such an analysis, we could miss several political opportunities for transformative action. For example, Connor and Ferri (2005) raise some critical questions regarding one of education’s most famous court cases, Brown v. Board of Education:

Why did supporters of Brown not recognize how the assigned status of “disability” could serve as a mechanism for resegregating students of color in otherwise desegregated schools? And why did special education fail to take into account the intersection of race and disability and, thus undermine the goals of the Brown decision? (p. 121)

Now that we have the benefit of hindsight, we need to move forward. Connor and Ferri’s questions require that we pay close attention to reading race and disability not through an additive/comparative lens, but by deploying an intersectional analysis that seeks to understand and transform the structures where power coheres in complex yet dangerous ways. It requires that critical educators plant themselves firmly at the intersections of multiple differences to submit our educational institutions to a ruthless critique of the status quo.

In the context of our argument, these are some of the questions that should be raised by all critical educators: What role do disability labels play in public school settings? Why should parents and educators of color be active participants in advocating special education reform in public schools? Why should parents active in the disability rights movement also foreground the racial dimensions of special education reform? Why should parents of color, parents of students with disabilities, and parents from economically disadvantaged backgrounds, and parents who live at all these intersections work together to radically transform schools?

One of the largest problems in the special education movement is that parent advocates usually deploy the individualist model when fighting for their children. Both CRT/F and disability studies scholarship point to the social/political context in which families are situated in relationship to educational institutions. It is these contexts that have real effects on the families and those individuals caught at these intersections. The history of the civil rights movement was successful because of community advocacy. At the intersections of race, class, gender, sexuality, and disability, we will find that collective resistance is more fruitful than individualized forms of resistance.

The need for change has never been more pressing than now. Even as we write this chapter, there may be yet another Eleanor Bumpurs, Junius Wilson, or Cassie Smith, whose life is quite literally on the line. If we allow eugenic- like ideologies to continue to plague our institutions (legal, rehabilitational, and educational), we will be required to face the consequences. In the Nobel Prize winner Toni Morrison’s famous book Beloved , she evocatively describes how we can never escape history because it will continue to speak to us in haunting tones until we listen, atone, and transform ourselves. Rather than viewing it as a threat, we argue that there is hope in this assertion. Patricia Williams (1997) herself also echoes Morrison’s call to all of us educators to heed the voices of those who are innocently sacrificed at the altar of educational expediency. She writes:

The legacy of killing finds its way into cultural expectations, archetypes, and “isms.” The echoes of both the dead and deadly others acquire a hallucinatory quality; their voices speak of an unwanted past, but also reflect for us images of the future. Today’s world condemns those voices as superstitious and paranoid. Neglected they speak from the shadows of such inattention, in garbles and growls, in the tongues of the damned and the insane . . . So- called unenlightened others who fail to listen to the voices of demonic selves, made invisibly uncivilized, simply make them larger, more barbarously enraged, until the nearsightedness of looking glass existence is smashed in upon by the terrible dispossession of dreams too long deferred. (Williams, 1997, p. 235).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.