Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

We don’t seek to put meaning behind narratives or the performance of 1AC, rather you should understand that the world is messy and the project of the 1AC is not complete but part of an ongoing process.

Pickens 19 [Therí Alyce Pickens, Professor of English, specializing in African American, Arab America and disability literatures and theories at Bates University, June 7, 2019 “Black Madness :: Mad Blackness”, Duke University Press, Durham and London, pgs. 95-96, JMH]

As an inroad to an ending, I turn to the issue of whether Black madness and mad Blackness must have meaning and what that meaning must be. I disambiguate meaning and value. The former is how a concept makes sense in or has an impact on public or private space. The latter concerns an affective and sociocultural conception of relative merit or perceived worth in public or private space. In the introduction to this volume, I called this line of inquiry an act of literary theorist blasphemy because it upturns one of the basic assumptions of literary criticism: namely, that certain concepts must continue to be impactful or that those concepts must make sense in a text, that they are available to be read and understood. Yet, this kind of inquiry has a long history in Black studies and disability studies. Scholarly interventions regarding Blackness and madness call into question the utility of both meaning and value. That is, disability studies and critical race studies attend to the ways that devaluation of Blackness and madness—legally, socially, culturally, historically—contribute to the thinking of these identities as abject. This is not simply about whether these subjects remain in a position of abjection but rather about sorting through the conditions that make that meaning shift. The political impetus is that one cannot have a different meaning unless the value ascribed changes. The lives of mad people matter. Black lives matter. According to a linear progressive view of history, as the value of Blackness and madness increase, the abjection ascribed to them will dissipate or go away altogether. Indeed, the fiction of postracial discourse is that we are/ were currently in this/that cultural moment. (The operative word here is fiction.) The conversations before this moment reveal that the artists-theorists discussed in this volume provide useful disruptions to linear time and progressive narratives. In drawing an intellectual cartography, this project lays bare how these artists-theorists trouble the stativity of those ideas and, in their dynamic theorizing, intervene in the commonly held discourses about Blackness and madness. As I warned, this map would uncover, recover, and discover, at times, contradictory relationships in the folds, lingering in the cut. A small bit of redistricting: Octavia E. Butler’s work wonders whether mutual constitution functions as an adroit reading strategy. Nalo Hopkinson suggests the intraracial space may offer some disruptive aesthetic and narrative potential, which challenges Butler without dismissing the possibility for new interpretative strategy. Tananarive Due’s heuristic queries how either of the worlds Butler and Hopkinson craft became possible given the ideological concept of the human. Each conversation intertwines with the other to examine the fissures in our analyses of Blackness and madness. As a result, they raise questions about the sought after goals of understanding these narratives. In what follows, I endeavor to do what is perhaps impolite at the end of a conversation: crawl under the discussion to retrace a thread that subtends but possibly upends the entire enterprise. I ask, if the value of Black madness and mad Blackness increases, do Black madness and/or mad Blackness retain the same meanings?

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.