Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The white body becomes the center of disability, creating a savage degeneracy at the heart of disabled blackness

Tommy Curry 17 [JOURNAL of SOCIAL PHILOSOPHY, Vol. 48 No. 3, Fall 2017, 321–343., “This Nigger’s Broken: Hyper-Masculinity, the Buck, and the Role of Physical Disability in White Anxiety Toward the Black Male Body,” African American scholar, author and professor of philosophy. As of 2019, he holds a Personal Chair in Africana philosophy and Black male studies at the University of Edinburgh. In 2018, he won an American Book Award for The Man-Not: Race, Class, Genre, and the Dilemmas of Black Manhood, -ekh-]

On September 23, 2015, Mr. Jeremy McDole was executed by Wilmington, Delaware police officers. Mr. McDole was allegedly a threat to himself and suicidal. The police were responding to a “911 call reporting that [Mr. McDole] had shot himself.”1 The 911 caller can be heard yelling: “A man just shot himself in the AutoZone parking lot ... he’s fallen out of a wheelchair.”2 Mr. McDole was reported to the police as a victim, not a criminal. He was described as a disabled man with injury. A man who was suicidal; in need of help. His need, his victimhood, was not seen. He was not recognized by the police as a vulnerable person. He was seen as a Black man; a threat—a body marked for death by the danger he posed to others. This stereotype applied to his body, despite him being confined to a wheelchair. Like the deaths of hundreds of other Black males in America, his execution was recorded and subsequently released to the American public for summary judgment—just or unjust killing of a Black man. Unlike the hundreds of Black men killed every year in America, however, Mr. McDole was paralyzed from the waist down from an injury he sustained after being shot at the age of 18. What threat did this disabled Black man pose to anyone? Was he armed? Did he have a gun? These are the questions that define Black male death in this country, and despite Mr. McDole’s disability, they now define him. Why is it so easy to frame the lives of Black men and boys by one act, that same moment all the public sees where it is almost willed in unison that these Black males are in fact yearning for death? What was it about him being Black-male-disabled that resists consideration—did not diffuse the presumed danger—and convey that he was not a threat?

Like many academic fields, disability studies has been confronted with its raced, classed, and gendered assumptions about the body which lies at the center of conceptualizations of disability. Over a decade ago, Phil Smith argued in “Whiteness, Normal Theory, and Disability Studies,” that “whiteness is a normative, dominating, unexamined power that underlies the rationality of Eurocentric culture and thought. It serves to push to the margins not only those defined as not-white, but also those defined as not-Able.”3 Similarly, Chris Bell’s “Introducing White Disability Studies: A Modest Proposal,” argues that disability studies functions to commodify Blackness as synonymous with disability. Reflecting on the Queer disability conference held in 2002, he writes many disabled non-whites “could not understand the overarching mentality of many of the attendees, perhaps best expressed by a remark made in a breakout session: ‘Being disabled is just like being black, so society should stop hating us and give us our rights.’ ”4 Bell clarifies in a footnote that disability studies normalizes disability such that the white disabled body is the conceptual/anthropological origin of disabledness. Far from excluding people of color, “White Disability Studies treats people of color as if they were white people; as if there are no critical exigencies involved in being people of color that might necessitate these individuals understanding and negotiating disability in a different way from their white counterparts.”5

The white body, being the ideal type, is then the basis of distortion or disfiguration which defines the disabled other. The racial designation of whiteness exceeds the borders of what is often meant by identity; who identifies or can be identified as a white person. In actuality, whiteness speaks to something more fundamental in the West that has come to define what it is to be human or nonhuman. To be non-white is to be abnormal—evolutionarily behind—in the phylogenetic order of human development. Those who are raced have historically been constructed as the degenerate/inferior/nonhuman opposite to the rational prototype of the human/superior/(Western) (abled) human.6 An outgrowth of nineteenth-century eugenics, “degeneration became a compelling racial metaphor such that the colonized races were assumed to be intrinsically degenerate, and as a result could never be improved.”7 Degeneracy suggested biological weakness and disease, often translating “into an attribution of diminished cognitive and rational capacities of nonwhite populations.”8

In the West, these colonial accounts of abnormality became dichotomizing anthropological designations separating those who are human from those who are not human. Those bodies whose origin are thought to share a phylogenic distance from European man have been thought to be the embodiment of pathology, degeneracy, and racial inferiority. As a kind of abnormality, disability was considered to be unnatural and detestable, while normality became synonymous with that which was natural and a means “of establishing the universal, unquestionable good and right.”9 The moral constitution of the self, the interior character one possesses, became associated with the physical and mental formation of the body. Oye`ronke Oyewumı argues that under Western epistemology, “The body is given a logic all its own. It is believed that just by looking at it one can tell a person’s beliefs and social position or lack thereof.”10 Because “the body is the bedrock on which social order is founded, the body is always in view and on view,”11 so the somatological becomes intuitive; that which is obvious when gazed upon. In the West, sight analyzes the body, and becomes the instrument used to identify biological deficiency which is thought to indicate degeneracy and inferiority. In this circuitous epistemology, the deformity of the body is a reflection upon the supposed distortion of the mind, just as the distortion of the mind suggests the savage degeneracy of the body.

In “Pathology to Power: Rethinking Race, Poverty and Disability,” Pamela Block, Fabricio Balcazar, and Christopher Keys explain that, even in the twenty-first century, “the concept of disability, when applied as a medical or psychological diagnosis, can subsume the culturally, socially, and historically derived identity of an individual beneath a label of pathology.”12 Despite the supposedly progressive social conscience of the American public, and the seemingly infinite theoretical nuances in identity theory, there is an anthropological, and dare I say, ontological problem, which continues to re-emerge as the basis of engaging those bodies perceived as disabled. This risk of being reduced to the perception and anxieties of others is only amplified by the vulnerabilities racial groups have in mainstream society. Whereas “white individuals with disabilities can recognize that their disability is the main reason why they are discriminated against, segregated, and oppressed, [disabled minority groups] have a harder time separating or consolidating their multiple identities.”13 Non-whites experience “segregation and discrimination independent of their disability. If we also consider the fact that poverty is a major source of marginalization and that most individuals of color with disabilities are poor, then the experience of disability is only one more factor in an already oppressed existence.”14

But what of Black males? Despite over a decade of work identifying the whiteness and bourgeois assumptions in disability theory, there has not been any attempt to create specific theories of Black male disability which engages the vulnerabilities his body has to death, hyper-sexualization, and super-humanism in America. Even Nirmala Erevelles’s work, which does an excellent job articulating the link between colonial concepts of inferiority, be they racial or cultural, misses the opportunity to fully articulate the vulnerabilities racialized maleness has within her transnational feminist disability studies perspective.15 This is not to suggest Erevelles does not engage the disabled Black male body. The concern she conveys for her husband Robert who was suffering with a grade IV brain tumor is a startling reminder of how the Black male body is perceived as a danger regardless of its actual physical state. As a Black male, I understand her relief when she tells the reader how lucky they both felt that most of Robert’s seizures occurred in the privacy of their own home.16 I know her fear, the repetitive terror she experienced imagining her husband being shot or killed because the public did not know how to react to a Black male body seizing. Erevelles is correct: “The Black male body ... is a source of terror in white patriarchal society, and when transformed during a grand mal seizure—with rolled back eyes, harsh grunting sounds, mouth drooling bloody foam, and the occasional loss of control of bodily function with its associated putrid smell—could become an even more terrifying spectacle as a result of the now lethal triple combination of race, gender, and disability.”17 But what conditions the maleness of this Black disabled body? What is the role Black man plays in Erevelles’s knowledge that “to be perceived as a dangerous black man in the wrong place at the wrong time ... could result in death,”18 and the public’s fear that even a disabled Black man is Black and male enough to pose a threat?

There is an asserted claim in gender theory holding that maleness need not have a separate theoretical account as an attribute of the racial body, as it represents privilege, domination, and hegemony in its relation to femaleness.19 For many, acknowledging the horror the Black male body conveys is enough, but the lack of an explanatory account as to why the Black male body is peculiarly dehumanized within patriarchal racial logics leaves the multiple levels of vulnerability Black males experience unexplored and untheorized. While it is obvious to many that Black males are seen as dangerous, it is often unacknowledged that Black men and boys have a long history of being victims of rape, sexual violence, and cannibalism.20 Black maleness is easily acknowledged as being the cause of white aggression and violence, but these ignored violence(s), which exist in the sexual register, are thought to be of no consequence to how Black men and boys are perceived, desired, and feared.21 This essay attempts to remedy this deficit in theory how the Black male body generally, and the disabled Black male body more specifically, is engaged as a phobia-inspiring entity. Because the Black male body is confined to the realm of terror—a living corporeal horror—I argue the recognition of physical or mental disability by white onlookers is subsumed by white fear. In other words, disability in the Black male is unrecognizable by whites because of a very real racial anxiety.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.