Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Only our critical analysis of capital at the level of labor functions can explain lived, material realities of disabled bodies as the surplus population.

De Cabral 22 – Vinicius Neves de Cabral holds a PhD in Education from the State University of Londrina and currently works as a lecturer in the Department of Pedagogy at the State University of Parana in Brazil. He is a researcher associated with the Centre for Critical Studies and Research in Education and Social Inequality, and member of the Editorial Board of the The Journal for Critical Education Policy Studies and of the Journal of Class and Culture. His main research interests lie in the fields of education, culture, literature, and film, drawing on Marxist methodologies. Recently published articles: (1) The Portrait of Exclusion in Brazilian Universities: the limits of inclusion, (2) Roma: images of dictatorial regimes and Human Rights abuse in Latin America, and (3) Capitalism, Class and Meritocracy: A Cross-National Study Between the UK and Brazil. (Vinícius Neves de Cabral, “A Marxist Approach to Disability: Notes on Marx’s Relative Surplus Population”, State University of Paraná (UNESPAR), Brazil and State University of Londrina, pgs. 41-51, June 2022, http://www.jceps.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/20-2-2.pdf ) || PZ

Capitalism, Disability, and the relative surplus population I would like to start by establishing the grounds on which I shall build my reflections. My first and final argument is that disability in capitalism is a social product of the contradictions produced by the clash between forces of exploitation and forces of labour. It is rather important to clarify, perhaps to the despair of postmodern perspectives (Eagleton 1998; 2016; Harvey 1990), that I shall focus my considerations on what we could call a materialist universalising view of the body and the mind, a body and mind that are expected by capitalism, the labour body/mind. The body/mind that is able to work and to sell its labour force in the market, so that it may extract surplus value from this abled-to-work body/mind. The contrast of the abled labour body/mind is the disabled body/mind, which is a term “used to classify persons deemed less exploitable or not exploitable by the owning class who control the means of production in a capitalist economy” (Russel 2019, p. 42). Those “deemed less exploitable or not exploitable”, deviant from the ideal labour body/mind, may be considered part of what Karl Marx calls a Stagnant Surplus Population (Figure 1), or the third category of the Relative Surplus Population (floating, latent, and stagnant) or Industrial Reserve Army (Marx 1990) – discussed in chapter 25 “The General Law of Capitalist Accumulation” of the first volume of the Capital. Although a famous quotation amongst Marxists is commonly used to summarise the author’s arguments3 , I would like to linger a little longer on his discussion of the Relative Surplus Population in order to establish a theoretical connection between a stagnant surplus population and the materiality of the lives of people labelled disabled in the capitalist society of the 21st century. Marx (1990, p. 794) argues that The relative surplus population exists in all kinds of forms. Every worker belongs to it during the time when he is only partially employed or wholly employed. Leaving aside the large-scale and periodically recovering forms that the changing phases of the industrial cycle impress on it, so that it sometimes appears acute, in times of crisis, and sometimes chronic, in times when business is slack, we can identify three forms which it always possesses: the floating, the latent, and the stagnant. David Harvey (2010, p. 145) clarifies that the surplus population is what “permits capitalists to super-exploit their workers without regard for their health or wellbeing”. Marx understands that there is a relation between the growth and accumulation of capital and the demand for a labour force, as capital expands so does the need for more workers - “[a]ccumulation of capital is therefore multiplication of the proletariat” (Marx 1990, p. 764). However, if the number of workers employed increases, so does the price of labour - an increase on wages - which means “a reduction in the unpaid labour the worker has to supply” (Marx 1990, p. 770). Despite its apparent simplicity, this movement is nevertheless more complex than it appears to be4 , but it can be summarised as follows: it is capitalistic accumulation itself that constantly produces, and produces in the direct ratio of its own energy and extent, a relativity redundant population of labourers, i.e., a population of greater extent than suffices for the average needs of the self-expansion of capital, and therefore a surplus-population. (Marx 1990, p. 782, my highlights). For starters, we should not forget that the sole aim of the capitalist is to produce profit5 . Capitalists are ruled by what Harvey calls “the coercive laws of competition” (2010, p. 146), in Marx’s words: “a coercive force external to him” (1990, p. 381). When wages rise, they become an obstacle between capitalists and the maximum amount of profit that can be extracted. More elements will then come into place, among others, the intensification of the exploitation of the work force and the use of technology to increase productivity and profitability (Harvey 2010; 2011; Marx 1990). One example that may be useful to illustrate such an abstract relation is that of bank workers in Brazil in the last 30 years. In the 1990s, bank employees in Brazil created influential labour unions to exert pressure on banks, therefore demanding higher quality jobs - higher salaries, less working hours, more job places, amongst others. When going on strikes, until the early 2000s, those unions would still have some influence in the decision-making process in the organisation of banks. In 2020, the widespread use of the new technology, which allows users to solve most of their needs using their smartphones, has caused demands for higher productivity, wage drops, more working hours, and an increase in unemployment in the sector - industrial reserve army. While strikes of the sector in the 1990s were catastrophic (crowds of employees on the streets, freezing of banks, very little or no money available, the support of the population), a strike in 2020 gathers a few dozen with signs in the streets that are usually ignored by most passerby, looking down at their smartphones. Leading us then to an important hallmark of capitalist labour exploitation practices: The Industrial Reserve Army as a regulator of the tensions between the exploiters and the exploited. As capital multiplies and grows, it also tends to follow two internal movements, namely concentration and centralisation. Respectively, the augmentation of capital and control of this capital in the hands of fewer people. At the other pole, it also produces what Marx called in the previous quote “a relatively redundant working population”, that is, the surplus population (Marx 1990, p. 782). This surplus population forms an army of workers who may at times be absorbed or rejected by the capital, according to the capital’s own needs (variation in the number of workers in a certain area), requirements (level of education, expertise, and/or experience), rules (wages/salaries, working hours, holidays, health insurance). In other words, “the working population therefore produces both the accumulation of capital and the means by which it is itself made relatively superfluous; and it does this to an extent to which is always increasing” (Marx 1990, p. 783). In the case of Brazilian bank clerks, the introduction of new technological machinery, as Marx calls it, allowed banks to dispose of thousands of employees and change the rules of the game, it developed new needs and new requirements. The first category of the relative surplus population characterises workers that are “sometimes repelled, sometimes attracted again in greater masses” by the job markets (Marx 1990, p. 794). A modern example may be the situation of engineering workers in Brazil - when the economy is growing, they are the first ones to be absorbed and to get higher salaries and better conditions of work. However, as the economy slows, they are repelled by the companies, made redundant, and will be unemployed again. The latent category represents those with potential to be part of the capitalist labour force but are in agricultural areas still struggling to survive with their own practices against massive capitalist companies; it is the representation of the death of a rural lifestyle. As cities and companies grow, they swallow small family farms and ranches, leaving those families with no other option but to sell their properties to the big companies, move to the cities, and sell their labour force. It is a situation portrayed in literature by Theodore Dreiser in The Lost Phoebe (1918) and by Graciliano Ramos in Vidas Secas (1938), and more recently in the American sitcom The Ranch (2016-2020), and vastly discussed in the works of Raymond Williams. The last category, the stagnant, is formed by those who must subject themselves to the lowest conditions of work, to the most irregular forms of employment, and to “a maximum of working time and a minimum of wages” (Marx 1990, p. 796) - a sediment of the working class that lives in the poorest conditions of life. Now that we have reached the stagnant category, we should remember that when Marx is discussing the three forms of relative surplus population, he is categorising workers, in other words, those who are forced to sell their workforce because they do not own any means of production – der Arbeitsmensch. They are those who are able to sell their workforce; those who are at their full capacity in body and mind to create surplus value at the lowest cost, with the lowest adaptation possible, as it is remarked by Marx (1990) and by Engels (1987). In contrast, when dealing with disability, we are considering those who have been labelled by capitalist practices, symbols, and meanings as disabled, unproductive, and as a burden to the rest of the working class. A burden to the rest of the working class because “what becomes of the operative…, in case he cannot work, is no concern of the employer” (Engels 1987, p. 543). Engels here sheds light on an important element of our discussion: the class condition is a fundamental aspect of analysis when we are discussing disability. Marx (1990, p.797, my highlights) enumerates three categories of those who dwell in pauperism – the lowest sediment of the relative surplus population’, (1) those who are able to work but who are not working; (2) orphans and pauper children; and, finally, (3) ‘the demoralized (sic), the ragged, and those unable to work, chiefly people who succumb to their incapacity for adaptation, an incapacity which results from the division of labour… Note that here he is dealing with the incapacity of adaptation. And he goes on to identify these workers as those “who have lived beyond the worker’s average lifespan; and the victims of industry… the mutilated, the sick…” (1990, p. 797, my highlights). Marx approaches both the issues of ageism and ableism in the same category to indicate that those who are deemed useless by capitalist practices and excluded from the labour market will dwell in pauperism. To clarify, pauperism is The hospital of the active labour-army and the dead weight of the industrial reserve army. Its production is included in that of the relative surplus population, its necessity is implied by their necessity; along with the surplus population, pauperism forms a condition of capitalist production, and of the capitalist development of wealth. It forms part of the faux frais of capitalist production: but capital usually knows how to transfer these from its own shoulders to those of the working-class and the petty bourgeoisie. (Marx 1990, p. 797). It seems to be implied that he differentiates the surplus population and pauperism. They are both conditioned to the ontological structure of the capitalist system and its ongoing wealth-making process. When Marx brings them together, he binds them, stating that one will be responsible for the other (the dead weight of the industrial reserve army), he is providing arguments against the traditional categorisation of disability as a personal and individual problem. Once again, disability is approached as a social, cultural, historical, and class-related issue. In a recent study, Santos (2020) scrutinised data on the living conditions of the Brazilian population comparing and contrasting the categories of race, gender, and disability with class condition. The author identifies how these elements come together to derail people’s access to a flourishing life in a racist, sexist/ patriarchal ableism, neoliberal Brazilian society. According to her, 30,06% of the population with a disability live with within the range of 0-1 minimum wage (R$ 1,100 reais) – in Brazil this means deprivation from a wide variety of essential goods and services, i.e., living in pauperism or close to pauperism. From another geographical perspective, in the United States, according to Erevelles (2011, p. 56), “[…] “one out of every four disabled people lives below the poverty line, and more than 75 percent have an individual income of less than $20,000.” In the Economic and Philosophic Manuscripts of 1844, Marx discusses the existence (Dasein) of the Arbeitsmensch in the labour-capital relationship. He points out that “[p]olitical economy… does not recognise the unoccupied worker, den Arbeitsmenschen, in so far as he happens to be outside [the] labourrelationship” (1988, p. 86), that is, it does not recognise their Dasein, their existence. According to Marx, “they are figures (Gestalten)…, specters(sic) (Gespenster) outside the domain of political economy” (1988, p. 86). Those deemed less exploitable or not exploitable are ghosts to a system that values profit over anything else. As I pointed out, when we consider the “class-disability” relationship in the working class, we are dealing with the sphere of pauperism – those on the lowest, poorest, most degrading conditions of life. These are either those who refuse to follow the system of discipline imposed by the capital or those who deviate from the ideal labour body/mind. Harvey (2010, p.149) points out that: there is the problem of what to do with people who don't conform and are therefore dubbed odd or even deviant. And this is Foucault's as well as Marx's point: they are called mad or antisocial and incarcerated in insane asylums or prisons; or as Marx notes, they get put in the stocks, mocked and punished. To be a "normal" person, therefore, is to accept a certain kind of spatiotemporal discipline convenient to a capitalist mode of production. What Marx demonstrates is that this isn't normal at all - it's a social construct that arose during this historical period in this particular way and for these particular reasons. According to Harvey, to be normal is to conform. Those who deviate will be labelled as abnormal, irrelevant, will be deemed useless, and set aside. So, normality does exist for capitalism – and it is very specific. On the one hand, it does not mean that we should simply accept it as a universal truth. On the other hand, we should not deny normality either but address it and question it. Theoretical and methodological perspectives that aim to refuse the existence of these antagonistic forces – normality and abnormality – in capitalist practices, symbols, and meanings, in an attempt to promote equality and the so-called inclusion, contribute to the ontological reproduction of the system that created the antagonism in the first place. Labelled as irrelevant and disposable to the political and economic structure, disabled people may be allocated in the Stagnant category of the Relative Surplus Population. In fact, even when they are absorbed by the system in times of need or when the system is forced to absorb them by affirmative action policies, those in the stagnant category “can be rendered superfluous at the slightest downturn of the business cycle” (Russel 2019, p. 76). Barnes (1992, p. 55) defines disability as “a diverse system of social constraints imposed on people with impairments by a highly discriminatory society — to be a disabled person means to be discriminated against”. A social approach to disability, therefore, does not deny the impairment, but understands that there is a socio-historical difference between impairment, disability, and disabled: the impairment is biological, the disability is social, and disabled is the end result of disabling a person with an impairment6 . Vygotsky (1993, p. 36) argues that “[i]n the final analysis, what decides the fate of a personality is not the defect [impairment in today’s terminology] itself, but its social consequences”. And it is this socio-psychological realisation that may or may not be a disabling one. In their development, disabled children will only require processes that will stimulate them in other ways rather than those traditionally applied at home, school, and any other social situation. As deviants of the patterns of normality, however, disabled people are many times completely or partially deprived of social participation. Deviant bodies and minds are expected to either follow the stabilised rules of society or not be part of it at all. Let us take a scene in Jack Nicholson’s One Flew over the Cuckoo’s Nest as an example. His character, Randle P. McMurphy, is in the swimming pool of a total institution for those considered mentally ill and/or intellectually disabled and tells one of guards that within six days he is going to leave the institution. To his surprise, according to the guard, he will only leave the institution when allowed to, when the doctors and nurses consider that he is able to adjust to social order. Randle is only pretending to have a disability to dodge prison, but to many of his companions it means never leaving the institution, because according to the rules, requirements, and needs of the capital they have already been deemed deviant and disposable or, as Harvey put it, they are “incarcerated in insane asylums or prisons […] they get put in the stocks, mocked and punished” (2010, p. 149).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.