Nanoscale risks are unique and outweigh nukes---math supports probability
(Duncan H. Forgan 19. Associate Lecturer at the Centre for Exoplanet Science at the University of St Andrews, Scotland, founding member of the UK Search for Extra-terrestrial Intelligence (SETI) research network and leads UK research efforts into the search. 04/30/2019. “14.3 Estimates of Existential Risk from Nanoscale Manipulation.” Solving Fermi’s Paradox, Cambridge University Press.)/LRCH Jrhee *graph omitted bc it wouldn’t copy
The nature of the nanoscale risk is quite different from the risks posed by (say) nuclear weapons. The nuclear arsenals of the Earth remain under the control of a very small number of individuals. As genetic engineering and nanotechnology mature as fields of research, the ability to manipulate the nanoscale becomes available to an increasing number of individuals. Any one of these individuals could accidentally (or purposefully) trigger a catastrophic event that destroys a civilisation. If there are E individuals with access to potentially destructive technology, and the probability that an individual destroys civilisation in any given year is P, then we can define the probability that the civilisation exists after time t and can communicate, C, as a set of independent Bernoulli trials, i.e., P(C|t, E, P) = (1 − P)Et . (14.1) Therefore, we can compute the number of civilisations existing between t = 0, t0 as N(t0) = B t0 0 P(C|t , E, P)dt (14.2) where we have assumed a constant birth rate B. This can be easily integrated to show (Sotos, 2017): N(t0) = B St0 − 1 ln S , S = (1 − P)E (14.3) At large t, this tends to the steady-state solution N(t) → B E P (14.4) i.e., there is an inverse relationship between the number of individuals in a given civilisation, and the number of civilisations remaining (Figure 14.1). The generality of this solution to Fermi’s Paradox – that the democracy of technology is the cause of its downfall – is particularly powerful. All we have assumed is that technology can be destructive, and that it eventually becomes accessible to a large enough number of individuals that the product E P becomes sufficiently large. The number of communicating civilisations as a function of time, given E individuals causing self-destruction with a probability of P per individual per year. The civilisation birth rate B is fixed at one per year. This is a sufficiently general solution that we may consider it to be hard – our definition of intelligence hinges on technology, and almost all advanced technology has a destructive use. We can already use the Great Silence to rule out the upper curves in Figure 14.1, which would yield civilisation counts that would be visible on Earth (see also section 19.2). This suggests that if this is the solution to Fermi’s Paradox, then roughly E P > 10−3.