Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

No checks or countermeasures to Nano

Dr. Olle Häggström 16 (Professor of Mathematical Statistics at Chalmers University of Technology and Associated Researcher at the Institute for Future Studies, Member of the Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences, PhD in Mathematical Statistics and MSc in Electrical Engineering, Here Be Dragons: Science, Technology and the Future of Humanity, p. 136-138, smarx, MLC)

The comparison to biology is apt, but it is not clear how convincing his idea is that it would take “some maniac” to initiate grey goo “for this very purpose.”313 Can we state with certainty that it cannot happen by mistake? It is true that self-replication will require “clever design,” but we can expect non-maniac nanotechnology engineers to attempt that, as it seems to be the most promising way to produce nanobots in the huge quantities we will need for a variety of applications. Such construction will presumably be done with a degree of precaution so as to avoid the self-replication going overboard as in the grey goo scenario, but such precautions could fail. At this point, the grey goo skeptic could point again to biology, and the fact that life has existed on our planet for billions of years without turning into grey (or green) goo, as an argument for why self-replication is unlikely to spontaneously produce such a catastrophe. While this argument has some force, it is far from conclusive, as the newly formed nanobots may, in the abstract space of possible living organisms, be located quite far from all biological life, and have very different physical and chemical properties. It is hardly absurd to think that this might give the nanobots a robust reproductive power unmatched by anything that the evolution of biological life has discovered. At the very least, this issue deserves further study. A possible middle ground could be that, on one hand, it is possible to proceed with nanobot technology without risking a grey goo scenario, provided that we respect certain safety protocols, whereas, on the other hand, grey goo would be a real danger without these precautions. Phoenix and Drexler (2004) have a number of suggestions for how nanobots can be made to self-replicate in controlled and safe fashion. A key insight is that the self-replication ability of an agent (be it a biological organism or a robot) is always contingent on its environment. Even a set of blacksmith’s tools can, in the right environment (one that provides suitable input of skills and muscle power), produce a duplicate set, and can thus be described as self-replicating. What is always needed for self-replication capability is the raw material and energy needed to produce the replicates.314 Hence, we could avoid grey goo if we construct the self-replicating machines to contain elements not available in the natural environment. But we may not even have to go that far. Phoenix and Drexler point out that a general-purpose molecular assembler will typically not be a general purpose molecular disassembler. It will, most likely, be far easier to construct an APM machine that requires its raw material to be delivered in the form of a limited range of simple chemicals (such as acetylene or acetone), rather than having the ability to extract molecular fragments and atoms from arbitrary chemical compounds. Suppose that we regulate the technology so as to make a specific list of sufficient safety precautions obligatory. With a risk such as grey goo, where the consequences of a single mishap could be global and even put an end to humanity, it is clearly not sufficient that most practitioners of the technology adhere to the regulation, or that almost all of them do: anything short of obedience to regulation from all practitioners would be unsatisfactory. Can this be ensured? This is not clear. Kurzweil (2006) advocates another safety layer, in the form of nanobots specifically designed to fight grey-goo-like outbreaks. Without defenses, the available biomass could be destroyed by gray goo very rapidly. Clearly, we will need a nanotechnology immune system in place before these scenarios become a possibility. . . . Eric Drexler, Robert Freitas, Ralph Merkle, Mike Treder, Chris Phoenix, and others have pointed out that future nanotech manufacturing devices can be created with safeguards that would prevent the accidental creation of self-replicating nanodevices. However, this observation, although important, does not eliminate the threat of gray goo as I pointed out above. There are other reasons (beyond manufacturing) that self-replicating nanobots will need to be created. The nanotechnology immune system mentioned above, for example, will ultimately require self-replication; otherwise it would be unable to defend us against the development of increasingly sophisticated types of goo. It is also likely to find extensive military applications. Moreover, a determined adversary or terrorist can defeat safeguards against unwanted self-replication; hence, the need for defense. The suggestion of setting up this kind of defense system against grey goo – which Kurzweil elsewhere calls “police nanobots” and “blue goo”315 – goes back to Drexler (1986). It makes me very uneasy. Joy (2000) points out that the system.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.