Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Err Aff on impact calculus---you’re cognitively biased against climate impacts because you haven’t experienced them, AND they’re in the far future.

Dr. Adam Briggle 21, Ph.D. in environmental studies, Colorado Boulder, associate professor and the director of graduate studies in the philosophy department at the University of North Texas, “The Unnatural Growth of the Natural,” Chapter 2 in Thinking Through Climate Change, pp 14-17, doi:10.1007/978-3-030-53587-2, pacc

The scale of the Anthropocene and the speed of the Great Acceleration pose a fundamental dilemma spotted by the German philosopher Gunther Anders early in the atomic age. For nearly all of history, our abilities to imagine (vorstellen) outstripped our abilities to produce (her-stellen). We could dream big, but we lacked the energy to build big. Now, things are inverted. Our productive powers exceed our imaginative ones. We are making a world that we cannot comprehend. The scholar Timothy Morton (2013) puts this in terms of 'hyperobjects,' phenomena that are so massively distributed across time and space as to confound our usual way of making sense of things.

Climate change is the prime example. It is there in the flood or the wildfire, but it is also not there. We can neither escape it nor keep our attention trained on it. Despite billions of dollars of scientific research, we have still never experienced or felt the climate. What we experience is weather, and it's always changing, so what's the big deal? That might explain why fossil fuels remain at around 80% of the world's energy mix—the same as it was back in 1987 (Harder 2019). The global economy hasn't decarbonized any faster during the era of climate science than it did in the two decades prior to all that knowledge (Pielke 2019).

Are we even capable of grasping what we are doing? As Nietzsche asked in his parable of the madman from The Gay Science, "Is not the greatness of this deed too great for us?" (1882, para. 125).

Climate change is everywhere and nowhere. It is now, but it can't be now because the now is the time of weather. After Hurricane Dorian devastated the Bahamas in 2019, the homeless survivors looked like victims of bad weather rather than climate. You can see how we might react to a climate apocalypse like the proverbial frog in the boiling pot of water comfortably slipping into oblivion.

Before he was forced to flee Nazi Germany in 1933, Anders married the political thinker (and fellow student of Martin Heidegger) Hannah Arendt. In her 1958 book The Human Condition, Arendt worried that we may soon no longer be able to "understand, that is to think and speak about the things which nevertheless we are able to do."

Hans Jonas (1984), another student of Heidegger's and a lifetime friend of Arendt, argued that all previous ethics could assume "that the range of human action and therefore responsibility was narrowly circumscribed." Our high-energy machines have altered the scale of our action and since ethics has to do with action, our ethics must change. But we may simply not be wired for this. If you strap someone into a functional magnetic resonance imaging machine (fMRI) and watch as they think about themselves, their medial prefrontal cortex lights up. We care deeply about ourselves. The lights get dimmer and dimmer as we think about people further removed from this central ego—family, friends, and acquaintances (see Walsh 2019). Thinking about a stranger in the Bahamas who lost their home hardly creates any spark at all.

It's not just spatial scales that challenge our moral psychology. It's also time. The prefrontal cortex even dims when you think about yourself in the future. As economists know, we discount the near future, which means it is worth less. The far future is entirely worthless, but of course what we call the "far future" is no time at all for the planet. There's the problem: we are geological agents unable to think geologically. Time and space are slipping from our grasp. This is why "global weirding" is a good term for what is happening.

Anders (1957) wrote that your first thought upon waking up in the morning should be 'Atom.' You should call to mind the enormous powers pulsing under the seemingly steady day-to-day world. "For you should not begin your day," he continued, "with the illusion that what surrounds you is a stable world." Your second thought should be: "The possibility of the Apocalypse is our work. But we know not what we are doing." Even the experts are ignorant when it comes to the whole. We cannot "realize the reality which we can bring into being." There is a gap between our actions and our imagination. Weird things are falling through the crack.

What was a gap in the time of Arendt and Anders is now a chasm. We have altered the energy balance of the entire planet. Now our first thought on waking in the morning should be CARBON, because the extra energy trapped in the ribbon-thin atmosphere from greenhouse gas emissions is equivalent to that released by 400,000 nuclear bombs exploding every day (Hansen 2012). We are proving that Heraclitus was right with his original philosophy of energy: all is fire.

* * *

The challenge facing us is unlike any other in human history: We have to fathom the world that we are making. The understanding that we require is not just scientific or technological, and the 'energy' we have to fathom is not just the stuff stored in chemical bonds, flowing through pipelines, or buzzing across wires. The energy transition that caused the Anthropocene is not just the one to nuclear power and fossil fuels. Something deeper happened over the last few hundred years. There was a revaluation of values, a transition from a world of virtues to a world of volts. As a result, the metabolic energies of human labor and consumption became unhinged and we started eating the planet.

Living organisms constantly wrest themselves from non-self. They pull in air and nourishment for their metabolic fires. The basic energies of life are labor and consumption (which are two stages of the same process), and they are incessant. I will feel the pangs of hunger tonight even though I just ate lunch. It will come again in the morning and for the rest of my life. The caloric demands of the consuming and laboring body cease only upon death. But this incessant activity, Arendt argued, is one that spins round and round a wheel and in that sense it "remained stationary" for all of human history. All along the long shaft of the hockey stick, human energy was "imprisoned in the eternal recurrence of the life process to which it was tied" (Arendt 1958, p. 46).

The jutting blade of the hockey stick, the Great Acceleration, is the rupturing of the chains that had kept this incessant life process spinning cyclically. Labor and consumption were taken from the dark interior of the private realm and admitted into the public realm. The household economy became the global economy. Labor, Arendt notes, has become liberated "from its circular, monotonous recurrence and transformed...into a swiftly progressing development whose results have in a few centuries totally changed the whole inhabited world" (p. 47). As Nietzsche put it, we lost all sense of limit or measure and embraced "the thrill of the infinite." We went from a world of virtues to a world of volts.

Arendt thought that this was a paradox. She called it "the unnatural growth of the natural," because the natural metabolic energy transformations were unleashed beyond all natural boundaries. We call this economic growth. Just as I need to feed my own metabolic fire with lunch, we need to feed this global metabolic fire. The difference is, though, that my body only grows to a point and then stops. The collective body of the Anthropocene keeps growing beyond all proportion and measure. There is no limit, no sense of sufficiency.

Can this continue? As I was writing this book, climate change morphed into the climate crisis. Greenland experienced a record ice melt. There were record heat waves in Europe, and unprecedented fires and floods around the world. The hockey stick blades kept reaching alarming new highs. Despite climate treaties, global CO2 emissions kept going up. The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), the world's most respected source of climate science, issued new studies with grim news about the impact of the human economy on planet Earth. Saying that they have a "moral obligation" to "tell it like it is," over 11,000 scientists broke with the more conservative rhetoric of the IPCC and issued a statement proclaiming that "Earth is facing a climate emergency" (Ripple et al. 2019). Prominent voices warned that the Earth may soon be uninhabitable (Wallace-Wells 2019) and that the human game may be playing itself out (McKibben 2019).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.