NATO states have differing positions on responsible use for AI – the potential exists for agreement, but states are implementing their own policies.
Stanley-Lockman, 2021 - Center for Security and Emerging Technology [Zoe CSET Issue Brief August “Responsible and Ethical Military AI Allies and Allied Perspectives” https://cset.georgetown.edu/publication/responsible-and-ethical-military-ai/ Acc. 4/21/22 TA]
With more of a focus on norms and state responsibility, a broader definition of responsibility beyond the DOD “responsible AI” principle can also introduce new convergences for U.S. RAI implementation. The DOD RAI Strategy and Implementation Pathway recently tasked by Deputy Secretary Kathleen Hicks can incorporate these views and help allies refine their approaches to AI ethics in order to enable greater cooperation and allied AI adoption. This is because many allies see firm approaches to managing ethical risk as a prerequisite policy question before investing in AI-enabled capability development—including defensive systems and countermeasures. Overall, international engagement is mutually beneficial to responsible AI endeavors. The United States should look at how other countries are implementing their approaches, just as the United States can exert influence and maintain its leadership role in responsible and ethical AI for defense by helping its allies and partners form their own views in alignment with one another. Conclusion No single actor has a monopoly on the answers to implementing responsible AI in any high-risk area, let alone defense. Cooperation is therefore important to collectively navigate the difficulties of responsible governance of emerging technologies. For DOD, the focus has been predominantly on the transposition of safe and ethical AI principles into action. Rather than adopting principles for defense, some allies are moving straight into implementation. Thus far, this is borne out in tabletop exercises, outreach, ministerial committees, ethical reviews, education and certifications, exercises and trials, and defense programs of record. It is too early to judge these fledgling efforts, but tracking their evolution may prove useful to broader AI ethics implementation, be it for other defense ministries or even civilian actors. While jumping straight to implementation can mean a more pragmatic focus on tools, tracking how different AI stakeholders use those tools may be more difficult. In this way, principles can be seen as a helpful organizing force, as is the case for DOD. This said, the scale of the U.S. military bureaucracy and national security innovation base may require higher visibility relative to allied counterparts. Still, another key difference is precisely this visibility. The analysis here is based on information in the public domain, which may also partially explain its transatlantic tilt. The U.S. approach to responsible and ethical AI for defense also differs from other countries in that the consultation and process that led to its principles is far more transparent than is true for most allies. A possible Catch-22 could be at play here, with allies reticent to publicize approaches to such controversial issues, despite the fact that offering such inroads can build trust and confidence that governments are handling these high-stakes questions responsibly.