Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Every person has inherent worth – if we value ourselves, then we Must respect the value of others to be consistent. Sacrificing the dignity of some to protect others denies equal dignity and is morally unacceptable. Every person must be treated as an end in and of themselves.

Applbaum, 1998 - Professor of Ethics and Public Policy at the Carr Center for Human Rights Policy [Arthur "Are Violations of Rights Ever Right?*." Ethics 108.2 (1998): 340-366 Acc 12/27/20 TA]

Since we think of ourselves as beings that matter, consistency demands that we extend that status to others. Says Nagel, ‘‘I believe, as did Kant, that what drives us in the direction of universal- izability is the difficulty each person has in regarding himself as having value only for himself, but not in himself. If people are not ends in themselves—i.e. impersonally valuable—then they have a much lower order of worth.’’ If one wishes to view and value oneself as a being that is an end in itself, and not as a means to be used for the ends of others, then the status of an end must be extended to others. The violation of other persons—using them as means—therefore is an impersonal bad, something we all have reason to avoid and prevent. But if such violation is bad, why should we not seek to minimize violations, even if that sometimes requires a lesser violation? Because a violation-minimizing violation uses one as a means for the ends of others and so fails to treat persons as ends in themselves. If persons are to matter in the highest possible way, then morality must value not only the absence of violations of persons, but the treatment of persons as beings who have the status of being inviolable—whose violation is not permissible. ‘‘What actually happens to us is not the only thing we care about: What may be done to us is also important, quite apart from whether or not it is done to us—and the same is true of what we may do as opposed to what we actually do.’’ Since having the status of inviolability is of great value, if morality permits violations so as to maximize the good of not being violated, all persons cease to have a high degree of inviolability, which is a great bad. We all may be better off in a world in which morality always treated us as ends, and so where it is always morally impermissible to violate us, even though we are thereby more likely to suffer violation at the hands of immoral actors

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.