Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Only respecting human dignity prevents treating humans as a means to an end. Utilitarianism is an instrumental rationality, which denies human dignity.

Heyns, 2016 - Professor of Human Rights Law, University of Pretoria [Christof, Human Rights Quarterly 38 (2016) 350–378 “ Human Rights and the use of Autonomous Weapons Systems (AWS) During Domestic Law Enforcement” https://www.academia.edu/37475669/Human_Rights_and_the_use_of_Autonomous_Weapons_Systems_AWS_During_Domestic_Law_Enforcement Acc 12/27/20 TA]

There are different conceptions of dignity. For example, it has a religious connotation for some and is tied up with the belief that humans are created in the image of God (imago Dei);87 others rely on the Kantian notion that each person should be treated as an end and not as a means.88 Dignity can also be seen as related to the capacity of someone to be a moral person and as moral responsibility.89 Violations of dignity often take the form of physical infringements of the person, but it is not confined to that—not being able to act out one’s moral choices could be another form of indignity. Underlying the concept of dignity is a strong emphasis on the idea of the infinite or incommensurable value of each person.90 The Kantian concept of dignity assigns this value to each person as a separate and unique, or irreplaceable, individual. Acts of indignity involve an unwarranted reduction of this worth. Each person has an inner core that may not be infringed upon, even if such infringement would be beneficial to the common good because that would mean they are used as a tool. Individual dignity cannot be accounted for properly within schemes of instrumental rationality, where competing claims are measured against each other based on their assigned weights, because each human being is considered to be of infinite value.91 Exactly whose dignity is potentially at stake? In the first place, I would submit, the concern should be about the dignity of those at the receiving end of the force used: those targeted as well as those caught in the crossfire.92 Secondly, the dignity of those in whose name force is used may also be at stake. The effect of AWS on the dignity of these two different categories will now be considered in turn. How does the use of AWS impact the dignity of those subjected to the use of force? It has been argued that to have the decision whether one lives or dies being made by machines is the ultimate indignity and similar arguments can be made about other forms of force, especially if they are potentially lethal or can seriously maim. 93 A machine, bloodless and without morality or mortality, cannot fathom the significance of using force against a human being and cannot do justice to the gravity of the decision.94 Each instance where force is used against a human being requires that another human being should decide afresh whether to cross that threshold. The heuristic argumentation used by computers fails to capture and do justice the complexity and fullness of human life and decisions about life. Robots cannot be preprogrammed to respond in an appropriate way to the infinite number of scenarios that real life—and real people—offer.95 Death by algorithm means that people are treated simply as targets and not as complete and unique human beings, who may, by virtue of that status, meet a different fate. They are placed in a position where an appeal to the humanity of the person on the other side is not possible. Some have argued that people in such situations are treated like pests or objects, as a nuisance that must be gotten rid of, rather than as someone with inherent dignity.96 When someone comes into the sights of a computer, that person is literally reduced to numbers: the zeros and the ones of bits.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.