Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

NATO is key to ethical principles for AI weapons due to its democratic principles and its existing agencies with experience in AI

Stanley-Lockman, 2021 - Center for Security and Emerging Technology [Zoe CSET Issue Brief August “Responsible and Ethical Military AI Allies and Allied Perspectives” https://cset.georgetown.edu/publication/responsible-and-ethical-military-ai/ Acc. 4/21/22 TA]

Multilateral Institutions Focusing on Ethical and Responsible AI in Defense Understanding ethics and legality as part of the adoption of emerging technologies is not only a priority for democratic countries, but also a topic of interest for multilateral institutions that are part of the security and defense architecture. Autonomy in weapons has been on the agenda at the UN level for longer than the countries highlighted here have spent time bridging technical and policy approaches to responsible AI in defense. Select multilateral institutions are also critical for consultations and alignment about these issues. Beyond those mentioned here, several smaller allies may be waiting for multilateral views to then drive their own approaches to RAI, rather than dedicating resources to first issuing national views that will later have to align with broader multilateral structures. NATO is an obvious player in this domain, for reasons that are described below. The emerging PfD is important as an AI-specific multilateral format for like-minded countries—including non-treaty partners—to coalesce on this policy area. North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) NATO is an important actor because it can help coordinate and facilitate consultations between allies to come to agreement on how ethical and responsible AI developments impact interoperability, cohesion, and operations. Further, the NATO Defence Planning Process is the primary defense planning tool for many Allies.142 The focus on principles for “responsible use” is consistent with NATO’s added value without dwelling too much on development—which happens primarily at the national (or bi- /multilateral levels outside of NATO).143 Here, responsibility refers both to best practices in engineering (e.g., ethical design) and responsible state behavior.144 The North Atlantic Council and Military Committee—the senior civilian and military decisionmaking bodies in NATO—began contending with EDTs, including AI, in 2018.145 This high-level interest built on several years of military and scientific experience at the working levels, as well as the introduction of conceptual and operational considerations in the workstream of Allied Command Transformation and the NATO Science & Technology Organization in the 2010s. When presenting on EDTs to the senior civilian and military leadership at NATO in 2018, then-Supreme Allied Commander Transformation General Denis Mercier stressed that legal, ethical, and political differences between Allies could “endanger our capacity to operate together.”146 He also focused on considerations around the “level of confidence in new technologies” as an adoption factor that is not purely technical.147 This set the tone for political alignment on ethical concerns across the Alliance—already building on the foundations of the shared value embodied in the North Atlantic Charter and legal framework in which NATO operates. Subsequently, in October 2019, the Allies agreed to an EDT Roadmap that cited “legal and ethical norms” and “arms control aspects” as key technology areas among Alliance priorities to consider.148 The political will to cooperate on technologies was solidified in February 2021, when NATO Defence Ministers endorsed an EDT Strategy.149

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.