Even if dialogue does not produce a viable plan, the process of discussion promotes cohesion through shared values.
Hill and Marsan, 2018 - Director and Senior Assistant, NATO Office of Legal Affairs [Steven and Nadia, 7-18-18 “Artificial Intelligence and Accountability: A Multinational Legal Perspective” https://www.sto.nato.int/publications/STO%20Meeting%20Proceedings/STO-MP-IST-160/MP-IST-160-PP-4.pdf Acc 4/21/22 TA]
In the 2016 Warsaw Summit Communiqué, NATO Heads of State and Government recognized that “the changed and evolving security environment demands the ability to meet challenges and threats of any kind and from any direction”.2 As an Alliance of 29 Nations focused on collective defense as one of its core tasks, NATO must be prepared to address emerging threats and security challenges arising from the development of new technologies. Among these, the development and use of Artificial Intelligence (AI) presents both opportunities and challenges to the North Atlantic security landscape. On 22 March 2018, Allied Command Transformation, NATO’s adaptation hub located in Norfolk, Virginia in the United States of America, organized an informal workshop with NATO Ambassadors and Military Representatives to discuss the impact of the development of disruptive technologies on the Alliance. One question raised concerned the interoperability challenges NATO could face as Allies develop disruptive technology with differing capabilities. A take-away from the discussion is that Nations may wish to discuss some of the legal implications of this emerging technology in a multilaterally forum such as NATO. We have already witnessed the effect that the development and use of AI is having on Allied security: the recent revelations regarding the use of Facebook data by a consulting firm for political leverage show that automated data processes providing sophisticated profiling of individuals can be used to manipulate the fundamental elements of democracy, with potentially profound effects on security. How Allies respond to this changed security environment, both individually and collectively, raises a number of legal questions. The cross-cutting nature and widespread impact of AI-enabled technologies necessitates multinational discussion and debate. For now, these debates are fueled by the absence of State practice and jurisprudence on the development and use of AI-enabled technology. Multinational organizations such as NATO can provide a venue for discussion amongst Allies, providing a forum where States can express their views on these issues from a military and security perspective. As of yet, there are no NATO policies providing guidance on how to address the development and use of AI technology. Consequently, this paper provides some preliminary observations from the personal perspective of NATO legal advisers who have begun to encounter these issues rather than on the basis of agreed NATO positions or doctrine. It is therefore intended to introduce rather than resolve some of the key legal issues that are likely to arise in future AI-related discussions within NATO. This paper begins by presenting the concept of “legal interoperability,” one of the tools that legal advisers working in NATO seek to promote. It then introduces some of the current legal issues and debates surrounding the development and use of AI, including the difficulty in defining key concepts arising out of the increased use of AI such as “autonomy,” and questions pertaining to accountability.3 Finally, this paper examines how further dialogue among Allies and with NATO partners can contribute to the development of a reliable approach on accountability issues related to AI-enabled technology. The paper argues that given the rapidly evolving technology and the asymmetric approach and capabilities of nations on the matter, efforts within the Alliance should focus on ensuring NATO’s “legal preparedness” so that collective action is not thwarted by legal hurdles and mismatched legal approaches.