Different ethical perspectives can undermine political cohesion – different ethical perspectives can increase burden sharing tensions
Stanley-Lockman, 2021 - Center for Security and Emerging Technology [Zoe CSET Issue Brief August “Responsible and Ethical Military AI Allies and Allied Perspectives” https://cset.georgetown.edu/publication/responsible-and-ethical-military-ai/ Acc. 4/21/22 TA]
This philosophical debate is implicit in the Defence Ethics Committee’s opinions, and is relevant to adjacent questions about AI for two practical reasons. First is that French military officers see the need for guiding principles for technology that increases operational distance or can be applied to grey-zone activity. They note that ethics and law are well structured in rules of engagement, commander’s intent, and compliance with legal frameworks for conflict. But because these often only apply above a certain threshold of hostility, guidance that allows the armed forces to maintain “ethics and moral strength” for other types of military activity is lacking.69 This includes governance for technology that increases the distance between operators and operations, including in the information domain. As technology broadens and accelerates changes to the operating environment, taking these ethical and moral considerations into account could necessitate new “deontological principles” on duty and obligation for the French Armed Forces.70 The concept of distance from operations enters into advisory opinions, both in relation to automation bias and psychological effects. But even with the advisory opinions of the ministerial committee, such a framework is still missing.71 Second is that different allied perspectives on distance from operations could affect coalition operations if political differences widen. If guiding principles on distance from operations enter into rules of engagement or prompt questions about commanders’ intent and responsibility, then different ethical bases for the use of new technologies in warfare could create political tensions. More specifically, if the more technologically advanced allies send more AI-enabled support and fewer troops as their contributions to coalition operations, some allies may perceive that others are not willing to equally share the burden of risks to life.72 If not managed, sensitive issues that stem from different ethical risk calculations could decrease political cohesion.