2. Hope – Autonomous AI weapons deny dignity because algorithmic decisions deny Hope, which is essential to dignity.
Heyns, 2016 - Professor of Human Rights Law, University of Pretoria [Christof, Human Rights Quarterly 38 (2016) 350–378 “ Human Rights and the use of Autonomous Weapons Systems (AWS) During Domestic Law Enforcement” https://www.academia.edu/37475669/Human_Rights_and_the_use_of_Autonomous_Weapons_Systems_AWS_During_Domestic_Law_Enforcement Acc 12/27/20 TA]
The interrelated considerations of time and hope play a role in this context. One of the problems presented by computer algorithms that determine when AWS will be allowed to release force is that they do so in advance, on the basis of hypotheticals, while there is no true and pressing emergency rendering such a far-reaching decision unavoidable. Even if it may be permissible in a real emergency to take far-reaching measures, it does not follow that such decisions can be taken in the abstract. Decisionmaking by politicians and scientists about the life and limb of people based on theoretical possibilities contemplated in the halls of the legislature or laboratories risks trivializing the issues at stake. Hypotheticals such as the ticking-bomb scenario present the same kind of problem. It makes crossing the threshold of using force against another human being too easy. The statute authorizing the shooting down of the plane, struck down in the German Air Security case cited above, had a similar quality—it authorized in advance, in the abstract, the ending of the lives of imaginary passengers. This seems to fly in the face of the requirement that the use of force against a human being should be a measure of last resort.97 Hope, often against the odds, is an important part of our psychological makeup and dealing with the harshness of reality.98 A sentence of life without parole, for example, like the death penalty, can be seen as a violation of dignity because it means “writing off” the person, not leaving open the possibility of hope. The possibility of a deliberative process somewhere down the line, where a change of mind and fate is possible, is ruled out in advance by the introduction of AWS if human control is sacrificed in the process A world in which death comes with the certainty of science, with no prospect, however farfetched, of a last minute change of plan, or the possibly of human compassion—what may be called humanitarian override—offers little room for hope. Hope in this sense—and thus dignity—may be one of the casualties of AWS.