Focusing on dignity is essential to make the ban successful – it resonates with the public.
Rosert, 2019 - Professor for International Relations at Universität Hamburg [Elvira, with Frank Sauer Researcher at Bundeswehr, Global Policy, July 5 “Prohibiting Autonomous Weapons: Put Human Dignity First” https://doi.org/10.1111/1758-5899.12691 Acc 12/27/20 TA]
The discourse about LAWS is not and does not have to be confined to the CCW discussions. While human dignity is admittedly not a crucial point of reference within this particular forum, it is a universal and ubiquitous concept that does resonate with States Parties in other UN fora (such as the General Assembly, for instance). In addition, as of 2019, it is in fact quite likely that the CCW will yet again end up being merely an incubator for regulative action. Should the process surrounding LAWS leave the CCW, proponents of a ban on LAWS must be ready to refocus on human dignity. After all, in the US, 55 per cent of the public is opposed to LAWS (Carpenter, 2013); in Germany, 71 per cent of the population is against handing weapons control in warfare over to AI (YouGov 2018). And international opinion polls conducted online by the Open Roboethics Initiative (2015) as well as by IPSOS (CSKR 2019b; Roff, 2017) indicate not only a similar picture but even growing resistance against LAWS at the global level. Since the public's reaction to LAWS is mostly visceral, rather than based on legal considerations, putting human dignity first will gain traction. This point is granted even by skeptics of our line of argument: ‘There could be some campaigning advantages. Saying that something is against human dignity evokes a strong visceral response’ (Sharkey, 2018, p. 9).