Legal interoperability is key to NATO cohesion and operational interoperability - different legal viewpoints make it impossible to coordinate militarily.
Hill and Marsan, 2018 - Director and Senior Assistant, NATO Office of Legal Affairs [Steven and Nadia, 7-18-18 “Artificial Intelligence and Accountability: A Multinational Legal Perspective” https://www.sto.nato.int/publications/STO%20Meeting%20Proceedings/STO-MP-IST-160/MP-IST-160-PP-4.pdf Acc 4/21/22 TA]
1.0 THE NATO CONTEXT: LEGAL INTEROPERABILITY NATO is an Alliance of values, and one of the core values that the Alliance defends is the rule of law. The commitment to respect the rule of law is enshrined in the preamble to the 1949 North Atlantic Treaty and is reaffirmed in declarations by NATO Heads of State and Government at their regular Summit meetings. It is a key element of NATO and NATO-led operations and is necessary to ensuring legitimacy and securing public support. Compliance with international law is an essential component of NATO’s success in all of its endeavours and activities. Correspondingly, the demand for legal advice from over 70 legal offices that make up the NATO legal community has never been higher. The scope of issues on which the typical NATO legal adviser is called to advise on can be daunting and guidance on Allied views is not always available, especially in an easy-to-access consolidated format. This is especially true in the context of emerging technologies such as the security impact of AI-enabled tools. Under the auspices of the NATO Office of Legal Affairs, NATO has launched and reinvigorated a number of legal dialogues, including with Allies, partner nations and international organisations. Such legal dialogues are essential to understanding Allies’ potentially conflicting legal postures. NATO Allies each have their sovereign domestic legal systems and are bound by different international legal obligations. Allies also often have their own understanding on what international law obligations are applicable to them and under what conditions. As an alliance of 29 nations, NATO takes all decisions by consensus and the main challenge in such a multilateral environment is enabling Nations to act together in line with the individual legal obligations of each, taking account of the differences in applicable legal parameters. A key technique that legal advisers use to help achieve consensus despite these legal differences is “legal interoperability”. “Legal interoperability” is derived from the military concept of interoperability of forces, whereby the military forces of the 29 Allies are able to work together to achieve common objectives. NATO doctrine defines the interoperability of forces as “[t]he ability of the forces of two or more nations to train, exercise and operate effectively together in the execution of assigned missions and tasks.”4 In the Warsaw Summit Communiqué, Allied Heads of State and Government referred to the need for interoperability to accomplish NATO’s goals. Within NATO, there is often a diversity of legal views on core issues of international law. Let us take, for example, the laws of war, where 27 of NATO’s 29 Allies are party to the Additional Protocols to the Geneva Conventions. This challenge is also reflected in International Criminal Law as the Rome Statute establishing the International Criminal Court is likewise adopted only by 27 Allies. As a military Alliance founded on the rule of law, these sometimes different legal obligations can be challenging. The challenges are especially daunting when there is a need for a rapid decision by Allies based on collective consensus and requiring legal justification. NATO’ raison d’être is collective defence, and legal interoperability is one of the key enablers for the Alliance. From a legal perspective, interoperability refers to the need for Nations to work together in a variety of contexts despite the application of differing legal frameworks and obligations. As one observer of NATO operational law defined it, “‘[l]egal interoperability’ is understood … as the ability of the forces of two or more nations to operate effectively together in the execution of assigned missions and tasks and with full respect for their legal obligations, notwithstanding the fact that nations concerned have varying legal obligations and varying interpretations of these obligations.” 5 Legal interoperability relies on a broad understanding of those areas of legal divergence amongst Allies, which requires careful analysis of the legal positions expressed by the relevant Nations. In the case of new technologies, this understanding is difficult to acquire, in part because Nations have not had the opportunity to set forth their legal views or have refrained from doing so in order to prevent the loss of a potential technological edge. Within NATO, legal interoperability has proven to be indispensable to rapid decision-making and is facilitated by Allies’ pragmatism when faced with questions of collective security, emphasizing and relying on those elements that are common to all rather than on those elements of divergence.