The PfD did not resolve AI disagreements between participants and did not include some key nations.
Trabucco, 2020 - Research Assistant at the Centre for Military Studies at the University of Copenhagen [Lena, May 10 “AI Partnership for Defense is a Step in the Right Direction – But Will Face Challenges” http://opiniojuris.org/2020/10/05/ai-partnership-for-defense-is-a-step-in-the-right-direction-but-will-face-challenges/ Acc 4/17/22 TA]
Despite the many benefits and opportunities, the partnership will face challenges as it defines the boundaries and practices of the collaboration. I believe three challenges ought to be raised at the outset. DoD officials have discussed interoperability as a an explicit goal of the partnership – interoperability being an umbrella term referring to group integration in order to operate cohesively and share information effectively. Interoperability is a necessary yet difficult achievement in any kind of partnership, but the AI partnership has a unique challenge. Namely, one of legal interoperability. Legal interoperability is one subset of the broader partnership interoperability and refers to the pursuit of the partnership’s goals within the participating state’s diverse legal obligations and interpretations. The partnership must find a way to achieve their ultimate goal in a manner consistent with domestic and international legal obligations of the participating states. Differing regulatory frameworks and data strategies among participants could lead to inadvertent challenges to the AI partnership legal interoperability. This is particularly relevant for the European partners, which currently constitute over half of the AI partnership. The European Union has deliberately distinguished the European approach to AI from China and the US, instead situating itself as the global leader advancing responsible and trustworthy AI. As part of this strategy, the EU submitted substantial proposals for data regulation and restrictions. Public and private organizations in these states are subject to European data regulation and restriction. It is not yet clear how these differences may affect the AI partnership; largely because it is still in its infancy and the DoD has not offered many specifics about the partnership in practice. But the issue could become a major one as the partnership moves forward. If the US hopes to expand the partnership to include more European partners, then the different approaches to data sharing could become a legal hurdle that hinders the legal interoperability – and thus partnership interoperability – potentially requiring special agreements. The second challenge is about which states are – and which states are not – included in the partnership (so far). The larger trans-Atlantic implications of the partnership should not be neglected as the collaboration moves forward. Crucial European partners are missing, such as Germany and the Netherlands. Germany is the biggest economy in Europe and a readily acknowledges the economic possibilities of AI development. The Netherlands has yet to reach the AI development of some of its European counterparts, but the Dutch government has been explicit about investing into research initiatives to bolster the Netherlands in the AI landscape. Mark Beall, JAIC Chief of Strategy, expressed his hope that more states will join the AI partnership in the future; but the absence of some of Europe’s heavy hitters could signal a bigger issue for the partnership. Commentators have expressed concern of a trans-Atlantic divide, and an intra-European divide, on AI in the military domain. See, for example, here and here.