Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Dialogue can clarify the definition of AI which facilitates solutions

Allen, 2022 - Director, AI Governance Project, Strategic Technologies Program at CSIS [Gregory C. June 6 “DOD Is Updating Its Decade-Old Autonomous Weapons Policy, but Confusion Remains Widespread” https://www.csis.org/analysis/dod-updating-its-decade-old-autonomous-weapons-policy-confusion-remains-widespread Acc 6/6/22 TA]

As it updates the policy, there are at least four key issues that DOD needs to address. The first two will require actual changes to the policy, while the latter two can be addressed simply by providing additional clarification and guidance, perhaps through publication of a policy handbook. Define how a system’s “AI-enabled” status does or does not affect the policy’s requirements. Define how retraining machine learning models will be handled in the senior review process. Clarify the specific features that formally define an autonomous weapon system. Clarify the types of weapons that are and are not required to go through the autonomous weapon senior review process. While the final word on these issues must come directly from DOD, the sections below attempt to shed some initial light. Define how a system’s “AI-enabled” status does or does not affect the policy’s requirements. The debate over what constitutes AI as opposed to mere mechanical computation and automation goes back at least as far as the 1830s, when Ada Lovelace worked with Charles Babbage to design and program the first mechanical computers. In recent decades, computer systems that in their heyday were routinely called “AI,” such as IBM’s chess-playing Deep Blue system in 1997, have higher-performing successors today that are merely called “software” or “apps.” Machine learning, a subfield of AI that has been responsible for extraordinary research and commercialization progress since 2012, is more often than not used as a synonym for AI—so much so that some argue that any system that does not use machine learning should not be referred to as AI. It is important to know whether a system claiming to be AI-enabled is using machine learning. Machine learning works differently from traditional software. It is better at some things, worse at others, requires different factors to enable success, and has different failure modes and risks that need to be addressed. When the U.S. military says that a given system is AI-enabled or that a given project is an “AI project,” it almost always means machine learning. While describing a military system as AI-enabled or machine learning-enabled provides useful information, it often remains unclear just what functionality is being provided by AI and how central AI is to the system overall. Suppose, hypothetically, that the F-35 Joint Strike Fighter Program Office decided that it should use machine learning to improve the performance on one of the aircraft’s many different types of sensors. Does that mean that the entire F-35 program, with its more than $8.5 billion in annual spending, is building AI-enabled weapon systems? The DODD 3000.09 update is a good opportunity to formally define “AI-enabled” in DOD policy and to specify how using machine learning does or does not affect the autonomous weapon senior review process. Confusingly, common usage of these terms differs significantly in other countries. For example, Russian weapons manufacturers routinely refer to their automated and robotic military systems as using AI even if the system does not use machine learning, and they rarely make it clear when it does. Varied definitions complicate international diplomacy on these subjects.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.