Non–Unique - Most legal and philosophical values lack agreed upon definitions.
Rosert, 2019 - Professor for International Relations at Universität Hamburg [Elvira, with Frank Sauer Researcher at Bundeswehr, Global Policy, July 5 “Prohibiting Autonomous Weapons: Put Human Dignity First” https://doi.org/10.1111/1758-5899.12691 Acc 12/27/20 TA]
From a strategic communication point of view, adjusting the message toward the infringement on human dignity would have the general benefit of dampening the overall level of contention. After all, while the suggestion to rest the case against LAWS more firmly on human dignity has drawn some scrutiny itself (see the overview in Sharkey, 2018), the supposed ‘awkwardness’ (Baker, 2018) of this proposal is commonly substantiated by pointing out that several meanings of dignity exist and that there is no agreed‐upon definition of dignity. Yet, being vague but relevant and even crucially important is a characteristic of many normative and even legally codified concepts. The concepts of civilian‐ness, of proportionality, or of unnecessary suffering – cornerstones of IHL despite all their ambiguities – are just three examples. Moreover, what we argue specifically is that mobilizing human dignity would strengthen the stance against LAWS by making it more resilient against consequentialist challenges, at least when compared to legal claims. After all, the legal claim that LAWS are indiscriminate weapons violating the principle of distinction might, in fact, prove vulnerable due to (unlikely but not impossible) technological progress that increases their discriminatory capabilities and even equips them with the (equivalent of) ‘common sense’ and battlefield awareness that human commanders possess (Amoroso et al., 2018, p. 33). In fact, this exact point is already being invoked by opponents of a prohibition on LAWS, and it keeps forcing its proponents into (rather pointless) hypothetic legal and technological debates. In addition, the emphasis on the protection of civilians from LAWS might jeopardize the call for a comprehensive ban and instead end in mere restrictions on the use of LAWS (e.g. in pre‐specified ‘kill boxes’ or domains like the high seas where the presence of civilians is considered unlikely) (Anderson and Waxman, 2013; Schmitt and Thurnher, 2013; Schmitt, 2013; HRW, 2016).