Britain would support the plan – their Integrated Review Command Paper proves they support ethics regulations for AI
Stanley-Lockman, 2021 - Center for Security and Emerging Technology [Zoe CSET Issue Brief August “Responsible and Ethical Military AI Allies and Allied Perspectives” https://cset.georgetown.edu/publication/responsible-and-ethical-military-ai/ Acc. 4/21/22 TA]
In the U.K., ethical and normative aspects of AI feature in recent strategic documents, including the government’s Integrated Review of national security and international policy, and in the Ministry of Defence’s accompanying Command Paper published a week later in March 2021. The Integrated Review names “supporting the effective and ethical adoption of AI and data technologies” and “identifying international opportunities to collaborate on AI R&D, ethics and regulation” as aspects that can help build public trust and early adoption of military AI.94 This is consistent with the Ministry of Defence’s contributions to achieving the British strategic interest of “the ethical development and deployment of technology based on democratic values,” as reaffirmed in the Command Paper.95 One area of daylight between the two documents, however, is the Integrated Review’s concern about the gap between the pace of global governance and the development of standards and norms, in contrast to the Command Paper’s stated need for “standards and norms for the responsible and ethical adoption of these new technologies.”96 How exactly the U.K. Ministry of Defence will approach these interrelated military governance challenges is due to become clearer in the near future. More specifically, the U.K. plans to establish a new Defence AI Centre in order to centralize its AI developments.97 Further, the U.K. Ministry of Defence is planning to publish a Defence AI Strategy that will incorporate ethical adoption considerations.98 A ministerial AI ethics committee is also currently analyzing AI in defense, including issues related to trust.99 In terms of oversight, both the new Defence AI Centre and this committee are important developments to bridge ethical AI endeavors at the working level with a higher degree of political and strategic attention. The U.K. approach to military AI adoption includes a process for developing guidelines on ethical AI, which includes public-facing aspects led by the Defence Science and Technology Laboratory (Dstl).100 Dstl established an AI Lab in 2018, which has made it the natural home for technical questions related to ethics, risk, and safety concerns.101 While few details of the ministerial AI ethics committee are available at the time of writing, Dstl’s activities advancing AI ethics in defense provide an indication of the U.K. approach. For instance, Dstl sponsors an ethics fellow at the Turing Institute to focus on “improving robustness, resilience, and responses of systems that support logistical, tactical and strategic operations, as well as wider applications in urban analytics, cybersecurity and social data science.”102 Furthermore, in 2020, they also hosted a conference that focused on safety, robustness, trustworthiness—which is part of the process on creating ethical guidelines for military adoption of AI.103