Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Turn – Reputation – ethical norms attract top AI developers and improves the reliability of the weapons – this improves NATO’s technological superiority. It also prevents accidental wars.

Kahn and Horowitz, 2021 – Research and Senior Fellows at the Council on Foreign Relations [Lauren and Michael, The Washington Quarterly 44:4 “Leading in Artificial Intelligence through Confidence Building Measures” https://doi.org/10.1080/0163660X.2021.2018794 Acc 6/6/22 TA]

Leadership in standard-setting and confidence-building measures will also enhance US military capability, rather than constraining the US military, assisting the United States in strategic competition. Unsafe AI systems do not just risk unintentional conflict and inadvertent escalation—they are less likely to be effective systems. Committing to lead the world in AI safety could create a ripple effect in the US defense enterprise and the private sector about putting a premium on safe and ethical AI, in turn making it more likely that military (and civilian) uses of algorithms are reliable, improving their utility for the military. Such signaling will also likely improve the reputation of the US military with Silicon Valley and AI/ML researchers, whose concerns about military uses of AI have loomed large since a protest halted Google’s renewal of its Project Maven contract in 2018. While concerns about Silicon Valley’s opposition to the Department of Defense are overstated according to some survey research,37 other surveys of AI/ML professionals show that increasing the emphasis on safety is a high priority.38 A public commitment to safety will thus help the Department of Defense improve at attracting top STEM talent, including AI/ ML talent, increasing its ability to keep the American military ahead. One might argue that the United States should let others lead on AI, focusing instead on developing AI-enabled capabilities and not concerning itself with how other countries behave. But there is no substitute for American leadership and its ability to rally countries around the world to support shared standards. If promoting norms of responsible behavior with AI encourages other states to use military applications of AI in more responsible ways, it will create a more ethical and predictable security environment, likely benefiting the United States. Additionally, current international dialogue about military uses of AI focuses almost exclusively on lethal autonomous weapon systems (LAWS), the subject of a Group of Governmental Experts in the Convention on Certain Conventional Weapons.39 Currently, the international conversation has been largely been driven by NGOs such as the Campaign to Stop Killer Robots.40 While such conversations help bring attention to some of these issues, they oversimplify the risks and fixate on worst-case scenarios that are more likely outcomes of artificial general intelligence or human level machine intelligence rather than technology today. LAWS represent only a small fraction of the universe of potential issues surrounding military applications of AI. Broadening the international conversation about military uses of AI to incorporate the full scope of potential applications would generate better dialogue because it would include more of the real-world AI scenarios likely to confront militaries. Expanding the discussion would also allow states to pursue levels of control and regulation other than an all-or nothing ban and create a more calibrated and flexible range of approaches to different technologies with various levels and types of associated risks. Finally, one might argue that due to the military importance of integrating advances in AI, the United States should not do anything that could limit American behavior or flexibility with AI. However, the strategy above, in addition to decreasing the risk of unintentional conflict, would not constrain the United States in developing or integrating advances in AI for military purposes.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.