The fetishization of difference ironically collapses into a singular sameness, as the dominant culture’s white supremacy comes to regulate queerness into an ideal. This works to mystify racial and colonial violence, furthering marginalizing people of color.
Perez 5 [Hiram, Associate Professor of English at Vassar College, “You Can Have My Brown Body and Eat It, Too!” Social Text 23.3/4 (Fall/Winter 2005): 171-191]
The category "Latino," used as a racial descriptor rather than a political affiliation, is nearly as vague as "brown." Consider, for example, how easily "Latin" (or for that matter, "Spanish" and "Hispanic") may substitute for "Latino." However, most uses of "Latina/o" disregard the politics of that ambiguity, together with the differences that the category itself already collapses. Remarkably, queer theory understands the politics of difference as fundamental to its practice, yet it can participate in the circulation of categories like "Latin" without appreciating in the least its function within a complex web of identifications and desires. While the variations on the category "Latina/o" collapse innumerable differences, queer theorizing seems for the most part quite content to let that sameness alone. "Queer" needs to interrogate its own investments in sameness. Ironically, these investments deploy the rhetoric of difference precisely so that the presumed anti-identity of queer might dissimulate profiting by sameness. By this means, establishmentarian queer theory has colluded in rendering material and psychic violences of racialization unintelligible. I agree that communities are bound by fictions, but that does not diminish the violences enacted in constituting those communities. Queer theory has exchanged too hastily the politics of identity for the politics of difference. To combat oppression it is necessary to theorize how communities are bound by shared fantasies and desires, in other words, how they are bound at some level by sameness. This is especially crucial where sameness makes itself transparent, as it does with whiteness. Sometimes, people are not so different from one another. Queer theory, when it privileges difference over sameness absolutely, colludes with institutionalized racism in vanishing, hence retrenching, white privilege. It serves as the magician's assistant to whiteness's disappearing act. Hanson acknowledged that he had anticipated my response and had heard exactly the same protest before. Oddly, these repeated protests only invalidate one another. I should in fact feel shamed at this revelation of the commonplace nature of my thinking. Hanson's accusation constitutes a defensive posture, a way to dismiss criticism. However, I think the solace I received (much of it from white lesbian theorists) may similarly indicate a form of defensiveness. I absolutely experienced solidarity with white lesbian theorists at the conference, but there was also from some an expression of solace that I think masqueraded (and only just barely) as solidarity.231 am sure that reactions to the dispute between Hanson and me had to have been more complicated than the (apparent) polarization, the taking of sides that occurred after the final roundtable. But I also wonder if that] (apparent) polarization did not in fact need to happen to preserve the status quo, to further bind queer theory's white indivisibility. As I alternately inhabited the body of an intransigent and vulgar savage as well as that of a noble one (depending on where you sat), as I performed my brownness—and what choice did I have really, fated to my performance of the unsophisticated and banal—I understood the rupture I witnessed as one that needed to happen in order to fortify that white body of queer theory, to strengthen its immunity against foreign agents. I did experience genuine intellectual engagement with colleagues. Otherwise, I would not waste my energy formulating this critique. However, that engagement was subsumed by a reductive polarization; like the brown body (poor Mario's, Kiko's, my own, and, most important, the brown body missing in action), it was an obligatory sacrifice to the status quo of Gay Shame's queer theorizing. Although the ironies of Ellis Hanson's presentation were lost on me, I was keenly aware of another much crueler irony. The brown body in his schoolboy uniform, invited into the university classroom of a cosmopolitan gay male fantasy for a game of show and tell, remains simultaneously shut out of the university classroom. Increasingly, the brown body finds itself expelled from civil society—if not expelled outright from the nation. Seeing Kiko up on the screen, his dick hanging out of his khaki shorts, made the absence of gay men and lesbians of color at the conference all that much more pronounced. The brown body is variously sacrificed at the exigencies of white privilege and white desire. As peculiar as this may sound, I am not convinced that institutionalized forms of queer theory really care to investigate desire. An established group of queer theorists remain quite riled, understandably, about the normalization of queer. However, queer theory resists the critique of its own even more alarming normalizations. The dominant queer culture, like any dominant culture, demands assimilation. Queer theory does not want to be normalized, but neither does it want to be queered. Unruly subjects are expelled to its margins. This expulsion is telling. Establishmentarian queer theory, despite its oft-professed revulsion at mass culture assimilation, has also quite comfortably settled at the center or, rather, that comfortably furnished space just left of center. We would be deluded to think that queer theory is not invested in protecting the institutional structures that have accommodated it, including, most significantly, white patriarchal structures of knowledge. This does not call for abandoning the field but rather for greater vigilance, imagination, and accountability, as well as a reinvigorated inquiry into the complex trajectories of desire and identity.